ANALYSIS
PM took the risk, but the ministry’s making the Air India acquisition difficult for potential buyers
Animal spirits or death wish? Risk taking appetite or cautious decision making?
These are difficult choices to make and apply equally to governing polity as well as corporate captains. The case of Air India sale emphasises this painful choice. The line between the two is not just thin, but almost invisible. Tata Group’s acquisition of Anglo-Dutch steel company Corus in 2007 for about $12 billion and of Jaguar Land Rover in 2008 for $2.3 billion was seen as brave and courageous and even visionary. The Corus deal went south, while JLR is seen as a success today.
Was the Tata Group too brave or too foolhardy? Opinion will be divided.
Similarly, the Modi government decided to go ahead with GST and Aadhaar even though it was considered politically fraught by many observers. Some thought it was foolhardy politically, but brave economically.
This is the choice political and corporate leaders face when they go for big decisions. A similar situation has emerged in the sale of Air India. The government took a big political risk and expected private sector to take a business risk by acquiring it.
Prime Minister Narendra Modi invested much effort in the project to sell Air India and cut the losses that have been bleeding the tax payers. There is little or no justification politically or economically for tax payers to bear the burden of an inefficient, costly and poorly-managed airline when private entities can and have done a better job. The estimated accumulated debt of $8 billion looks even worse when one considers the additional estimated $1-billion loss every year.
These billions of dollars can be better spent on welfare and infrastructure in a country where both are sorely needed. From an external perspective, it appeared that Prime Minister Modi handed the task of managing the disinvestment to Jayant Sinha, who was moved from Ministry of Finance to Ministry of Civil Aviation in July 2016. Additional support to Sinha was offered by way of Cabinet Minister Suresh Prabhu, who is also reform oriented.
An alumni of Harvard Business School and a 25-year career in the corporate world, including as a partner in McKinsey, was perhaps the ideal choice to lead the toughest case of disinvestment that the government of India has attempted. As it happened, nobody turned up, even to express interest in acquiring Air India. Usually, even in the toughest of cases, bidders exit after having participated in the initial process. First step is submitting an expression of interest, then participating in the bidding. And then choosing to stay in the game or exiting, depending on the situation. In the case of Air India, nobody had the courage (or foolhardiness) to even express interest.
Here comes the aftermath of the failure where risk and courage are being debated. Government officials are privately saying that the industry does not have risk taking appetite. The question then goes back to the original one.
How much risk is tenable and how much is suicidal?
A couple of insights have emerged from conversations with people who were working closely with the government and potential bidders.
The numbers did not add up. The equity structure thought up by the government would scare even the most risk-taking entrepreneurs. The government said it will hold 24 per cent. An Indian private entity would hold a minimum of 51 per cent and the rest 25 per cent could be with foreign investors. Now, domestic companies don’t have the financial muscle to buy 51 per cent. And foreign buyers would not want to take the burden of change for just 25 per cent equity and lack of control. Partial government ownership doesn’t fly at all. This is an issue that Sinha would appreciate with his corporate background.
Attitude and approach. Those in the know were most disappointed by the approach and the attitude of some in the Civil Aviation Ministry. “They were not hearing the concerns of the potential bidders. It was almost as if the government was doing us a favour by offering Air India,” one of the insiders lamented.
In the end, it appeared that the goodwill and tenacity of Modi was wasted by the team tasked to manage the disinvestment. Modi took the political risk, but the people who prepared the deal made the deal even riskier for potential buyers.
The future for Air India looks bleak at the moment. Sinha and the Ministry of Civil Aviation will have to change their approach and see the sale from the perspective of the buyer. Entrepreneurs and corporate conglomerates can set up a new airline for much less than the cost of acquiring Air India. Though undoubtedly, the assets are flying slots, real estate and its market share. Without control and freedom to make it efficient, the terms have pushed the deal from being risky (acceptable) to being foolhardy (unacceptable) for potential buyers.
The Ministry of Civil Aviation needs to understand the difference between the two now.
The author is an economic analyst and author of Kranti Nation: India and The Fourth Industrial Revolution. Views are personal.
Delhi: All primary schools closed, classes shifted to online mode due to rising pollution levels
BIG trouble for Anil Ambani, criminal charges against his Rs 14422 crore company over...
Bhool Bhulaiyaa 3 producer calls Singham Again team 'unfair' after the box office win
From Play to Pay, Gaming Is Big Business And A Genuine Professional Prospect
Leasehold vs Freehold: Exploring Options for Expats and Investors in Dubai
Mukesh Ambani's Reliance, Disney complete Rs 70352 crore media merger, to be headed by...
Badshah lands in legal trouble, case registered against rapper for...
GRAP III imposed in Delhi: What is allowed, what is banned amid 'severe' air quality
'Throwing me in deep end': Ricky Ponting takes fresh dig at Gautam Gambhir over Virat Kohli remarks
Revolutionizing Inventory Management in the Cloud Era: Pradeep Kumar’s Strategic Innovations
Delhi: AAP's Mahesh Khichi elected mayor as party defeats BJP in MCD polls
Delhi Air Pollution: GRAP 3 to be imposed in national capital from Nov 15, strict ban on...
WATCH: Inside Rinku Singh's Rs 3.5 crore luxurious house with rooftop bar, private pool
Renowned Yoga Guru Sharath Jois passes away at 53 after suffering heart attack
NASA alert! Giant 'God Of Chaos' asteroid set for close approach to Earth, may trigger astroquakes
UPPSC protest BIG update: RO-ARO exam postponed, PCS prelims to be held in one day
This man earned more money than Mukesh Ambani and world's richest man Elon Musk in one day, he is...
'World's best....': Japan vlogger's reaction to Bengaluru airport goes viral
Sania Mirza named Sports Ambassador of THIS city, not Delhi, Hyderabad, Jaipur
Shloka Mehta turns heads in sleek white gown at Tira store launch, see pics
Amid Abhishek Bachchan and Aishwarya Rai divorce rumours, Jaya Bachchan surprises everyone with...
IND vs SA: Arshdeep Singh goes past Bhuvneshwar Kumar to become Indian pacer with most....
Mukesh Ambani, Isha Ambani’s luxury retail chain opens new store at...
PM Modi to receive Dominica’s highest national award for...
Shraddha Kapoor says people with big foreheads are…
'Busy making...': Kanhaiya Kumar sparks row with remarks on Devendra Fadnavis' wife; BJP hits back
'Full baarati vibes': Vietnamese man's epic 'nagin dance' steals show at Mumbai event
Tilak Varma credits THIS player for his century against South Africa, says 'He gave me...'
UPSC IFS Mains Admit Card 2024 to be released today at upsc.gov.in, check direct link to download
'Be prepared for...': Rupali Ganguly's stepdaughter Esha Verma REACTS to Rs 50 crore defamation case
Saudi, Iran: Cautious dance toward détente?
Anushka Sharma shares glimpse of Children’s Day special dish for daughter Vamika, son Akaay
Jaw-dropping! Man wraps massive green anaconda around his shoulders, internet says...
Donald Trump plans to end Russia-Ukraine war with THIS move, is expected to 'soon' appoint...
As pollution worsens in Delhi with AQI at 'severe' level, experts at COP29 urge India to...
SDM Assault Case: 60 people arrested in Rajasthan's Tonk
Veg thali cost more than non-veg thali in October, here's why
Land drug trafficking patterns in North-Eastern Region
Shillong Teer Result November 14, 2024: Know updates on lucky winning numbers
Mukesh Ambani's SUPERHIT offer for Jio users: Get unlimited validity for 84 days at just Rs...
Delhi air quality dips to 'severe' category as AQI nears dangerous...
Bigg Boss OTT-fame Bhojpuri actress Akshara Singh receives extortion threat
‘All I do is…’: After Arjun Kapoor confirms breakup with Malaika Arora, her cryptic video goes viral