ANALYSIS
The amended IBC essentially bars controlling shareholders (or promoters) of companies from bidding for their bankrupt companies that are being auctioned off via the NCLT (National Company Law Tribunal)-overseen process.
The recent changes to the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code (IBC) through an Ordinance has brought into stark relief an enduring cliché — “good politics is not good economics”. Or at least, that is the dominant narrative of the market and the financial nomenklatura (let’s call it the finklatura) that cheerleads the market. Prima facie, the rationale of the finklatura is unexceptionable.
The amended IBC essentially bars controlling shareholders (or promoters) of companies from bidding for their bankrupt companies that are being auctioned off via the NCLT (National Company Law Tribunal)-overseen process. In its original avatar, only those promoters deemed as “willful defaulters” were proscribed from bidding. Before this amendment came through, bidders in many of these cases before the NCLT included promoters (eg, Ruias for Essar Steel).
The politics of this is ostensibly simple — harsh measures against big business make for good optics and good messaging.
Economically, the finklatura asserts, it’s the other way round. Currently, there are 12 identified bankrupt companies that are before the NCLT for auctions that try to minimise the haircuts creditors (primarily banks) will need to take on the loans outstanding. In the short run, with promoters out of the process, bids are likely to turn less aggressive. There are multiple reasons for that. Most of the 12 companies are in steel, power and infrastructure sectors. To start with, all of these are industries where an enormous amount of local operating domain knowledge is critical to successful operations. Second, all 12 are large, complex enterprises — typically insiders have a lot better handle on the complexities of effective management. Put both factors together, and it is clear why existing promoters would have greater confidence in running these companies, and therefore bid more aggressively, compared to any other third-party bidder. The cherry on the cake —– structurally, all three are what economists call oligopolistic markets, i.e, industries with few operating players. In other words, in the best of times, there are relatively few viable bidders, and removing the promoter from the fray takes away a large chunk of active interest in the auction.
Less aggressive bids, naturally, would cause the banks to accept a price that demands a higher haircut on their loans (initial market estimates range from 10-20 per cent higher haircuts in bids). This, in turn, would mean banks requiring more capital to clean up their balance sheets. Given that the recently announced bank recapitalisation plan is fully taxpayer-funded, this would check all the wrong boxes — higher public debt, higher interest rates, potentially even an expansion of the recapitalisation required, and all their downstream adverse consequences. The economic impact, therefore, is clear, that we have (yet again) sacrificed economic gains at the altar of politics. Or is it?
Let us examine the economics of it. There has recently been a great deal of excitement around Richard Thaler’s Nudge Theory (primarily driven by, as is usual for arcane subjects, by the Economics Nobel Prize awarded to Professor Thaler).
Simply put, a Nudge is an act (or influence) that alters behaviour, while not precluding any options for the user. Now, a law is somewhat more than simply a nudge, it is perhaps more akin to a shove. From a signalling standpoint though, this shove makes for interesting potential outcomes. Fundamentally, a strong, almost unforgiving insolvency law sends a strong message to promoters across the board. The message fundamentally seeks to alter promoter behaviour. It does not preclude the option of promoters taking loans in their enterprises but puts the fear of God on ensuring prudence, analytical rigour and above all, integrity, in the utilization of loans.
India’s promoters don’t fall sick, only their companies do — has been an oft-quoted, and sadly, accurate description of Indian capitalism. The spectre of promoters of distressed companies remaining in a saddle, infusing no additional equity, even as banks take large haircuts on loans — militate against a very fundamental definitional tenet of the market economy. Under that tenet, creditors are senior to equity shareholders over assets of a company.
In other words, creditors need to be repaid in full before equity-holders can own any assets of a company that has defaulted on servicing its loans. Seldom has this been honoured in its letter and spirit in India. The new law and the ongoing resolution process should, hopefully, establish the seniority of the creditor in the capital structure, for perhaps the first time in India.
All policymaking is political. In this case, the good politics of the law makes for good economic principles too. Ben Graham, the legendary investor, described markets as being a voting machine in the short term (tallying up stocks that are popular and unpopular) and weighing machine in the long term (assessing the substance). In the case of the new Insolvency law, the nomenklatura representing the markets is seemingly in its voting phase. Ironically, the vote-driven government seems to have “weighed” it in a lot better!
The author is Managing Partner of ASK Wealth Advisors. Views expressed are personal.
Radhika Merchant changes name, shares thoughts on work and marriage
Renewable Energy: Power generation expert Shahroz Anjum leads way in solar optimisation
Meet man, Indian-origin VP, who uses vacations to determine if he's hired right people, he is...
Ricky Ponting hits back at Gautam Gambhir's 'minding own business' advice, says, 'He is…'
Decision between renting and owning: Krupa Goel's perspective on what's shaping choices today
SC pronounces verdict on 'bulldozer justice': 'Having a home is a longing that never fades...'
Archbishop of Canterbury resigns over Church of England sex abuse scandal
Why world's most valuable company Nvidia's CEO Jensen Huang doesn’t wear a watch, know here
Renowned Yoga guru Sharath Jois passes away at 53
Guru Nanak Jayanti 2024: Know date, time and significance of festival
DSP tracks down vegetable vendor after 14 years, reason will leave you surprised
Chennai Rain Alert: Heavy showers expected today, IMD issues warning to 11 districts
Ankur Warikoo shares details about his annual salary, reveals he earns Rs...
Donald Trump chooses Elon Musk to lead THIS new Department, it is...
Jharkhand Assembly Elections 2024 LIVE UPDATES: Voting for first phase begins
IND vs SA: Arshdeep Singh on verge of scripting history, need 8 wickets to achieve THIS massive feat
Bulldozer justice: SC to pronounce verdict today on pleas for guidelines on demolition of properties
IND vs SA, 3rd T20I: Predicted playing XIs, live streaming details, weather and pitch report
Russia plans to boost birth rate with 'Ministry of Sex', here's how
Jharkhand HC issues notice to MS Dhoni in business deal case, asks him to...
IND vs SA, 3rd T20I Dream11 prediction: Fantasy cricket tips for India vs South Africa match
Meet IAS officer, aka 'Collector Bro', who cracked UPSC exam in 2007, now suspended due to...
Here’s why Chunky Panday wouldn’t stay in Shah Rukh Khan’s house in London
Yash's Toxic in trouble? FIR filed against producers of KGF star's upcoming actioner for illegal...
Meet Dr Priti Challa, Kangana Ranaut film director Krish Jagarlamudi's second wife, she leads...
Yaariyan actor Himansh Kohli ties the knot with mystery girl in Delhi temple, first wedding pics out
‘Sometimes I wish I was more tough, more thick-skinned,’ says Aishwarya Rai in viral video
KL Rahul sweats hard in Perth nets ahead of BGT series, WATCH video here
Shahid Kapoor, wife Mira Kapoor rent out their Rs 580000000 luxury Mumbai apartment for Rs...
South Korean actor Song Jae-rim dies at 39 in Seoul apartment
Viral video: Thar SUV gets stuck on railway track after man tries to shoot reel, watch here
Elon Musk's new X post claims Putin must not be blamed for Russia-Ukraine war, instead names…
Fabulous Lives vs Bollywood Wives fame Shalini Passi reveals 'Mom used chilli powder in my...'
My experiences with dating apps
Zomato CEO Deepinder Goyal reveals how company got its name, says 'we wanted…'
Key Differences Between the Indian Stock Market and Global Indices
Stock prices vs company valuation: Is your stock worth it?
Navjot Singh Sidhu is back on Kapil Sharma's show after five years, but there's a twist
Mukesh Ambani set to invest Rs 65000 crore in THIS Indian state, it will be Reliance's biggest...
Mohammed Shami to return to competitive cricket; star pacer set to play for…
Makoons World School brings a new approach to K-12 education across India
Pakistan Cricket looking to take BIG step on Champions Trophy issue, planning to...
Did Isha Ambani lend Neetu Kapoor her Navratna necklace? Reddit users react
J-K: Gunfight underway between security forces and terrorists in Bandipora
Viral video shows women as 'live mannequins' in mall, sparks fury; WATCH
As Vistara bids goodbye, Air India-Vistara's first flight takes off from Mumbai to...
GATE 2025 Schedule: Exams to begin from February 1; Check full timetable here
CBSE announces BIG changes in Class 10,12 board exams 2025, know details here