ANALYSIS
Though Bhutan sided with India during the Doklam standoff, India must counter China’s bids to woo it
Recently in Kathmandu, Nepali journalists were saying that Prime Minister Narendra Modi would shortly visit Bhutan. Defence Minister Nirmala Sitharaman then stated in Parliament in a written reply to a question that the PLA has built infrastructure near a face-off site at Doklam. This was the first time helipads, military fortifications and PLA were deployed in North Doklam on Bhutanese land.
China has consistently maintained that Doklam is Chinese territory even as it offered Bhutan a package deal exchanging 269 sq km of territory for 89 sq km of Doklam, so critical is this piece of real estate. In this regard, China and Bhutan have had 24 rounds of border talks but have no diplomatic relations. Meanwhile, India and China made unusually conciliatory statements to reset relations.
India and Bhutan’s case at Doklam would have been optically much stronger had some soldiers of the 8000-strong Royal Bhutan Army, few located at nearby Jampheri post also joined Indian troops in jostling with PLA and stayed there. The mutual defence arrangement would have stood out starkly: so would have the linkage in the resolution of their respective border disputes with China.
On November 30, last year shortly after the Doklam disengagement, this newspaper covered the visit of the royals of Bhutan pictorially. The four pictures of K 5 (King 5) Jigme Khesar Namgyal Wangchuck and Princess Jetsum Pema Wangchuck meeting separately with President RN Kovind, Prime Minister Modi, Foreign Minister Sushma Swaraj and Defence Minister Nirmala Sitharaman are conspicuous by the spotlight on the accompanying one and half year-old heir apparent, the Crown Prince. India’s relations with the Wangchuck Royal family are vitally important especially after the fait accompli China attempted to present at Doklam aimed at de-coupling India and Bhutan. President Kovind conveyed ‘deep appreciation for the King of Bhutan’s personal involvement and guidance and support provided by Bhutan in addressing the recent situation in Doklam’.
Although Bhutan is a constitutional monarchy the King is the symbol of national unity and of its people. He is still the real power though the optics might belie this impression. Elections to Parliament are to be held later this year.
Bhutan and India have signed a Treaty of Perpetual Peace and Friendship in 1949 which was unilaterally changed by India in 2007 to give greater strategic autonomy to Bhutan in managing its external relations. Article 2 of the Treaty is the key and says both countries will cooperate closely on issues relating to national interest. Neither country will allow use of its territories harmful to the national security and interest of the other. What the Treaty does not say but is part of an understanding is that India will be responsible for the defence of Bhutan. The face-off at Doklam is inextricably linked to Article 2 of the Treaty. This understanding allows the deployment of an Indian military team in Ha in West Bhutan as well as deployment of Indian Army units earmarked to assist the RBA in the defence of Bhutan. The presence of Indian Army units in Bhutan has been both an irritant and an embarrassment for the government and gentry of Bhutan because the Defence Cooperation Agreement is under wraps.
The Indian Dantak border road building force in Bhutan since 1961 has provided connectivity and lost 100 men in the process. K4 (King 4) Jigme Singhye Wangchuck would openly say that he has put all his eggs in India’s basket and Bhutan is part of the Indian security system.
While India pushed for democracy and a constitutional monarchy in Nepal, in Bhutan K4 saw the writing on the wall, compressed the democratic process in five years and abdicated. Incidentally there is no defence minister in Bhutan as the King is responsible for the defence and security of the Kingdom. The closed Kingdom gradually opened up with Internet, TV, media and an increase of tourists. While Bhutan joined the UN in 1970 it established diplomatic relations with some 53 countries – none of the P5 including China. There was a minor political upheaval in 2012 on account of Prime Minister Jigme Thinley bypassing the King in attempting to establish diplomatic relations with China. For the first time there was mild public criticism of India and the question raised ‘why do we have to be guided by India’? More questions were asked during the Doklam crisis but it can be said with certainty that Bhutanese will never go against India and its national interest.
In his book, China’s India War: Collision Course on the Roof of the World, Bertil Lintner says Bhutan cannot antagonise China, its powerful northern neighbour. He writes that on 1 August 2017 during the Doklam crisis, Bhutan’s Ambassador to India Gen Vetsup Namgyel attended the 90th anniversary function of the PLA at the Chinese Embassy in New Delhi. It should be seen as a subtle signal of Bhutanese goodwill towards China.
Last month, Prime Minister Tshering Tobsay was the chief guest at a maiden global investor summit Advantage Assam which Modi inaugurated. Bhutan has opened its second consulate in India after Kolkata at Guwahati in sync with India’s Act East policy which focuses on India’s North East. Bhutan, like Nepal where monarchy has been dismantled is stuck between two powerful neighbours who have bitter rivalries and unsettled borders.
Bhutan will not go the Nepal way as long as the Wangchuck dynasty is around. The Chinese need to understand this before trying to rekindle Doklam by devious means. Sitharaman’s optimism about China’s good behaviour is misplaced as it is difficult to trust Xi Jinping’s New China. In fact, a visit by Prime Minister Modi to Bhutan shortly, as is being speculated in Kathmandu, would be very welcome post-Doklam.
The author is a retired Maj Gen and a defence and strategic affairs expert. Views are personal
DNA TV Show: Why Ajit Pawar distances himself from CM Yogi's slogan 'Batenge toh katenge'?
Meet Yashvardhan Dalal, Haryana batsman who scored 426 runs in an innings in CK Nayudu Trophy
Pakistani TikTok star Minahil Malik's dance video goes viral amid MMS leak controversy, watch
Gujarat: 38 injured in collision involving bus, two vehicles near Ambaji
MSMEs will get collateral free term loans scheme of upto Rs 100 crore through..., says FM Sitharaman
Rashmika, Samantha, Nayanthara, Tamannaah: Meet top South actresses
Will Hania Amir-Fahad Mustafa’s romantic drama return for Kabhi Main Kabhi Tum season 2?
New Maruti Dzire vs Old Maruti Dzire: Engine, specs, safety compared
Meet man, son of rickshaw puller, cracked UPSC in 1st attempt at 22, currently posted in...
AUS vs PAK Live Streaming: When and where to watch Australia vs Pakistan 3rd ODI live in India?
Tesla CEO Elon Musk becomes world's richest man, enters exclusive club of Rs...
Meet man, Elon Musk’s 'right-hand man', known for re-shaping Tesla, set to lead...
Calculated Risk: Exploring Iran's motives behind alleged Donald Trump assassination plot
Meet Jan Zelezny, Neeraj Chopra's new coach and current javelin throw world record holder
Do you wake up tired? Here's how to fix it
Canada ends fast-track visas for foreign students, know how will it affect Indians
'BJP-RSS want to destroy Constitution, we will keep protecting it': Rahul Gandhi in Jharkhand
'Jab Congress mazboot hogi, desh…' PM Modi's scathing attack on Aghadi bloc in Akola rally
Ajay Devgn says Ranveer Singh talks 'RUBBISH', Kareena Kapoor has all the...
Meet man, who used his pension money to build bridge for his village, he is from...
This was world's largest Eagle which went extinct 500 years ago, was found in...
Ratan Tata disliked this food, ate only this ice cream made by…
Gautam Gambhir to be sacked? Report indicates India coach could lose Test role if...
Bridal beauty routine: 6 essential skincare tips for a perfect wedding glow
IND vs SA: Sanju Samson goes past MS Dhoni, Rishabh Pant to achieve this massive T20I feat
CBSE Datesheet 2025: CBSE class 10, 12 timetables expected soon at cbse.gov.in
What is saree, petticoat cancer? From causes, symptoms to prevention, all you need to know
This is world's largest building 'shaped like chicken', has bonita huts, wave pool, is located in...
'More civilised than...': Viral video captures Japan's Nara deer bowing back at woman, WATCH
Nitin Chauhaan suicide case: Actor's wife breaks her silence, says he wasn't getting work due to...
Candyman star Tony Todd passes away at 69
Tesla shares skyrocket post Donald Trump's win, Elon Musk's wealth soars beyond USD 300 billion
'Agastya needs to...': Natasa Stankovic reveals how she co-parents son with ex-husband Hardik Pandya
Ananya Panday wears mom Bhavana Pandey's 21-yr-old suit by Rohit Bal, see VIRAL photos
Pakistan: 20 killed, 46 injured in explosion at Quetta railway station in Balochistan
PM Modi pays heartfelt tribute to Ratan Tata: 'Reopening of Taj Hotel after 26/11 attacks was...'
At UN, India lashes out at Pakistan for spreading 'falsehood' on J-K
Amitabh Bachchan calls grandson Agastya 'shaana', reveals how he used his name to get…
Grammy Awards 2025 Nominations: Beyonce leads, Taylor Swift follows closely; here's FULL list
Meet man, who is friends with world's richest people, ex-husband of Bollywood star, he is...
West Bengal: 3 coaches of Shalimar Secunderabad Express derail near Nalpur station
Delhi-NCR update: No relief from pollution as AQI continues to remain 'very poor'
Viral video: Little girl's adorable dance to 'Ghani Bawri' wins hearts online, watch
Meet woman, sub-inspector's daughter who cracked UPSC exam in first attempt, Tina Dabi is her...
IND vs SA: Sanju Samson equals Rohit Sharma's massive feat, becomes Indian batter with most...
IND vs SA: Sanju Samson's century guides India to 61-run win over South Africa, lead series 1-0
DNA TV Show: Loudspeaker controversy erupts ahead of Maharashtra Polls
Another masterstroke by Mukesh Ambani, set to challenge Haldiram, Britannia