INDIA
The environmental clearance given on 24th June 2015 says “the project involves lifting 21 TMC water from Ujjani reservoir.” Except this this is nearly 40% of the Bhima river (a tributary of the Krishna) dam's live storage capacity (54 TMC).
What is the first thing that comes to mind when you think of an irrigation project? Water? Well, that doesn’t seem to be the case with the Union Union Ministry for Forests, Environment & Climate Change (MoEF). How else would it have cleared the the Rs 4,845 crore, 23.66 TMC (thousand million cubic feet) Krishna Marathwada Lift Irrigation Scheme (KMLIS) without water availability?
The environmental clearance given on 24th June 2015 says “the project involves lifting 21 TMC water from Ujjani reservoir.” Except this this is nearly 40% of the Bhima river (a tributary of the Krishna) dam's live storage capacity (54 TMC). “Where is the surplus water going to be available for any such diversion given how the Ujjani waters are already over-allocated?” asks Parineeta Dandekar of the South Asia Network for Dams, Rivers & People (SANDRP) which had highlighted the problems with this project to the MoEF on several occasions. “The project just does not have water availability certificate for 23.66 TMC water.” KMLIS is part of a bigger Krishna-Bhima stabilisation scheme planning to transfer 63 TMC water to Ujjani dam from Kolhapur which is 250 km away. “Only after this transfer could any water be diverted for the Krishna-Marathwada scheme,” underlines Dandekar. Incidentally, the state government has already acquired land through private negotiations, issued tenders and spent over Rs 400 crore on this project, which is littered with irregularities, absence of water availability, bad Environment Impact Analysis (EIA) and violations.
Prakash Jawdekar who heads the Union MoEF said, “The expert committee had several sittings to discuss the project which was finally given green clearance on June 24th after a lot of deliberation.” On water availability, he passed the buck to the state government. His Maharashtra counterpart, Ramdas Kadam, said, “Its not like the project has been inaugurated and there is no water. We have factored in all the issues and will come up with a solution.” He refused to spell out what this entailed. “This only confirms our worst fears about irrigation infrastructure being created more with tenders and contracts in mind than water,” observed Dandekar who likened this to what was happening in the DF government.
Also, neither the Centre nor the state have any clarity on the niggling problem of the Krishna Water Disputes Award Tribunal (KWDT). In a November 2013 verdict, the tribunal categorically rejected any water transfer for the Krishna Bhima Stabilisation Scheme saying this will lead to lesser water for Karnataka and Andhra Pradesh downstream where the Krishna flows after its 303 km run in Maharashtra.
Don't the state government and Jawdekar, who hails from Maharashtra, know this? The secretary of Water Resources ministry V V Gaikwad in a letter (dated July 7th, 2009) had admitted that Krishna Marathwada Scheme cannot be designed at 21 TMC (the capacity then proposed which has since been up-scaled) water availability from Ujjani, but has to be scaled down at 7 TMC because of tribunal considerations. Amazingly, even then, there was little clarity on the source for even this 7 TMC water!
Despite all this, Maharashtra went ahead and started work on the KMLIS for 23.66 TMC availability long before applying for environment clearance. This violation of the Environmental Protection Act & EIA notification of Sept 2006 was front-paged by this newspaper on August, 8, 2014.
SANDRP has raised several questions about the EIA report on the project by Science and Technology Park, University of Pune. “It not only leaves out all mention of where the 23.66 TMC water will come from, but is also quiet on the 1,068 hectares of land required for the scheme in Ashti, Khuntephal of Beed district. This, despite many project-affected people repeatedly writing to the MoEF,” points out Dandekar.
Dr Rajendra Jagdale of the Science and Technology Park, University of Pune defended the EIA. "We have diligently gone into every aspect of the project." Unwillling to accept that there is enough water in Ujjani he also rubbished claims of the extent and number of project affected. "We have not come across anything like this."
Incidentally the Dr Madhav Chitale Committee set up in December 2012 after the furore and outrage over escalation of costs of various irrigation projects had also singled out KMLIS as a “flawed project,” recommending: “Detailed further investigation of this project by an independent committee and also action against officials.”
NCP then, BJP now?
The erstwhile Democratic Front government and its Water Resources Minister Ajit Pawar of the NCP got flak from the BJP on what came to be called the dam scam, after the state economic survey in 2008 observed that despite spending Rs 70,000 crore on projects, a mere 0.1% per cent land had been brought under irrigation.
Several eyebrows were raised over how, as CM, the same Fadnavis, took a sharp U-turn at a meeting held on April 8, 2015 at Osmanabad – with principal secretary (water resources) Malini Shankar and MLAs Rana Jagjitsingh Patil, Madhukarrao Chavan, Basavraj Patil, Rahul Mote, Jaydutt Kshirsagar, Dnyanraj Choughule and Bhimrao Ghode - where he pushed a project mired in irregularities.
“It was based on non-existent water availability and the environment impact analysis (EIA) report was quite shoddily done,” a senior bureaucrat of the Water Resources Department present at the meeting had then told dna. “Fadnavis had promised shifting of focus from non-performing, large dams and lift irrigation projects to small-scale sustainable projects and schemes.”
Meet IAS officer, who is nemesis of criminals, cracked UPSC exam with AIR 36, she is...
SC to pronounce verdict on Aligarh Muslim University's minority status today
Happy Chhath Puja 2024: Top 50 wishes, What'sApp messages, quotes to share with your loved ones
Viral video: Woman's sensual dance to 'namak' sets internet on fire, watch
SA vs IND, 1st T20I: Predicted playing XIs, live streaming details, weather and pitch report
SA vs IND, 1st T20I Dream11 prediction: Fantasy cricket tips for South Africa vs India match
Meet man who is set to lead Truecaller, not from IIT, IIM, earlier served Vice President of...
DNA TV Show: Why Pakistan worried about a Donald Trump presidency
Pakistan bow down as THIS country set to host India’s Champions Trophy 2025 matches
Amid heavy pollution in Delhi, these 12 Indian cities enjoy fresh, clean air
Bigg Boss 18: Vivian Dsena confides in Kashish Kapoor about his stepdaughters, talks about his...
After S Jaishankar's conference, India slams Canada for action against Australian news channel
Sidhu Moosewala's parents share NEW pic of his baby brother, netizens say 'so cute'
‘It definitely does a lot of good to my ego’: Aishwarya Rai gets candid in film promotion interview
Ignored for Australia Tests, India star slams sensational Ranji Trophy double ton
Interviewer asks Aishwarya Rai ‘how do you look so fab’, she says…
How Biden’s Lame-Duck Period Could Influence Policy Decisions After Choosing Not to Run in 2024
Watch: Viral video shows heated argument between passengers in Delhi metro
Virat Kohli's 'new chapter for me' post ahead of Border-Gavaskar Trophy sends internet into frenzy
Mukesh Ambani, India's richest man, donated over Rs 400 crore in one year, Gautam Adani gave Rs...
Delhi: Air pollution in national capital spike during Chhath Puja, AQI reaches 'severe' level
AUS vs PAK Live Streaming: When and where to watch Australia vs Pakistan 2nd ODI live in India?
'I gain weight as body...' Arjun Kapoor reveals being diagnosed with Hashimoto’s disease
Stark Visas: The Best Immigration Consultant in Delhi Sets Immigration Dreams High in Ahmedabad
KREEVA targets top 1% elite for its ultra-luxury homes in Delhi-NCR’s prime locations
Tata Group acquires another company for over Rs 18 crore days after Noel Tata joins board
WPL 2025 Retentions: Full list of players retained and released by all 5 franchises
ED raids main vendors of Amazon, Flipkart across multiple cities, including Delhi, Mumbai due to...
Anil Ambani suffers major setback, his company banned for 3 years due to...
Meet woman, a cuddler, professional hugger, earns Rs 7400 in 1 hour, she is...
Meet teen who started working from garage, now set to make Rs 25 crore at just 16 from...
Viral video: Slum children recreate Sabyasachi bridal wear, designer reacts; WATCH
Missing Home on Chhath Puja: Yearning and significance behind Bihar’s holy festival
Chhath Puja 2024 Day 4: Usha Arghya date, timings of sunrise, puja rituals, significance and more
Ricky Ponting wants Babar Azam to follow Virat Kohli's footsteps for THIS reason
Elon Musk's net worth surges by Rs 2193295096200 in a day after...
Meet India's richest female YouTuber, left teaching job, has Rs 43 crore net worth, now works as...
This fruit is called non-vegetarian, it is...
Meet man who was India's biggest con artist, he sold Taj Mahal, Rashtrapati Bhawan, Red Fort...
Nita Ambani reveals husband Mukesh Ambani follows a strict diet, here's what he eats
'Tu jhuti woh makkar': Influencer accuses 10-year-old of groping her; narrates ordeal in viral video
Richa Chadha, Ali Fazal name their daughter, Zuneyra Ida Fazal; it means...
After returning as President, what will happen to cases against Donald Trump? Know here
25-year-old turns temple thief, steals ornaments worth Rs 78 lakh for...
Why Mahindra XUV700 is perfect for road trips and off-road adventures
Mahindra Scorpio N: A legacy of toughness with a modern twist
'Capable of loving more women': Kamal Haasan's bold take on marriage and relationships goes viral
How reaction time and speed tests can give gamers a competitive edge
This is world’s most polluted city with AQI of 1165, it’s just 409 kms away from Delhi
Blow to Gautam Adani as his company's shares fell 7% due to...
Pune Porsche crash: Father of teen driver's friend surrenders before court