ANALYSIS
The idea of reflective judiciary is being projected as measure to overcome and manage diversity
The Constituent Assembly and numerous Supreme Court judgments have restated that economic criterion cannot be the sole basis for granting reservation.
In spite of that, the Modi government announced 10% quota for economically weaker section (EWS) through 103rd Constitutional Amendment Act. This political move has been confronted, but the apex court refused to grant an interim injunction on the EWS quota.
In a similar move, the Supreme Court refused to stay the Bombay High Court’s decision to uphold reservations for the Maratha community in educational institutions and jobs in public services in Maharashtra.
Apex Court’s denial to grant an interim injunction on EWS quota and the Maratha quota exhibits an abundant dichotomy in judicial policy while dealing with social justice.
Judicial discourse on reservation beginning 1950, focused on expanding formal equality as enshrined under Articles 15(1) and 29(2) and drastically confining the principle of substantive equality inherently embedded in Articles 14, 15, 16, 38, 46, 332, 335, 338 and 340.
This strategy was initially developed to pre-empt claims of proportionate representation in educational institutions on mythical grounds.
The first-ever attempt for reservation did not find favour with the Constitution bench composed of upper caste elite judges in Champakam Dorairajan case (1951) because it marginally restricted upper caste space by prescribing their percentage of representation and created some space for Bahujan students in the process.
This left no option for a determined Periyar and Babasaheb Ambedkar to claim the Bahujan space in educational institutions by convincing the Parliament to pass the First Constitutional Amendment, which enabled the State to make special provision for the representation of Bahujan class in educational institutions.
Despite this, constitutional courts deployed the ‘judicial policy of postponement of social justice’ to deny Bahujan representation both in educational institutions and state services.
The State of Mysore strived to make special provision for the advancement of the socially and educationally backward classes of citizens under Article 15 (4) of the Constitution since 1958, and every time it faced stiff resistance from the High Court of Mysore until it reached to the apex court in Balaji case.
The Supreme Court packed with elite and upper caste judges, underplayed the role of caste and carefully crafted the economic argument to prevent social and educational arguments from taking strong roots.
Interestingly, caste as a factor for determining backwardness was marginalised by unfairly assuming that the test of castes would be inapplicable to Muslims and Christians.
It also prevented the categorization of OBCs into Backward Class and More Backward Class by holding that such a categorisation is outside the scope of Article 15(4).
The strategic interpretation of the Balaji case was legitimised over the decades by courts, jurists, journalists and textbook writers.
For instance, the Supreme Court in Devadasan (1963) and Chitralekha (1964) reiterated the economic argument of Balaji with greater emphasis. Such reasoning was utilised by the constitutional courts to delay social justice so that the ruling class was able to develop neutralising strategies.
However, relentless social movements forced the Supreme Court to concede some space in the N M Thomas case (1975), but the higher judiciary’s unbending resistance continued.
A similar thread of thought runs through Indira Sawhney v. Union of India (1993), when the nine-judge bench, while upholding the 50% reservation in favour of backward class, stated that the very idea of reservation implies the selection of a less meritorious person and cost has to be paid if the constitutional promise of social justice is to be redeemed.
The Court cautioned that there are certain services and positions such as technical posts in research and development organisations/departments/institutions, in specialities and super specialities in medicine, engineering and other such courses in Physical Sciences and Mathematics, in defence and connected services, promotions where merit alone counts.
Later in Mohan Bir Singh Chawla v. Punjab University (1997), Sadhna Devi (Dr) v. State of U. P., (1997) and Dr PritiSagar Srivastava vs. State of M.P. (1997), the Court admonished that reservation in higher levels of education would be dangerous and belittle merit and excellence.
However, surprisingly, the Supreme Court appeared to be more generous when it comes to upper caste issues. Apex court declined to grant a stay on the Centre’s decision to grant 10% reservation to economically weaker sections in the general category in jobs and educational institutions.
But it had stayed the central government’s policy to introduce 27% reservation for the OBCs in central educational institutions for one year before it upheld its constitutionality. Even in the Indira Sawhney case, the Supreme Court granted an interim stay at the time of admission.
Constitutional court’s dubious approach was also seen in the Maratha reservation policy, which came under the spotlight when the poll-bound Devendra Fadnavis-led government enacted a law to grant 16% reservation for the Maratha community.
The Bombay High Court upheld the law, in spite of the fact that the state’s reservation quota exceeded 60%. Introduction of 13-point roster and dilution of SC, ST Atrocities Act by the higher judiciary further indicates the perpetuity of such alignment.
To overcome the difficulties created by the judiciary, the Parliament has from time to time, brought amendments in the Constitution, but how to overcome this persistent judicial resistance has become a moot question.
The idea of the reflective judiciary is being projected as one of the measures to overcome this problem and manage diversity. The social construction of judicial power is a delicate and complex issue, but the government will have to conceive a scheme to not only enhance the quality of justice administered by the courts but also to restore greater faith of all sections of the society in the judiciary.
Author is registrar, National Law University, Odisha
Amid rising air pollution, Delhi-NCR's crematorium records cleanest air; check AQI here
Revolutionising Medical Imaging: Venudhar Rao Hajari’s impact on healthcare technology
Abhishek Gupta and Onevision Media: Scaling brands on social media
Video shows Korean girl eating jalebi for first time, her reaction to Indian sweet goes viral
Cristiano Ronaldo confirms THIS YouTube star as his next guest, says, 'Will break Internet'
Delhi Assembly Elections: AAP releases first list of 11 candidates for 2025 polls
Adani Group's FIRST REACTION after US indicts Gautam Adani in alleged bribery case
Instagram introduces new feature, know how to reset app's algorithm, change your feed
Oppo Find X8 and X8 Pro launched in India, check specifications, price, other details
Charges against Gautam Adani: BJP's scathing attack on Congress, questions timing of development
Jasprit Bumrah's BIG statement on taking up Perth test captaincy, says, 'tactically better...'
Blackout on breaks: Company imposes no-sick-leave policy until 2025
Drug-laden terrorists on India's western, northern frontiers
Mohammad Shami trolls Sanjay Manjrekar over IPL auction bid prediction, says, 'Baba ki...'
IND vs AUS Test: When and where to watch 1st match of Border-Gavaskar trophy, know details here
CAQM amends Grap Stages III, IV, enforces stricter measures in Delhi-NCR amid air pollution woes
Malayalam actor Meghanathan passes away at 60 after suffering from...
Adani Green Energy's FIRST reaction after US indicts Gautam Adani in alleged bribery case
'Keep me out of...': Pakistani Instagram star Mathira on MMS leak controversy
Delhi Air Pollution: AQI marginally improves from 'severe' to 'very poor' category
'I love him, he loves me! Why hurt...': Rekha's bold confession about Amitabh Bachchan goes viral
Meet man, IITian who built Rs 5493 crore firm, has this Mukesh Ambani connection, he is from...
Shillong Teer Results TODAY November 21, 2024 Live Updates: Check winning numbers here
‘I didn’t have time to…’: When AR Rahman revealed having ‘agreement’ before marriage to Saira Banu
Viral video: Woman's sizzling belly dance to 'Namak' impresses internet, watch
Hardik Pandya banned, Mumbai Indians captain to miss first match of IPL 2025 due to...
Meet man who studied at IIM, IIT, then built Rs 1160000000 company, got inspired by…
Meet woman, who quit as dentist for UPSC exam, became IAS officer with AIR...
Viral video: Little girl steals hearts with her adorable dance to 'o meri cutie', watch
Gautam Adani's company signs another pact to acquire 100% stake in...
CBSE Date Sheet 2025 announced: Class 10, 12 board exams to begin from...
Apollena: Aditi Sharma on how space-based drama encourage young girls, says 'no matter how many...'
Is Mia Khalifa dating ex-Man City star Julian Alvarez? Former adult star says 'It certainly...'
IPL 2025 auction RTM rule: How this year’s right-to-match card is different from previous seasons
'Virat Kohli is trying to...': Shoaib Akhtar makes BIG statement on Champions Trophy 2025
Maharashtra Election 2024: Mukesh Ambani and family cast their votes in Mumbai
Centre revises performance-linked incentive scheme for THESE employees; check details
Manipur violence: Prohibitory orders to be relaxed in Imphal Valley for 7 hours
Jharkhand Exit Poll Results 2024: 36-41 seats predicted for BJP, JMM to secure…
Elon Musk faces big threat after million of users switch from X to Jack Dorsey's Bluesky
ICC Rankings: Hardik Pandya reclaims No. 1 T20I all-rounder spot, Tilak Varma enters top 10
DNA Verified: Is retirement age for central govt employees increasing to 62? Know truth here
Android 16 preview unveiled by Google: Who can access it? Here's all you need to know
Anti-pollution diet: Foods that can help fight air pollution naturally
Tech millionaire Bryan Johnson's face 'blows up' after anti-aging experiment; here’s how
Expanding Horizons: GOCL Corporation’s Strategic Diversification in Electronics and Metal Cladding
TrezarBit App Review 2024: Legit Trading Platform? Quick Facts!
Meet man who worked closely with Isha Ambani, Mukesh Ambani, set to take new role as...
Meet man, lifted bricks 8 hours a day, cracked NEET by studying on broken phone, he scored...
US embassy in Kyiv shuts down after receiving warning of 'potential significant' Russian air attack