ANALYSIS
India's options in the Afghan matrix
In the rapidly changing quicksand of Afghanistan, New Delhi faces some stark choices. As many countries reach out to the Taliban, should it jump in and start exploring options for engagement? Or should it wait for the proposed peace processes to take their own course and deal with the situation as it evolves? Will the ‘wait and watch‘ policy be strategically suicidal? Or is it the best course as Afghanistan traverses a difficult process of transition (inteqal)?
Arrival of the Islamic State (IS-Khorasan or IS-K) in Afghanistan, with its local battles against Taliban for area domination, would be complication enough for the security situation. Added to this, though, is an intensification of competition for influence between regional countries, each operating through proxies in order to maintain position. Ironically, some of the attempts to neutralise the IS-K have now been directed at making the Taliban more amenable for negotiations, a throwback to the time of 'good boys versus the bad boys' distinction. Infighting may have weakened the Taliban leadership, but efforts to undermine the IS-K has emboldened it and strengthened its negotiating potential.
Simultaneously, Afghanistan is re-emerging as a theater of rivalry between the United States (U.S.) and Russia. On 14 April, the U.S. military targeted an IS cave complex in eastern Afghanistan's Nangarhar province with the 22,000-pound "mother of all bombs" (MOAB), the largest non-nuclear weapon ever used in combat. Conflicting reports of the impact of the measure notwithstanding, timing of the move was crucial.
It came a day before Russia was to host multi-nation talks on prospects for Afghan security and national reconciliation, the third such initiative since the December 2016 trilateral talks involving Russia, China, and Pakistan. Eleven countries – including Afghanistan, China, Iran, Pakistan, India, and former Soviet Central Asian states—met in Moscow. The U.S. skipped the talks, terming them a "unilateral Russian attempt to assert influence in the region.” Moscow in response said that it "could not comprehend" the U.S. action. A new chill in the bilateral relations of the Cold War rivals has set in. American military officials suspect Russia's Afghan peace diplomacy is aimed at “undermining NATO efforts."
The Russians and the Chinese cite the rise of the IS as a greater threat and are more amenable to talks with the ‘nationalistic’ Taliban as an effective counter. Reports from the field indicate that even Iran is not averse to engaging the Taliban and has established multiple contacts. Compared to the U.S. estimate of minimal IS strength (perhaps 1,000 combatants), the Russian estimate is 3,500.
Beyond the perceived IS threat, though, a ‘hedging strategy’ on Afghanistan appears to be the key reason for the renewed Russian and Chinese interest in the region. Should the insurgency succeed, either through military or political means, both countries desire to have in place the required links.
There are, however, real limits on Russia’s outreach and influence. Among the Afghans, the 1979-89 interlude has not been entirely forgotten. It is doubtful that Russia will be able to get the Taliban talking and, more importantly, get Pakistan to acquiesce. In this the U.S. itself failed to achieve, despite its enormous clout, in the 2016 Quadrilateral Coordination Group’s (QCG) process.
The Afghan perspective, however, is starkly different. Senior Afghan government officials were skeptical of Taliban’s presence in Moscow as they see it is as conveying legitimacy without demanding anything in return, particularly a reduction in fighting. To the Afghans in the security sector, the use of MOAB is not a solution for the long term. They contend that with better training, weapons and force modernisation, they can deal with the IS threat as well as address the larger threat of an emboldened Taliban .
Despite the moderate success of the Afghan National Army (ANA) in gaining some ground vis-a-vis the extremists, the force lacks appropriate training, equipment, air power support, assistance in strategic planning, risk assessment, engineering to help improve their capabilities. A proposed increase in the number of U.S. forces to train and assist will by itself not dramatically change the conditions on the ground, unless there is a change in the rules of engagement. The number of enduring structural flaws and gaps in the Afghan security forces could continue to hamper their battlefield effectiveness.
India hence finds itself in a challenging position. There has never been clarity in the desired ‘end-state’ that would result from a peace deal, even as a large number of international commentators and analysts continue to seek talks with the Taliban that include granting concessions like ceding territory with an asymmetric federalism arrangement. Interestingly, such propositions are acceptable neither to the Afghans nor the Taliban. To their mind, they provide no end-state superior to the ongoing 'war'.
In particular, the Afghans are not willing to buy into the desperate desires of the U.S. Neither are they open to Moscow's peace efforts, which they justifiably interpret as yet another attempt to impose a solution on them. Hence a dose of caution is in order while dealing with the murky waters of externally initiated peace processes. The fundamental question is why and with whom New Delhi should talk to within the Taliban.
Any unilateral attempt at ‘talking’ violates India's core objective of building a strong and stable Afghanistan that acts as a bulwark against the return of extremist forces. Even though there are dangers of being left out in the cold as other major powers are establishing Taliban contacts, a senior Indian diplomat has noted, "Even if we did nothing, Taliban when it mainstreams, will become friends of India and its hatred for Pakistan will come to the fore.”
Though there seems more than a tad wishful thinking in such assessment, were such a scenario to unfold, the central concern would be whether a mainstreamed Taliban could bring peace to Afghanistan. There remains concern that Pakistan would move forcefully to deal with a turncoat Taliban. A rebranded Taliban rump, would buy a few more years to fuel the conflict in Afghanistan.
A New Delhi rush to embrace the Taliban thus needs to be resisted. Instead, India should support the Afghan reintegration and reconciliation process and help build a transparent and inclusive process. Indigenous peacebuilding efforts, such as the High Peace Council, are the right place for India to support and strengthen Afghan efforts. In partnering with the U.S. under the new Trump administration, New Delhi will have to lay out the conditions for its cooperation, especially since there remains no clarity on the ‘end-state’ in Afghanistan.
The author is founder and president of Mantraya.org and has carried out field studies in Afghanistan since 2007. She can be reached at shanthie.dsouza@mantraya.org
Ajay Devgn's fans don't want Singham Again to become a blockbuster: 'Rohit Shetty jab tak hai...'
Types, Most Popular and Where to Buy Peptides for Bodybuilding
Luxury in the City of Light: SABO Boutique Hotel Brings Elegance to Varanasi’s Sacred Ghats
Virat Kohli, Babar Azam could play for same team as Afro-Asia Cup set for revival
Shaping the Future of Web Apps: Full Stack Developer’s Expertise in API Design and Cloud Deployment
The Role of Artificial Intelligence in Enhancing Software Performance and Security
Mastering Linux for Superior Sound
Amid divorce rumours of Abhishek Bachchan and Aishwarya Rai, Aaradhya praises mother in viral video
AI in Data Warehousing: Future Trends and Innovations
Mukesh Ambani's Reliance Jio IPO worth Rs 840960 crore in 2025: All you need to know
After India's 0-3 loss against New Zealand, Shah Rukh Khan calls Gautam Gambhir...
BIG revelation on Imane Khelif, Olympic gold medallist boxer's medical repot leaked, it confirms…
Meet man who built Rs 152000 crore company, donated Rs 100 crore, now set to lead US firm as...
Visa Uncertainty: Impact of US polls on global talent
Virat Kohli turns 36: IPL franchises send heartwarming birthday wishes to legendary India cricketer
Meet Sanjay Verma, the new DGP of Maharashtra who replaced Rashmi Shukla
Anushka Sharma shares FIRST photo of Akaay, Vamika to celebrate Virat Kohli’s birthday
CAT 2024 admit card to be out today at iimcat.ac.in; know release time, steps to download
Vikas Divyakirti UPSC Tips: Check strategy to crack IAS exam, aspirants should study for...
Video of Pakistani man putting hand into chained tiger's mouth goes viral, social media reacts
Shalini Passi reveals her husband's connection to Shah Rukh Khan's wife Gauri Khan, they were..
SC upholds validity of UP madrassa law, says it does not violate principle of secularism
US Presidential Elections 2024: What time do the polls close; when will the results be known?
Elon Musk shares controversial post on X amid US election results, video goes viral
Mukesh Ambani's company earned Rs 15393 crore last week, his net worth now stands at...
Chhath Puja 2024: Know about Kharna, Sandhya Arghya, Usha Arghya, date, timings and puja vidhi
Virat Kohli Birthday: Legendary batter turns 36, here's a look at his incredible milestones
When Ratan Tata met his first true love after 50 years, went for dinner together, know who she was
Samantha Ruth Prabhu hits back at trolls who body-shamed her: 'If you guys...'
Two fall prey to Narayana Murthy and Mukesh Ambani's deepfake videos, lose Rs 80 lakh: Report
North Korea fires multiple ballistic missiles toward sea ahead of US election
Deepika Padukone romances Hrithik Roshan in Bikini, looks sizzling hot in UNSEEN viral video
Chhath Puja 2024: Top 50 wishes, What'sApp messages, quotes to share with your loved ones
Meet Caroline Emmons, Ratan Tata's 'first love' with whom he couldn't marry due to...
Who is Rohan Jaitley, frontrunner to replace Jay Shah as BCCI secretary?
World’s most expensive human tooth is valued over Rs 3000000, it belonged to…
Viral video: Little girl’s adorable dance to Lisa Haydon’s 'Manali Trance' impresses internet, watch
SC to deliver its verdict on pleas against Allahabad HC order scrapping UP madrasa law today
DNA TV Show: Why Election Commission changed Assembly by-elections' dates
Days after imposing fine on Anil Ambani, Sebi now issues Rs 130 crore demand notices to...
Thailand announces indefinite visa-free entry for Indian travellers
Meet daughter of billionaire, who studied in UK, now works in Rs 32770 crore Indian company as...
MUDA case: Lokayukta police summon Karnataka CM Siddaramaiah for questioning on...
This city is 4000 years old, belongs to bronze age where 500 people lived, it is located in...
Kamala Harris has been the President of US before? Here's when and how
What is elimination inflammation diet that helped Vidya Balan lose weight?
Shah Rukh Khan feels breathless after quitting smoking: Know withdrawal symptoms, how to manage them
Zomato CEO Deepinder Goyal takes action on vendor for mislabelling mushrooms at Hyperpure warehouse
Mukesh Ambani's Reliance shares fell by 3%, loses Rs 50205 crore in one day due to...
IAF's MiG-29 crashes near Agra in Uttar Pradesh, pilot ejects safely, court of inquiry ordered