INDIA
Has the time has come for army to get rid of caste-based regiments. 'Yes' is the answer if the army is to be made into a truly secular force. A DNA Special
NEW DELHI: He may have put a lid on the controversy surrounding the headcount of Muslims in the Indian armed forces, but Defence Minister Pranab Mukherjee has a bigger problem on his hands.
National Commission for Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes Chairman Suraj Bhan has told DNA in an interview that the Indian Army should make provision for the creation of Ambedkar regiments. "These regiments will be exclusively created from scheduled castes [SCs] and scheduled tribes [STs]," he says.
Bhan's demand might sound outrageous, but he has an interesting explanation.
"Why do we have army regiments named after various castes? Isn't that a blatant violation of our secular commitment as a nation? Isn't it wrong?" he asks. "I think all army regiments named after castes and communities should be renamed after national heroes. Why don't we have a Bhagat Singh regiment, a Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose regiment or a Rani Jhansi regiment?"
Bhan says his demand for an Ambedkar regiment should be placed in the context of "secularising" the armed forces. "Recruit SCs and STs into this Ambedkar regiment. Such dedicated recruitment will improve their representation in the army. Today, when recruitment rallies are held, there are many instances where officers do not accept SC/ST candidates."
When the Justice Rajindra Sachar committee requested data from the armed forces on the number of Muslims in its ranks, it kicked up a storm, leading political and military leaders to defend the secular character of the institution.
"The armed forces are professional, apolitical, secular and the most disciplined organisation the country has today," Mukherjee told the Rajya Sabha, after backing down on the issue of the Muslim headcount. But is it accurate to describe the Indian Army as truly secular? Can an organisation structured at least in part along communal lines be secular?
What does it mean when you hear of a Rajput, Sikh or Gurkha regiment of the army?
The regimental system on which the army is built reflects the caste divisions prevalent in the country. There are not many audible voices in the force talking against the system, but many admit that colonial concepts need to be dumped to make the army a truly secular force.
"The system came about after a lot of trial and experience," says Major General (retired) Ashok Mehta, a prolific writer on military matters who spent most of his service years with a Gurkha regiment (officers in particular regiments can be from any community).
"It is a good system; why try and tamper with it?" he asks. "The primary motive for a soldier to fight is his paltan ka izzat [platoon's honour], and that comes about from his sense of identity, belonging and honour." This is in keeping with a structure with a vast amount of traditions that most army people believe should not be tampered with.
But Mehta also feels that regimental reform is essential if the army is to evolve into a truly modern force. The Indian Navy and Air Force are good examples. "We recruit on the basis of merit, and there are no problems," says Indian Navy chief Admiral Arun Prakash.
Mehta says there have been attempts in the past to change the army into a truly secular force. "In the early 80s," he says, "some units of Maratha and Rajput regiments were reorganised. But it proved a complete failure."
An officer with the Sikh regiment told DNA that 12 of its units were reorganised in the wake of the limited revolt by Sikh soldiers following Operation Blue Star. "The experiment was given up in the late 90s," he says. There is an overriding desire across the army to retain the system, but that is easier said than done. A senior officer who supports reorganisation says, "Nobody wants to touch such holy cows, nobody wants to take responsibility for such far-reaching changes."
DNA TV Show: Why Gautam Adani charged with bribery and fraud in US
IND vs AUS: Records Virat Kohli can break during Border-Gavaskar Trophy
Diljit Dosanjh fans get angry over Ananya Panday's birthday post for her grandmother, here's why
Reddit suffers outage with ‘upstream connect error’ message, says 'currently investigating...'
Border-Gavaskar Trophy: How has Jasprit Bumrah fared in Tests in Australia?
Delhi records coldest night of the season, temp drops to...
Crossing the Line: Ukraine's Use of Storm Shadow Missiles and the Escalation of Conflict
When Malaika Arora talked about the controversial ‘instant pleasure’ ad, it was for…
This is the world’s most expensive shopping street, not Fifth Avenue, New Bond Street, it is...
Big setback for Gautam Adani, Kenya cancels Rs 6216 crore deal with Adani Group due to...
Viral video: Man’s jugaad to stay warm in winter will leave you SHOCKED, watch here
Hinduja Group firm gets key approval for acquisition of Anil Ambani's debt-ridden Reliance Capital
Viral video: Middle-Class man lives dream of having tea at Taj Hotel, netizens applauds
Shloka Mehta looks stunning in white floral kurta as she clicked with Akash Ambani, it costs Rs....
Who is Sagar Adani, Gautam Adani's nephew, accused of bribery, fraud charges in US?
IND vs AUS: Jasprit Bumrah, Pat Cummins eye historic captaincy milestone in Perth Test
PayPal down: Several users face issue while logging into accounts, say 'no one could...'
BGT 2024, Ind vs Aus: Can Shubhman Gill be the new Cheteshwar Pujara? Is he really ready?
The Ultimate Guide to Luxury Gifting: Discover Heirloom Pashmina by Pashmina.com
Effortless Relocations: The Perks Of Professional Removalists In Melbourne
Watch: Pakistan fan with 'Imran Khan' poster asked to leave Hobart stadium in Australia
International Criminal Court issues arrest warrant against Israeli PM Benjamin Netanyahu for...
What is demisexuality? Everything you need to know about this lesser-known sexual orientation
WATCH: World’s shortest woman meets world’s tallest woman, video goes viral
IND vs AUS 1st Test: Predicted playing XIs, Perth weather forecast and pitch report
IND vs AUS: When will Rohit Sharma join India squad? Check latest update
'Scam 2024': Diljit Dosanjh lookalike pranks people on Pune streets, video goes viral
Delhi Air Pollution: Centre announces staggered work timings for govt employees; check details
Mukesh Ambani's Reliance Jio loses nearly 80 lakh subscribers in just 30 days, BSNL adds...
IND vs AUS, 1st Test Dream11 prediction: Fantasy cricket tips for India vs Australia match
This country has most expensive passport in world, not US, UK, UAE, it costs Rs...
Amitabh Bachchan opens up on Aishwarya Rai-Abhishek Bachchan divorce rumours
Amid rising air pollution, Delhi-NCR's crematorium records cleanest air; check AQI here
Revolutionising Medical Imaging: Venudhar Rao Hajari’s impact on healthcare technology
Abhishek Gupta and Onevision Media: Scaling brands on social media
Video shows Korean girl eating jalebi for first time, her reaction to Indian sweet goes viral
Cristiano Ronaldo confirms THIS YouTube star as his next guest, says, 'Will break Internet'
Delhi Assembly Elections: AAP releases first list of 11 candidates for 2025 polls
Adani Group's FIRST REACTION after US indicts Gautam Adani in alleged bribery case
Instagram introduces new feature, know how to reset app's algorithm, change your feed
No mention of Aaradhya Bachchan in Amitabh Bachchan's post on birthdays, it happened recently
Oppo Find X8 and X8 Pro launched in India, check specifications, price, other details
Charges against Gautam Adani: BJP's scathing attack on Congress, questions timing of development
Jasprit Bumrah's BIG statement on taking up Perth test captaincy, says, 'tactically better...'
Blackout on breaks: Company imposes no-sick-leave policy until 2025
Drug-laden terrorists on India's western, northern frontiers
Mohammad Shami trolls Sanjay Manjrekar over IPL auction bid prediction, says, 'Baba ki...'
IND vs AUS Test: When and where to watch 1st match of Border-Gavaskar trophy, know details here
CAQM amends Grap Stages III, IV, enforces stricter measures in Delhi-NCR amid air pollution woes
Malayalam actor Meghanathan passes away at 60 after suffering from...
Adani Green Energy's FIRST reaction after US indicts Gautam Adani in alleged bribery case
'Keep me out of...': Pakistani Instagram star Mathira on MMS leak controversy
Delhi Air Pollution: AQI marginally improves from 'severe' to 'very poor' category
Meet actress who worked with Alia Bhatt, was asked to 'compromise', connected to Aishwarya Rai by..
Aishwarya Rai’s remark on Amitabh Bachchan’s ‘habits’ goes viral amid divorce rumours with Abhishek
Rekha's BOLD statement about Amitabh Bachchan goes viral, 'why hurt...'
Meet man, IITian who built Rs 5493 crore firm, has this Mukesh Ambani connection, he is from...
Shillong Teer Results TODAY November 21, 2024 Live Updates: Check winning numbers here
‘I didn’t have time to…’: When AR Rahman revealed having ‘agreement’ before marriage to Saira Banu
Amitabh Bachchan praises Abhishek Bachchan's new film, netizens ask 'kash ye Aishwarya...'
Viral video: Woman's sizzling belly dance to 'Namak' impresses internet, watch
Hardik Pandya banned, Mumbai Indians captain to miss first match of IPL 2025 due to...
Meet man who studied at IIM, IIT, then built Rs 1160000000 company, got inspired by…
Meet woman, who quit as dentist for UPSC exam, became IAS officer with AIR...