INDIA
For the fifth day in succession, a united opposition led by Congress created turmoil in Rajya Sabha demanding a reply from Prime Minister Narendra Modi on forcible religious conversions, leading to two adjournments before lunch.
Leader of the Opposition Ghulam Nabi Azad made a forceful demand that Modi should reply to a debate on the controversy but the government's stand was unchanged that it is ready for a discussion and the concerned minister will reply. This led to slogan shouting opposition members trooping into the Well, forcing Deputy Chairman P J Kurien to adjourn the proceedings till noon.
Azad, who had been away from the House for most part of the session to campaign for Jammu and Kashmir polls, said religious conversion by force or allurement of money, ration card or BPL card is not only unconstitutional but also unlawful and criminal offence.
He said the reception Prime Minister receives when he goes abroad is because he represents the 125-crore multi-religion country. In past when there was doubts that he did not represent all sections, he was not welcome in foreign land with some countries imposing restrictions, he said. Modi during general elections asked for votes for himself and not even for his party - BJP, he said.
Prime Minister won the mandate on the plea that he will be answerable if the people of the country empower him, Azad said. "Unhone dard diya hai, toh dawa bhi woh hi denge (he gave pain, now he will give remedy)," he said, adding Modi should give confidence to Hindus, Muslims, Sikhs, Christians and others that they are "not just safe in the country but also their religion is safe." He said the Opposition is not asking Modi to stand on the street and apologise but is only asking him to learn from leaders like Atal Bihari Vajpayee and respect the House, come to Rajya Sabha and listen to the debate and reply to it.
Azad said the Prime Minister should come to Parliament and allay people's apprehensions. "The Prime Minister and BJP will benefit most as his silence is being seen as his and his party's support (to religious conversations)."
"Instill confidence that this government will protect people from all religions," he said. Environment Minister Prakash Javadekar said Azad can say whatever he wants to during debate on the issue, a resolution for which was accepted on Thursday. "I will start the debate if he (Modi) comes and replies," Azad insisted.
Minister of State for Parliamentary Affairs Mukhtar Abbas Naqvi said government is ready for a debate and it should be taken up without conditions. Congress and other Opposition members then trooped into the Well shouting slogans demanding that Prime Minister should come to the House. As members from treasury benches shouted to counter the opposition, Kurien adjourned the House till noon.
Earlier, on a point of order raised by Naresh Agarwal (SP), Kurien said the motion for discussion was moved under rule 267 and allowed. The rule, he said, does not stipulate for a particular minister or Prime Minister coming and replying. "Government is bound to listen to the discussion and concerned minister is to reply to it," Kurien said. Agarwal said rule 259 gives all rights to the Chair, including asking the Prime Minister to reply.
V Hanumantha Rao (Congress) said Parliamentary Affairs Minister M Venkaiah Naidu had at a press conference charged him with using unparliamentary language against the Prime Minister while protesting on the issue in the House earlier this week. "I never used any unparliamentary language against Prime Minister... please see the records and put things straight. It is a question of my character," he said.
"I have got respect for Prime Minister and I did not make any such remark. You can see the record," he said. Anand Sharma (Congress) said what Naidu had said was serious and the Chair should protect the member.
Naqvi then said, "No one has said anything... regarding you, no one has said anything inside or outside the House."
Satyavrat Chaturvedi (Congress) said Kurien had promised on Thursday to examine the records and come back to the House. Kurien said he cannot do anything about what Naidu had stated outside the House. "I am at loss to understand the position. If Naidu had said something against him inside the House, I can expunge it... if something has been said outside, what can I do? He (Rao) can reply outside," he said.
Sitaram Yechury (CPI-M) wanted Naidu to come to the House and clarify on the issue. Kurien said Rao should give notice with all documents. "It will be examined and proceeded according to the law." Similar scenes were seen when the House reassembled for the Question Hour with Opposition demanding presence of the Prime Minister during discussion on the "secular fabric of the country" and give reply.
Chairman Hamid Ansari's plea for having the Question Hour "for a change" went unheeded as P Rajeev (CPI-M) said the nature of discussion warranted Prime Minister's presence and a reply from him only. Derek O'Brien (Trinamool) asked as to why the Prime Minister was "shying away from the House; he should be in the House."
D Raja (CPI) also wondered, "What is preventing the Prime Minister to come to the House and reply?" The Chair tried to pacify the Opposition saying that as per the rule, if the reply to the discussion by the minister concerned was not satisfactory, only then Prime Minister could intervene. "Why are we jumping to that stage?" he asked. Anand Sharma (Cong) said the request of the Opposition was rejected by the government "arrogantly".
To this Naqvi said the Opposition cannot insist as to who would reply. As the din continued, Ansari adjourned the House till 2:30 PM.
Watch: Former CSK star gets hit for 6 sixes in an over against England during Hong Kong Sixes
'Makes no sense': Ex-India star slams Rohit Sharma, Gautam Gambhir for absurd Sarfaraz Khan decision
World's richest man Elon Musk faces lawsuit from Ex-Twitter CEO Parag Agrawal for...
Security forces kill 2 terrorists, including a foreign national in Jammu and Kashmir
WWE Crown Jewel 2024: Full match card, timing, live streaming details - All you need to know
'Absurd and baseless': India dismisses Canadian minister's allegations against Amit Shah
IND vs NZ: Virat Kohli scripts history in Mumbai Test, becomes first player in world to...
This 51-year-old woman leaves husband to marry 30-year-old Indian security guard
Mukesh Ambani's best plan for Jio users, 200GB data, 90 days of unlimited calls at just Rs...
'Thanks for...': Abhishek Bachchan's viral statement amid divorce rumours with Aishwarya Rai
Jammu and Kashmir: 2 terrorists killed in encounter with security forces in Anantnag
21-Day Mars, Moon simulation in Ladakh
Prashant Kishor's fee for advising in one election will leave you shocked, it is Rs...
Dua Padukone Singh: Here's how Deepika Padukone, Ranveer Singh named their baby girl
Another BIG move by Mukesh Ambani, set to provide some help for debt-ridden Ghana as Reliance Jio...
J-K: Gun battle breaks out between security forces and terrorists in Srinagar's Khanyar
Noel Tata takes BIG decision at TCS after Ratan Tata's death, plans to hire...
'Will chop them up...': Mithun Chakraborty hits out at TMC’s Humayun Kabir at Kolkata rally
Delhi Air Pollution: Delhi-NCR AQI turns ‘very poor’ as city wakes up to toxic smog post-Diwali
Gautam Adani's next BIG step: Adani Power stops Bangladesh’s power supply due to...
Indian troops start patrolling Demchok sector in eastern Ladakh following India-China disengagement
Amy Jackson announces first pregnancy with husband Ed Westwick, flaunts baby bump in adorable pics
In THIS Indian village, families live with cobras, the reason is...
Hardik Pandya flaunts his special 'World Champion' ring after being retained by MI, video goes viral
Happy Govardhan Puja 2024: Top 50 WhatsApp wishes, messages, quotes for loved ones
Despite massive Diwali opening, is Singham Again paying the price for banking on huge star cast?
Shah Rukh Khan's heartfelt gesture towards jewellery store staff wins internet, watch
DNA TV Show: Public calls out celebrities’ hypocrisy on Diwali pollution
Fashion designer Rohit Bal dies at 63: Last year, he was on ventilator for heart ailments
BCCI scraps India's intra squad warm-up game ahead of Border-Gavaskar Trophy, reason revealed
Legendary fashion designer Rohit Bal dies at 63 after prolonged illness
Another terrorist attack in J-K, militants shoot two non-locals in Budgam
Meet Anish Sarkar, world's youngest FIDE-rated chess player at 3 years
Bigg Boss 18: These two wild cards to enter Salman Khan's show, get into heated argument on stage
Fact check: Did Abhishek Bahchan tie knot with Nimrat Kaur amid divorce rumours with Aishwarya Rai?
Govardhan Puja 2024: History, significance, Puja timings; why it is celebrated after Diwali?
Aishwarya Rai Bachchan Birthday: Kajol pens heartfelt wishes for actress, calls her…
Dhirubhai Ambani played matchmaker for Mukesh Ambani and Nita Ambani, he did...
Amid Diwali festivities, UPI sets new record in October with transactions over…
PM Modi's BIG attack on Congress: 'Making unreal promises is easy but...'
Singham Again box office collection day 1: Ajay Devgn film beats Kartik Aaryan-starrer, earns Rs...
'Always fun to...': Google CEO Sundar Pichai shares why Diwali is his 'favourite time of the year'
Why Rishabh Pant and Delhi Capitals parted ways ahead of IPL 2025 auction? Report makes huge claim
'Bhool Bhulaiyaa 3', 'Singham Again' banned in Saudi Arabia; know why
Delhi Government announces public holiday for THIS festival, find details here
Despite festive season, Rs 7.90 lakh cars lying unsold, it is worth...; here's the reason
'CSK Ne Chaal Chal Di': Ex-India star takes humourous dig at franchise’s decision on MS Dhoni