WORLD
A group of Italian scientists was facing six years in jail for manslaughter last night (Monday) for providing "an incomplete, inept, unsuitable and criminally mistaken" assessment of risks posed by the devastating L'Aquila earthquake that killed more than 300 people.
A group of Italian scientists was facing six years in jail for manslaughter last night (Monday) for providing "an incomplete, inept, unsuitable and criminally mistaken" assessment of risks posed by the devastating L'Aquila earthquake that killed more than 300 people.
The landmark decision was welcomed by victims and their families but immediately prompted uproar from the scientific community, which contends that there is no reliable way of predicting earthquakes.
The six scientists and a former government official were all members of the Major Risks Committee which met in the central Italian city on March 31, 2009, after several small tremors had been recorded in the region. At the time, they ruled that it was impossible to determine whether the tremors would be followed by a large quake, in a judgment which reassured residents. One of the group famously advised them to relax with a glass of wine. Just six days later, a 6.3 magnitude quake devastated L'Aquila.
Yesterday, Judge Marco Billi announced the manslaughter sentence to a packed courtroom in a temporary building put up to hear the case in the still devastated city. He also ruled that the defendants should pay euros 7.8?million (pounds 6.4?million) in damages, with euros ?2?million to be paid immediately.
The sentencing provoked strong criticism from the scientific community. Richard Walters of Oxford University's Department of Earth Sciences, said he was "saddened" by the verdict, which set a "dangerous precedent".
"The issue here is about miscommunication of science, and we should not be putting responsible scientists who gave measured, scientifically accurate information in prison. This sets a very dangerous precedent and I fear it will discourage other scientists from offering their advice on natural hazards and trying to help society in this way."
Professor Malcolm Sperrin, Director of Medical Physics, Royal Berkshire Hospital, said: "If the scientific community is to be penalised for making predictions that turn out to be incorrect, or for not accurately predicting an event that subsequently occurs, then scientific endeavour will be restricted to certainties only and the benefits that are associated with findings from medicine to physics will be stalled."
Fabio Picuti, the prosecutor, had sought four-year terms for each of the defendants. Judge Billi's reason for the longer sentence imposed will be disclosed at a later date.
In his summing up, Mr Picuti told the court that the defendants had provided "an incomplete, inept, unsuitable and criminally mistaken" analysis which gave the residents of L'Aquila a false sense of security. He compared them to the US Federal Emergency Management Agency, which came under fire for failing to assess the risks before Hurricane Katrina swept through New Orleans in 2005.
Enzi Boschi, the former president of Italy's National Institute of Geophysics and Volcanology, who was among the seven found guilty, said he was "disappointed and devastated". He added: "I thought I would be cleared. I still don't understand of what I am accused."
Defence lawyers condemned the sentence and pledged to appeal. Under the Italian system, the seven will remain free until they have exhausted two chances to appeal.
Mohammad Rizwan set to replace Babar Azam as Pakistan's ODI and T20I captain
Viral video: Little girl's adorable dance to 'Aayi Nai' impresses internet, watch
Gujarat: Vadodara man performs CPR to save snake's life, netizens say, 'Barodians can do anything'
Mukesh Ambani's brand forces Tata Group company to reduce its product price, revenue hit by...
DNA TV Show: Mumbai Police receives threat message seeking Rs 5 crore from Salman Khan
Shraddha Kapoor breaks silence over credit battle for Stree 2's success: 'I believe it was...'
Who is IAS Sanjeev Hans, arrested by ED in money laundering case?
Gautam Adani donates Rs 1000000000 to THIS Indian state for...
Mukesh Ambani's Jio Financial Services' profit rises by 3%, company earns Rs 6890000000 in...
Virat Kohli completes 9000 Test runs - Is he the fastest Indian to achieve this feat?
Karwa Chauth 2024: Check muhurat, moonrise timing in Delhi, Mumbai, Lucknow, Patna other cities here
Salman Khan to import bulletproof SUV from Dubai after threats from gangster Lawrence Bishnoi
Apple's HR head resigns in less than 2 years marking another high-level departure under Tim Cook
60 guards and no one can leave the sets before it is over: How Salman Khan shoots for Bigg Boss 18
Karan Johar, Akshay Kumar join hands for a film inspired by…
Suresh Mansharmani - The Father of OKR is transforming SMEs of India
Meet world's 10 most beautiful women, including an Indian, not Aishwarya Rai, Alia Bhatt
Apple iPhone 16 under Rs 70000? THIS company is offering flat Rs 10000 discount, check details
Meet Bollywood actress who graduated from Harvard, wrote children’s books, did nude scenes in…
IND vs NZ, 1st Test: Virat Kohli falls on final ball of Day 3, India trail New Zealand by 125 runs
Pro Kabaddi League 2024 Live Streaming: When and where to watch PKL season 11 live on TV and online
Karwa Chauth 2024 Sargi timing: What you must include in your sargi thali?
SAT stays Rs 250000000 Sebi fine on Anil Ambani with one condition, asks him to...
Man was crossing railway track with phone glued to his face, watch video to know what happened next
Pioneering Business Intelligence at Cisco: The Visionary Leadership of Sagar Shukla
AAP leader Satyendar Jain walks out of jail, says, 'We will continue...'
Driving Innovation: Aravind Reddy Nayani's breakthrough in electric vehicle technology
From legacy systems to advanced analytics: The evolution of Devidas Kanchetti
Who is IPS Bhagyashree Navtake, Maharashtra cadre officer booked by CBI in Rs 1200 crore scam probe?
Meet IIT-JEE topper with 339 marks in JEE Advanced, went to IIT Bombay with AIR 1, now working as...
Virat Kohli's decision to not celebrate Rachin Ravindra's wicket sparks debate, know what happened
Watch: Radhika Merchant stuns in Rohit Bal lehenga at friend's wedding, dances to 'Sajna Ve Sajna'
PAK vs ENG: Pakistan beat England by 152 runs, register 1st Test win at home after 1348 days
Excel in finance and SAP integration-mastering an extraordinary journey of Dignesh Khatri
Revolutionizing Ad Technology: Arth Dave’s Leadership in Machine Learning-Driven Ad Recommendations
Redefining In-Store Shopping Experience: Krishnateja Shiva's impact on retail innovation
Vijay Bhaskar Kamireddy: Revolutionising machine learning with innovation and expertise
PM Modi to visit Russia next week to attend BRICS Summit in Kazan
Good news for Indian travellers as THIS country is now offering visa-on-arrival, check details
IPL 2025: 3 reasons why RCB might go in bidding war for New Zealand batter Rachin Ravindra
Key skills for successful web development career
6 important things to keep in mind before taking loan
Good news for Sadhguru as SC dismisses plea against Isha Foundation
Mukesh Ambani’s dream comes true as Reliance Jio beats Airtel, BSNL in...
Kunal Kamra reignites debate with Bhavish Aggarwal, says, 'Ola Electric hasn’t...'
IPL 2025: All teams possible retention list ahead of mega auction, CSK, RCB, MI will retain…
Hamas leader Yahya Sinwar dead: List of top figures who may replace him
Elon Musk, Jeff Bezos have new 'job', they now work for...
Ex-India captain's clip goes viral amid India's batting disaster, fan says, 'he is trolling BCCI'
Meet people who will execute Ratan Tata's will, not Noel Tata, Jimmy Tata, they are...
US charges former RAW official for plotting to kill Sikh separatist Gurpatwant Singh Pannun
Byju's Raveendran finally BREAKS SILENCE on his rumoured move to Dubai amid legal tussle
What are Nita Ambani's lavish daily habits and how much does she spend in a day?
A company accidentally hired a North Korean cyber criminal and then…
Karisma Kapoor reveals this actress on Hum Saath Saath Hain set would sit alone, eat only…
Ratan Tata's neighbours share stories of everyday encounters with him, say he was...
Viral video: Internet can't stop gushing over this little girl's breathtaking dance, WATCH
THIS Gautam Adani company's shares are in spotlight as it raises Rs 42000000000 in...