ANALYSIS
A bailout or a bail-in for a bankrupt bank is the only way to stave off huge repercussions for the economy
There’s never a dull moment in banking these days. The Financial Resolution and Deposit Insurance (FRDI) Bill 2017, now sent to a Parliamentary Committee, has been the latest source of much-alarmed commentary recently. At the heart of the alarm is the concept of “bail in” introduced in the bill. Typically, when in stress, banks around the world have been bailed out, ie, external funds (mostly taxpayer) have been used to rescue depositors and bond-holders. A bail-in is just the opposite, where depositor/bond-holder funds could be used to rescue a distressed bank.
In simple terms, it would mean conversion of the bailed-in deposit into equity. In the case of FRDI, the relevant bail-in clause has a provision of “cancelling a liability owed by a specified service provider” and “modifying or changing the form of a liability owed by a specified service provider”.
The principle of bail-in has been discussed in depth since the global financial crisis of 2008 when the US and Europe alone spent upwards of $1 trillion of taxpayer funds to bail-out stricken banks. The moral hazard question — using taxpayer money to bail-out private investors/depositors — is one that had to be answered. The Bank of International Settlements (BIS, the central bank of all central banks) and G20 formed the Financial Stability Board (FSB) in 2009 to draft rules to prevent an encore of such situations. Bail-in was part of the package of sweeping reforms suggested by BIS. Since then, a number of countries have implemented country-specific banking regulations around bail-ins. European Union’s Bank Recovery and Resolution Directive set out broad guidelines for rescuing distressed European banks.
Since then, Europe has used bail-ins a number of times to rescue banks. Starting with a small Danish bank (Amagerbanken), which went bankrupt in 2011, prompting Denmark’s Finansiel Stabilitet to force bailing in of high-value deposits and bonds. This was small compared to Cypriot banks in 2013, which saw massive bail-ins of high value ( >Euro 100,000) deposits and bonds to rescue banks reeling from Greek sovereign defaults. Even more recently, in 2016, Banco Popular, Spain’s sixth-largest bank, had certain categories of bonds bailed in en masse, even though depositors were spared.
In a nutshell, it is an idea whose time has not just come but has been tested live many times. What explains the “oh my God” reactions to FRDI then?
Prima facie, the rationale is deceptively intuitive — small depositors put their life’s savings into bank deposits. Corralling them as equity to rescue distressed banks is unfair and illogical. Politically, this has indeed been the case globally (and in India). Outside of cooperative banks, not a single depositor has lost any money in India, even when their banks went belly-up. In the recent past, instances of Global Trust Bank (GTB) and Bank of Rajasthan are illustrative — RBI organised bail-outs in each case to protect depositors. The issue is, all bailouts involve taxpayer funding, explicit or implicit. In the case of GTB, the same was implicit, via funding required in the Oriental Bank of Commerce that took GTB over. The recent Rs. 1.3 lakh crore recapitalisation programme of Public Sector Banks (PSB) is an instance of explicit taxpayer funding of bank bailouts. Back to moral hazards!
The bigger issue is simple — private sector banks, in good times, make profits for its shareholders. But in distress, they are expected to be bailed out by the state.
A classic case of privatisation of profits and nationalisation of losses. It is an untenable equation, precisely why bail-ins become crucial. Banks are not ordinary enterprises. Sans a bailout or a bail-in, a bankrupt bank will have massive repercussions on not just the financial system but also the larger economy. Lehman Brothers is an illustrative case — a medium-sized investment bank, its bankruptcy nearly brought the financial system to a collapse.
Above all, while Lehman did not have depositors, its senior unsecured bondholders (same seniority in capital structure as depositors) received nothing more than 10-15 cents on every dollar they had invested. Turn back to the Cypriot example, where bailed-in depositors/bondholders have retained at least 40-50 cents to every dollar they had invested. No two cases are the same, but they do provide illustrative lessons.
In a nutshell, the choice between a taxpayer-funded bailout and a depositor-funded bail-in isn’t that much of Hobson’s territory.
If bail-ins are considered sacrilege, the default option left is to nationalize banks altogether. That way, all profits would belong to taxpayers. And then, when there is a bank in distress, taxpayers pick up the rescue tab. The Indian banking system, with PSB having 70 per cent market share, have tackled the moral hazard quite elegantly. Unfortunately, some of those who cry loudest for privatisation of banks are also those that have expressed the greatest horror at the bail-in provisions of FRDI. Unfortunately, like in everything else in life, we cant have our cake and eat it too!
The author is Managing Partner of ASK Wealth Advisors. Views expressed are personal.
Chhattisgarh: 10 Maoists killed after encounter with security personnel in Sukma
Mukesh Ambani's SUPERHIT plan for Jio users, offers unlimited 5G access for 1 year for just Rs...
IND vs AUS 1st Test: KL Rahul's dismissal sparks DRS controversy in Perth Test
Dense fog, heavy rain predicted in these states till November 25; check here
Oreshnik Hypersonic Missile: Which nations are within its range?
Bihar teacher, principal reach school in drunken state; know what happened next
'I have faced a lot of...': Arjun Kapoor REVEALS his biggest fear amid break up with Malaika Arora
How millions of Indians may get affected due to US indictment of Gautam Adani in bribery case
Amid divorce rumours with Aishwarya Rai, Abhishek Bachchan says 'missing someone is okay but...'
After Bibles, watches and sneakers, Donald Trump is now selling autographed guitars, price is...
Delhi pollution: Air quality improves to ‘very poor’ category, AQI at...
Vladimir Putin's BIG threat, warns he could strike UK with new ballistic missile if...
Shillong Teer Results TODAY November 22, 2024 Live Updates: Check winning numbers here
Somebody misbehaved with Alia Bhatt on Highway sets then Imtiaz Ali had to...
Zomato CEO Deepinder Goyal reveals twist behind Rs 200000 job fee, closes application window
Days after Ratan Tata's demise, Tata Group's Rs 131000 crore company inks pact with ADB for...
WATCH: Woman makes Biryani with Parle-G biscuits, viral video fumes internet
Only train in India in which passengers can travel for FREE; check route, timings and more
'Justice for biryani': Parle-G biryani takes internet by storm, video goes viral
DNA TV Show: Why Gautam Adani charged with bribery and fraud in US
IND vs AUS: Records Virat Kohli can break during Border-Gavaskar Trophy
Diljit Dosanjh fans get angry over Ananya Panday's birthday post for her grandmother, here's why
Reddit suffers outage with ‘upstream connect error’ message, says 'currently investigating...'
Border-Gavaskar Trophy: How has Jasprit Bumrah fared in Tests in Australia?
Delhi records coldest night of the season, temp drops to...
Crossing the Line: Ukraine's Use of Storm Shadow Missiles and the Escalation of Conflict
When Malaika Arora talked about the controversial ‘instant pleasure’ ad, it was for…
This is the world’s most expensive shopping street, not Fifth Avenue, New Bond Street, it is...
Big setback for Gautam Adani, Kenya cancels Rs 6216 crore deal with Adani Group due to...
Viral video: Man’s jugaad to stay warm in winter will leave you SHOCKED, watch here
Hinduja Group firm gets key approval for acquisition of Anil Ambani's debt-ridden Reliance Capital
Viral video: Middle-Class man lives dream of having tea at Taj Hotel, netizens applauds
Shloka Mehta looks stunning in white floral kurta as she clicked with Akash Ambani, it costs Rs....
Who is Sagar Adani, Gautam Adani's nephew, accused of bribery, fraud charges in US?
PayPal down: Several users face issue while logging into accounts, say 'no one could...'
IND vs AUS: Jasprit Bumrah, Pat Cummins eye historic captaincy milestone in Perth Test
BGT 2024, Ind vs Aus: Can Shubhman Gill be the new Cheteshwar Pujara? Is he really ready?
The Ultimate Guide to Luxury Gifting: Discover Heirloom Pashmina by Pashmina.com
Effortless Relocations: The Perks Of Professional Removalists In Melbourne
Watch: Pakistan fan with 'Imran Khan' poster asked to leave Hobart stadium in Australia
International Criminal Court issues arrest warrant against Israeli PM Benjamin Netanyahu for...
What is demisexuality? Everything you need to know about this lesser-known sexual orientation
WATCH: World’s shortest woman meets world’s tallest woman, video goes viral
IND vs AUS 1st Test: Predicted playing XIs, Perth weather forecast and pitch report
IND vs AUS: When will Rohit Sharma join India squad? Check latest update
'Scam 2024': Diljit Dosanjh lookalike pranks people on Pune streets, video goes viral
Delhi Air Pollution: Centre announces staggered work timings for govt employees; check details
Mukesh Ambani's Reliance Jio loses nearly 80 lakh subscribers in just 30 days, BSNL adds...
IND vs AUS, 1st Test Dream11 prediction: Fantasy cricket tips for India vs Australia match
This country has most expensive passport in world, not US, UK, UAE, it costs Rs...
Amitabh Bachchan opens up on Aishwarya Rai-Abhishek Bachchan divorce rumours
Amid rising air pollution, Delhi-NCR's crematorium records cleanest air; check AQI here
Revolutionising Medical Imaging: Venudhar Rao Hajari’s impact on healthcare technology
Abhishek Gupta and Onevision Media: Scaling brands on social media
Video shows Korean girl eating jalebi for first time, her reaction to Indian sweet goes viral