ANALYSIS
The government released in 2017 some disturbing statistics: of the judges in the Supreme Court and various High Courts, only 12% are women.
The idea of a reflective judiciary representing all sections of the society has only lately been recognized in India.
Even though reflective judiciary has not been raised as an issue before the Supreme Court, but Justice S R Pandian in Second Judges Transfer Case manifestly spoke for it: “It is essential and vital for the establishment of real participatory democracy that all sections and classes of people, be they backward classes or scheduled castes or scheduled tribes or minorities or women, should be afforded equal opportunity.”
This paper efforts to highlight the critical state of gender representation in the Indian judiciary. The government released in 2017 some disturbing statistics: of the judges in the Supreme Court and various High Courts, only 12% are women. The Supreme Court has only ever had eight women judges.
It was astounding to learn that the first woman judge in the Supreme Court was appointed only after 39 years of its establishment. After the retirement of Justice Ruma Pal, the Supreme Court was without a female judge for almost four years.
It was only after Her Excellency Prathibha Patil’s intervention, that the collegium headed by the Chief Justice K G Balakrishnan recommended the elevation of Gyan Sudha Misra, Chief Justice of the Jharkhand High Court, as Supreme Court judge.
The situation in High Courts are equally grim. The 24 High Courts of our country have only around 10% of women judges. And High Courts of Uttarakhand, Tripura, Meghalaya, Manipur, Jharkhand, Chhattisgarh, Jammu & Kashmir and Himachal Pradesh do not have even a single female judge.
The condition is shoddier in the lower judiciary. A report by the Vidhi Centre For Legal Policy (2017), reveals that the number of women judges can be pegged at around 28% of the total strength.
While states like Bihar (11.52%), Jharkhand (13.98%), Gujarat (15.11%), Jammu and Kashmir (18.62%) and Uttar Pradesh (21.4%) are at lowest end of spectrum, Meghalaya (73.8%), Goa (65.9%) and Sikkim (64.7%) are slightly better.
Inadequate representation of women has serious social and political ramifications. It not only demonstrates the lack of diversity in judicial perspectives, but directly magnifies the implied bias that exists in courts.
This dearth of diversity is sensed most intensely when we see constitutional benches, all comprised of men, pondering over critical women issues such as triple-talaq, marital rape, adultery and entry of women in temples and mosques. It crumbles the courts’ legitimacy as representative of the various sections of society and questions the equality of opportunity for women in the legal profession.
There seems a world of difference between precept and practice. The Supreme Court, which is at the helm of appointment affairs in constitutional courts for the last three decades, has failed miserably to apply principles of gender justice (which it has preached from the bench in cases like Vishaka or Sabrimala) while recommending names for High Courts and the Supreme Court.
It apparently seems to be clutched by patriarchal bias that confronts the process of appointment, promotion and elevation. Several judges and lawyers have testified to this gender bias in the appointment and promotion process.
The former Chief Justice of the Delhi High Court, Justice A P Shah, has evoked an instance how a woman lawyer recommended for judgeship was vetoed on the grounds that she was ‘rude, but similar behaviour displayed by a male lawyer have not been taken as a ground of disqualification.’
As far as subordinate judiciary is concerned, states like Andhra Pradesh, Assam, Bihar, Chhattisgarh, Jharkhand, Karnataka, Odisha, Rajasthan, Tamil Nadu and Telangana have provided a quota for women that ranges between 30 to 35%.
Prominent women lawyers like Indira Jaising, Meenakshi Arora and many others have expressly raised the issues of discrimination that women lawyers face in the legal profession embedded with a deeply-rooted ‘old boys club mentality’.
This has contributed to the low representation of women in legal profession, as estimated around 10%. When it comes to senior advocates in the Supreme Court, this further goes down to 3% (only 12 women lawyers have been designated as senior counsels by the Supreme Court).
Eight women in the Delhi High Court, six in the Bombay High Court and one in the Allahabad High Court, have been designated as senior advocates so far. This state of affairs makes it difficult for this class to aspire for judicial posts in constitutional courts.
Prime Minister Narendra Modi, who swears by gender justice, has to persuade state governments, at least those where the BJP is in power, to reduce this gender inequity by providing women reservation in judicial services at all levels.
But, eyes will be more on the five lords of country’s highest court. They will have to take this issue on board in a more systemic manner, if India’s higher judiciary is to be truly representative.
Writer is associate professor of law, NLU
Why Mahindra XUV700 is perfect for road trips and off-road adventures
Mahindra Scorpio N: A legacy of toughness with a modern twist
'Capable of loving more women': Kamal Haasan's bold take on marriage and relationships goes viral
How reaction time and speed tests can give gamers a competitive edge
This is world’s most polluted city with AQI of 1165, it’s just 409 kms away from Delhi
Blow to Gautam Adani as his company's shares fell 7% due to...
Pune Porsche crash: Father of teen driver's friend surrenders before court
Geographic and political nature of drug trafficking sea routes to India
Delhi AQI Update: Air quality turns 'severe', AQI reaches...
Mukesh Ambani's SUPERHIT new plan for Jio users, offers 100 GB of free cloud storage for just Rs...
Delhi-Mumbai expressway to slash travel time to 25 minutes: Key stretch to open on...
'Modi govt is committed to building terror-free India': Union Minister Amit Shah
Chhath Puja 2024: What is the importance of bamboo basket in Chhath Puja?
SC to deliver verdict today on plea against NCLAT order transferring Jet Airways to winning bidder
Is it time for Virat Kohli, Rohit Sharma to step down from playing Test cricket?
Chhath Puja 2024: Are banks open or closed today? Check state-wise list here
DNA TV Show: How did Donald Trump win US elections despite his several controversies?
Sunil Mittal's Airtel joins hands with Indian Army, becomes only private company to...
Shah Rukh Khan's Mannat to Amitabh Bachchan's Jalsa: 5 most expensive celebrity homes in India
IPL 2025 auction: 42-year-old England legend registers for first time, his base price is...
Stranger Things season 5 teaser reveals episode titles, release date confirmed as...
Singer Rahul Vaidya buys 3110 sq ft luxury apartment worth Rs 90000000, it is located in...
Nimrat Kaur asks Abhishek Bachchan ‘would you distract Aaradhya’, he praises Aishwarya Rai in reply
JEE Advanced 2025: Candidates now allowed to give 3 attempts, check details inside
Watch: MS Dhoni's video of playing golf with Donald Trump goes viral after US Polls
Viral: Italy's Lake Como's 'fresh air' can being sold for Rs 907, details inside
Ranji Trophy: Jalaj Saxena scripts history, becomes first cricketer to achieve massive feat
Gautam Adani congratulates Donald Trump on winning US elections, says, 'If there is one person...'
Meet Usha Chilukuri, who is set to become first Indian-origin second lady of US, she is wife of...
Delhi NCR: Traffic advisory issued in Ghaziabad ahead of Chhath Puja 2024, check routes to avoid
ICC Test Rankings: Rishabh Pant breaks into top 10; Virat Kohli, Rohit Sharma suffer massive loss
NASA's Sunita Williams witnesses 16 sunrises, sunsets daily in space, here’s how
'India will…': Ricky Ponting makes BOLD prediction for Border-Gavaskar Trophy
From DU to Tesla: Meet man who works for Elon Musk, manages his company's...
Essence of Leadership: Insights from Ankur Saini
Who is Thomas Draca? First Italian player to register for IPL 2025 mega auction
IPL 2025 mega auction: Full list of players with Rs 2 crore base price
Meet man who quit Paytm after Rs 2048 crore deal with Deepinder Goyal's Zomato, he is...
Anushka Sharma can't stop laughing seeing Virat Kohli's funny move in unseen viral video - Watch
SA vs IND: Arshdeep Singh aims to surpass Bhuvneshwar Kumar’s all-time T20I record
Donald Trump reclaims US presidency, netizens win hearts with meme-fest
'Everyone will come to know...': LoP Rahul Gandhi's BIG statement on caste census in Nagpur
Thama: Ayushmann Khurrana reveals all about 'bloody love story', says it is....
'History’s greatest comeback': Israel PM Netanyahu congratulates Donald Trump on US Election victory
US Election Results LIVE: Donald Trump's victory speech; WATCH HERE
Arjun Kapoor hits back at haters post Singham Again success: 'To everyone who...'
'Let's work for global peace': PM Modi congratulates 'friend' Donald Trump on winning US election