ANALYSIS
By allowing the CA scheme to continue despite its failures, the state, central governments, and project investors are engaged in a conservation charade
Development projects have been a cause of numerous conflicts in India as land, on which these projects are situated, is key for the survival of rural and urban communities who are otherwise economically and socially marginalised. This is most true in the case of forest areas, which support over 300 million people.
As per India’s Forest Conservation Act, 1980, projects — be it industry, plantations, power or infrastructure — that require forested areas, need to undertake Compensatory Afforestation (CA). These forest plantations need to be raised over an equal amount of non-forest land or double the amount of degraded forest land, that is under the jurisdiction of the state forest departments. Land on which CA is to be done has to be earmarked before a final “forest clearance” approval can be granted to projects. However, securing land for CA is proving to be a great problem and government claims that, as a result, forest approvals and projects are being severely delayed. So, the environment ministry has a new plan — one that directs the states’ governments to create land banks for the purposes of CA.
On November 8, the ministry issued directions to all states to create land banks for the explicit purposes of raising CA plantations. The direction particularly focuses on areas classified as zudpi jungle/Chhote- Bade jhar ka jungle/jungle-jhari land/civil-soyam land. These are multi-use areas, defined as forests but could be under the jurisdiction of the revenue department, or historically managed by local communities. The proposal states that once these are demarcated and held in the land bank, they can be readily put to use to comply with CA requirements of projects granted with forest approvals. Once this is done, they will be recorded as Reserve Forests, thereby passing the ownership of these lands to the state forest departments. In addition to revenue lands, degraded forest land with crown density up to 40 per cent can also to be identified and locked in.
This is not new. In 2014, the DNA (October 6) reported that the environment ministry had asked all state governments to carry out such an exercise as the non-availability of land for CA was identified as a reason for holding up clearances by the Prime Minister’s Project Monitoring Group (PMG) and the TSR Subramanian committee for environment law reform. The Subramanian committee’s solution was to “identify degraded revenue land” and make it available for CA. State governments of Telangana and Odisha have had already supported this proposal to use “wastelands” and “mine voids” or exhausted mining pits for CA.
Mechanisms like CA create the illusion that it is easier to transform local ecology than rethink developmental models that are largely environmentally destructive. This proposal focuses on lands that have been historically maintained as village grazing lands and community forests to meet local bonafide needs. These include nistari forests, which provide fuel and fodder. Civil-soyam lands are revenue forests that have been managed by institutions like Van Panchayats in Uttarakhand. Converting these lands that are under creative forms of local management and conservation into land banks for CA would lead to conflicts, adding to the several that lie unresolved in local courts.
Secondly, the government’s move to compensate the loss of ‘land by land’ and loss of ‘trees by trees’, has been severely critiqued for compromising the rights of forest-dependent communities. Studies by the Community Forest Rights-Learning and Advocacy (CFR-LA) group show that plantations have already been initiated on lands being claimed under the 2006 Forest Rights Act (FRA), a legislation which upholds individual and community stewardship of forests. The government’s new proposal makes no mention of the FRA.
CA was officially designed as a way to check loss of forests, but in effect, it has done the opposite. Today forest approvals officially divert close to 35,000 hectares of forests annually to development projects. Approximately Rs 400 billion has been collected through the forest approval process and a part of this is to be used by state forest departments for CA. State agencies claim to regenerate lost forests but their implementation is fraught with insurmountable challenges. Forest-dependent communities have suffered forest diversions as their loss of place or home, ecologists have lamented the ecological damage of such schemes and the office of the Comptroller and Auditor General (CAG) has repeatedly pointed out to the mismanagement of funds for CA by state and central governments.
The law that is ostensible to protect forests from such projects has become a scheme for legitimising forest approvals involving vast sums of money. By allowing the CA scheme to continue despite its failures, the state, central governments, and project investors are engaged in a conservation charade.
The authors are with the CPR-Namati Environment Justice Program
Big move by Paytm, now users can make UPI payments in these foreign countries
'Chernobyl-like scene in Noida': Viral photo shows city's toxic sky
Manipur CM N Biren Singh breaks silence on fresh violence in state: 'Will not rest until...'
'Never going to...': Wipro chairman Rishad Premji says THIS big thing about work-life balance
Sarfaraz Khan's bizarre fielding leaves Virat Kohli, Rishabh Pant in splits, watch viral video
BIG move by Gautam Adani: Adani Group to invest Rs 2953844250000 to set up...
Meet richest footballer of 2024, not Cristiano Ronaldo, Lionel Messi, his net worth is…
Rs 200, Rs 500 in air! Guests climbs JCB to shower Rs 20 lakh at UP wedding procession, WATCH here
Pat Cummins's sarcastic reply to which Indian player can slot into Australia team, says...
Good news for Vaishno Devi pilgrims! New, high-tech service soon, cheaper than helicopter; details
'With Pakistan, the main issue...': India’s Ambassador at United Nations makes BIG statement
MoS Railways' big update on Kashmir to Delhi Vande Bharat Express, says PM Modi will...
How did Navsari's Dastur family get Tata surname? Know story behind Ratan Tata's family name
Upset over Donald Trump's win? You can move to THIS village offering USD 1 homes to Americans
Did Kriti Sanon just confirm her relationship with Kabir Bahia? Actress’ new post has fans convinced
Delhi air pollution: Government orders 50% of its employees to work from home
Shillong Teer Results TODAY November 20, 2024 Live Updates: Check lucky winning numbers
Delhi air pollution: Toxic smog chokes Delhi-NCR; AQI at 422
FPI inflows to bounce back India expected to attract USD 20-25 billion in FY25 Bank of Baroda
When AR Rahman talked about making adjustments after marrying Saira Banu: ‘I lost my…’
Bank Holiday November 2024: All banks to remain closed in THIS state today here's why
Bypolls 2024: 15 seats across Uttar Pradesh, Punjab, Kerala, Uttarakhand to vote today
Donald Trump attends launch of Elon Musk owned SpaceX’s Starship rocket in Texas
IAS officer's wife who 'eloped' with a gangster returns home; what happens next is bone-chilling
BGT: Jasprit Bumrah eyes Kapil Dev's elite record during India vs Australia Test series
Jharkhand Assembly Election 2024: Final phase of voting today, NDA, INDIA to fight for 38 seats
AR Rahman breaks silence on his separation from wife Saira Banu: 'Even the throne of God might...'
Meet India’s youngest female IAS officer, who cracked UPSC exam by self-study at 22, secured AIR...
'Kya baat hai': RJ Lucky mimics celebrities' voices to sing 'Mere Dhola 3.0', internet reacts, WATCH
India withdraws from Blind T20 World Cup in Pakistan due to...
‘Aiyyashi ka adda…’: Salman Khan’s farmhouse doesn’t belong to him but…
India beat Japan 2-0, to face China in final of Women's Asian Champions Trophy hockey
A gamble with radiation: The uncalculated risks of prolonged spaceflight
Roger Federer pens emotional tribute to Rafael Nadal ahead of his retirement
Dead man's eye goes missing at Patna hospital, doctors allege 'rats ate it off'
FIR against stand-up comic Yash Rathi for using derogatory words in his show at IIT Bhilai
How Zeenat Aman was instrumental in making Mithun Chakraborty a Bollywood hero to watch out for
Deepika Padukone, Ranveer Singh lease a new Mumbai apartment; monthly rent is whopping Rs...
Who is Mojtaba Khamenei, likely to take over as Iran's Supreme Leader?
Day before Maharashtra voting, BJP’s Vinod Tawde accused of distributing cash, poll body files case
When will ICC Champions Trophy 2025 schedule be announced? Know latest update here
BIG update on gold loans, RBI to soon bring this option to reduce lending gaps, it is...
Effective E-Commerce Promotion Strategies to Drive More Sales Revenue
Meet Shivraj, Aishwarya Rai's bodyguard, who earns more than CEOs, his whopping salary is...
Mahesh Babu subtly backs Nayanthara, Vignesh Shivan amid feud with Dhanush; here's how
Vladimir Putin to visit India says Russian government's spokesperson, official dates to be...
Vladimir Putin's BIG decision on nuclear weapons, threatens to use nukes against West if...
Virat Kohli’s bat being sold in Australia for THIS whopping price, watch video here
Apple quietly discontinues this popular iPhone accessory, once considered necessity, it is…