BUSINESS
The CPM general secretary says it is a "popular misconception" that the party, which lends outside support to the UPA govt, is a party in power.
NEW DELHI: A wide gulf separates the reformist section of the UPA government from its main political prop, the Left parties, who are supporting it from the outside. Whether it is disinvestment, foreign investment in retail or labour law flexibility for the IT sector and in special economic zones, the CPM - the main party on the Left - has a different take on it.
Using the Common Minimum Programme (CMP) as the touchstone, the CPM's line on reforms centres around a strict interpretation of the letter and spirit of the document. In an exclusive interview to DNA (See page 25), party general secretary Prakash Karat said the party opposed any disinvestment in Bhel because it was not part of the CMP.
"The CMP says the UPA will retain existing Navratna companies in the public sector while these companies can raise resources in the capital market. What does this mean? This means the government will not disinvest. (But) they can raise capital for their purposes."
The silver lining in this view is that Bhel can raise capital from the market for its own business requirements, even though government can't offload its shares to raise money for budgetary needs. But the UPA government may find it difficult to sell shares even in non-Navratna companies, since the CPM does not accept that stakes can be reduced to 51% from 80-100% in public sector companies.
Says Karat: "They say it's not privatisation when the government holds at least 51%. We say it is creeping privatisation. We will not accept it."
Then how can the government raise resources for even social sector projects? The government has already announced proposals to finance the National Investment Fund and various social sector schemes from the proceeds of disinvestment. But in the CPM's view, the questions of resource-raising and disinvestment should not be mixed up. It is prepared to discuss them only separately.
In other words, the chances of disinvestment of non-Navratna companies are as bleak as ever. Not only disinvestment, the government faces tough opposition to its reform proposals in many other areas as well. The Left is getting ready to place alternative proposals as a counter. It has either already submitted notes, or is about to do so, on several individual areas of economic policy, including FDI in retail trade, WTO negotiations and labour law reforms.
What could these alternate proposals be? Robbing Peter to pay Paul has long been the Left's favourite resource-raising model, and in this vein it is likely to propose ideas like hiking tax rates for companies and people in higher income brackets, apart from implementing more effective measures to unearth black money.
The centre is also cutting no ice with the Left by citing the economic reforms now underway in West Bengal under chief minister Buddhadeb Bhattacharjee. As Karat sees it, the Left Front in West Bengal as a constitutionally-elected body may be bound to implement all-India policies whether it likes it or not, but the CPM as a political party is under no such obligation.
In sum, the return of the Left parties to the coordination committee of the UPA government after a hiatus of four months does not signal any smoothening of the path for economic reforms.
"It is a myth that we are involved in day-to-day policy-making or indulge in administrative interference", said CPM general secretary Prakash Karat in a wide-ranging interview to DNA.
The mighty and powerful - from Mukesh Ambani to LN Mittal - have been making a beeline to Ajay Bhavan, the party's GHQ in Delhi, but the party chief calls it a "popular misconception" that CPM, which lends crucial outside support to the UPA government at the Centre, is a party in power.
Karat explains his party's stand on the gamut of economic policies and on the apparent dichotomy within the party on foreign direct investment (FDI) and workers' rights in the IT sector.
After a gap of four months, the Left parties recently rejoined the UPA-Left coordination committee on government's assurance that it was putting the Bhel disinvestments on hold. Is there also a softening on your part? Are you now willing to consider disinvestment in those profit-making PSUs that are not Navratnas?
What was the Bhel issue? There is a separate mention of Navratnas in the CMP (common minimum programme). The CMP says the UPA will retain existing Navratna companies in the public sector while these companies can raise resources in the capital market. What does this mean? This means the government will not disinvest. They can raise capital for their purposes.
This applies to Bhel and other Navratna companies. We had differences on this and we didn't participate in the coordination committee. But when they said they will neither disinvest in Bhel nor any other Navratna company, we rejoined the committee.
Did the letter (from UPA chairperson Sonia Gandhi) say that clearly for all Navratna companies or just for Bhel?
No. They told us during the talks. The Prime Minister told us three or four times that they will not touch any Navratna company. That settled the issue about Navratna PSUs.
What about other profit-making PSUs?
Now, the CMP says, generally profit-making PSUs will not be privatised. The provision here is privatisation. That is what the argument is about. They say they can bring down the government's holdings in these PSUs to 51% from 80% or 100% now. We do not agree. They say it's not privatisation when the government holds at least 51%. We say it is creeping privatisation.
We will not accept it. The question then is how do we raise resources for the social sector schemes or for the National Investment Fund (NIF). Before we rejoined the coordination committee, we discussed the matter (with the government). We said we will discuss the issue of mobilisation of resources separately. They will give their proposals and we will give our proposals. We can discuss that.
Does it mean that you do not agree to disinvestment even in non-Navratna PSUs?
We have said we should discuss this in the coordination committee in the overall context of how to raise resources? If they propose disinvestment in some PSUs for raising resources, we may also have some proposals for raising resources through other means. So let's discuss that.
Could you explain the dichotomy in your party. In West Bengal, the party seems to follow one line and at the Centre it takes an opposite line.
There is no dichotomy on Bhel. There is no Bhel in West Bengal. It's not just about PSU disinvestment but about the whole range of economic policies that your party is perceived to be following two different approaches.
There is a very superficial view. Take FDI. The party congress had adopted a document. The party is bound by it whether in West Bengal or in Delhi. The party is in the government in West Bengal. As a government, it will have to implement policies decided by the central government. So they have a different sphere, a different role. It's not now, but since 1967, when we formed the United Front government in West Bengal.
We have had to implement many decisions taken by the central government though we did not agree with those. The state government is bound to do certain things under the Constitution. When it comes to an all-India policy, for the country as a whole, the state government cannot say it won't implement it.
We may not agree with it. We may fight it even after it has become an all-India policy. As a party, things are different. We are there as a party in West Bengal but we are also in the government there. Why only West Bengal, it applies to Kerala and Tripura as well. We may implement certain things as a government that we are not advocating as a party.
So you will implement in West Bengal what you oppose in Delhi?
We may like to do things in a different way, but we can't do that as a state government. It can be done only when all-India policy can be changed.
But at the Centre also, you are seen as a party in power?
That's a popular misconception. We are not in power and they do not consult us on basic policy matters. It is only when policy has already been made that we raise the matter. And we do not expect the government to be run on that basis. It will not be fair for us, who are not in government, to expect the government to be looking behind its back all the time and asking us what should be done.
We don't expect that. We expect the government to broadly adhere to this (points to a copy of CMP document). When a new issue (not dealt with in CMP) comes up, not only economic but also political, it would be nice if the government consults us. They can do this in two ways: one, inside Parliament, and the other, outside Parliament. That's all. Beyond that it is a myth that we are involved in day-to-day policy-making or indulge in administrative interference. (To be concluded)
Karisma Kapoor reveals this actress on Hum Saath Saath Hain set would sit alone, eat only…
Ratan Tata's neighbours share stories of everyday encounters with him, say he was...
Viral video: Internet can't stop gushing over this little girl's breathtaking dance, WATCH
THIS Gautam Adani company's shares are in spotlight as it raises Rs 42000000000 in...
Delhi-NCR's air quality turns 'poor', AQI reaches...
India-Canada row: ‘No action on request to arrest Lawrence Bishnoi gang members’, says MEA
Cyclone Alert: Odisha coast likely to face cyclone next week, IMD issues alert
Noida school horror: Victim's mother reveals 'my daughter was told...'
‘India and Pakistan should bury the past’: Nawaz Sharif after S Jaishankar's visit
'Dil to bachcha hai ji': Rahul Gandhi's heartfelt interaction with kids, WATCH viral video
JEE Main 2025: NTA releases important notice on JEE Main exam pattern
Blow to Mukesh Ambani as Reliance Jio loses 10.9 million subscribers due to...
Joe Biden reacts to Hamas Chief Yahya Sinwar's killing, says 'that obstacle no longer exists but...'
Viral video: Desi girl's sizzling dance to 'Aaj Ki Raat' impresses internet, watch
Watch: Heartwarming video of girl treating slippers like a baby goes viral
Earn Rs 250000000 through THIS NASA challenge: Here’s how you can participate
DNA TV Show: Bahraich murder accused shot in police encounter near Nepal border; 5 held
Good news for Narayana Murthy, Infosys net profit rises to Rs 6,506 crore
Tamannaah Bhatia questioned by ED in Guwahati in money laundering case, details inside
Hamas leader Yahya Sinwar killed in Gaza, Israel PM Netanyahu confirms
UGC NET June 2024 Result DECLARED: NTA announces UGC NET 2024 June exam result online, check here
Did IDF eliminate Yahya Sinwar, or has Martyr been born in Gaza?
Hamas chief Yahya Sinwar among 3 killed by Israel? Israel Defense Forces updates
Kangana Ranaut's Emergency finally cleared by CBFC, new release date...
Here's the film after which Shah Rukh Khan started drinking, his co-stars were Aishwarya Rai and...
Akash Ambani, Shloka Mehta live on 27th floor of Rs 15000 crore Antilia, here's why
Young entrepreneur’s Rahul Sachdeva journey to make foreign education accessible
Is Rajinikanth's Poes Garden home flooded amid Chennai rains? Here's the truth behind viral video
'My family is broken but..': Zeeshan Siddiqui's first reaction to father Baba Siddiqui's death
DNA Auto Award 2024 Has Spoken: Jawa 42 FJ, bringing Neo-classic revolution in Motor Industry
Apple iPad 10th gen vs iPad 9th gen: Should you buy or wait for iPad 11?
Nita Ambani's hairstylist explains why haircuts can't fix damage and offers solutions
Bigg Boss Kannada's Kiccha Sudeepa retires from hosting duties, says 'let's make this season...'
Air India flight from Mumbai transmits emergency signal over London, claims Flight tracker
Elon Musk applauds India's decision: Spectrum allocation favors open access and innovation
BIG UPDATE on IPL auction, Saudi Arabia to host event, will take place on...
Two Bahraich violence accused shot by police in encounter while fleeing to Nepal; 5 held
'I won’t be returning': South African legend bids farewell to Sunrisers Hyderabad ahead of IPL 2025
Indian stargazers spot rare, ancient comet after 80,000 years, see breathtaking pics
'46 all-out new 36 all-out?': Cricket Australia trolls India after batting collapse vs New Zealand
Karwa Chauth 2024: Know the date, timings, history and significance
Mukesh Ambani's Jio superhit 5G plan, offers 90 days validity with unlimited data
IND vs NZ: Virat Kohli equals THIS unwanted record with 9-ball duck against New Zealand in 1st Test
Proba-3: ISRO to launch ESA Solar Eclipse Mission with precision satellites
'Law not blind': Supreme court makes 2 BIG CHANGES, unveils new justice lady and replaced…
J-K: Several CRPF Jawans injured in road accident in Budgam, probe underway
Who is Justice Sanjiv Khanna named CJI Chandrachud's successor, could become next Chief Justice?
Mukesh Ambani's BIG move: Reliance investors to get this DIWALI bonanza, know details here
'Ravan ko kisne maara?' This kid's hilarious answer will leave your in splits, WATCH viral video
Nayab Singh Saini takes oath as Haryana CM in presence of PM Modi, BJP brass
IND vs NZ: India all out for 46 runs, lowest test score at home
Hunter's Moon 2024: NASA drops first glimpse of brightest Supermoon, shares its significance