ANALYSIS
Time and again CJIs have pointed out that miniscule budgetary allocation impacts judicial governance
Any justice delivery system has an obligation to deliver prompt and inexpensive justice to its consumers, without in any manner compromising on the quality of justice or the elements of fairness, equality and impartiality. However, for justice to be meaningful, it must be delivered within a time-frame that makes sense during the lifetime of a litigant. Denial of ‘timely justice’ amounts to denial of ‘justice’ itself. The two are integral to each other. Timely disposal of cases is essential for maintaining the rule of law and providing access to justice, which is a guaranteed fundamental right. The official figures of pending cases clearly show that the challenge to the Indian State is that of timely justice. This is so because if timely justice is not made available by the State to its citizens, human and economic development is retarded.
Disputed contracts, properties and securities lie frozen in the courts for years, mocking at the constitutional right to property and the human right to dignity. Under trial prisoners burden the State finances, with the avoidable costs of public money as well as seething discontent over political, police and prison governance. The angst over proving criminal or contractual innocence, unable to wait for a judicial decision, held up because of the lack of adequate number of judges and judicial infrastructure. The rule of law, another judicially declared component of the basic structure, stands violated. The credibility of constitutional governance and a constitutional State is getting gradually eroded.
The Supreme Court led by Chief Justice Ranjan Gogoi, who immediately after taking over as the Chief Justice of India, reprimanded the states and the high courts for their inefficiency in filling the vacancies in the subordinate judiciary, once again admonished states government for its inability to give a definite time line for creating the necessary courtrooms and residential space for judges to be appointed in subordinate courts.
The National Mission for Justice Delivery and Legal Reforms outlined that adequacy of judicial infrastructure is a prerequisite for reduction of pendency and backlog of cases in courts. Department of Justice in 2015 estimated total 16,513 courtrooms for a working strength of 16,070 judicial officers. The Centre for Research and Planning, Supreme Court of India to which I was part documented more deteriorating figures: a sanctioned strength of 20,558 judicial officers now only had 15,540 courtrooms and a deficit of 8,538 residential units. Therefore, any attempt to unravel the problem of judicial vacancies is required to go hand-in-hand with enhancement of judicial infrastructure which includes courtroom, support staff, residential space and other technological requirements.
Miniscule budgetary allocation for the judicial governance has been a serious concern. Time and again, the Chief Justices have raised this issue that ungenerous budgetary allocation is utterly insufficient to improve infrastructure, which is imperative to bring down the massive pendency in Indian courts. The primary responsibility of infrastructure development for the subordinate judiciary though lies with the state governments, but central government also releases additional funds under the Centrally Sponsored Scheme (CSS) for creating judicial infrastructure. Till 2011, the Centre and states contributed equally but since 2011-12 the fund-sharing arrangement was revised with the Centre contributing 75 per cent of the funds, however, subject to budgetary allocation.
The Union Budget for 2016-17 assigned Rs 900 crore for ‘administration of justice’, including setting up of e-courts and capacity building of subordinate judiciary. Between 2011 and March 2016, the Centre released Rs 3,694 crore to the state governments and UTs for construction of court buildings and residential accommodation of judicial officers. The Union Budget 2018-19 allocated of Rs 2,167.24 crore for the judiciary struggling to cope with huge pendency of cases. This allocation is up by Rs 145.43 crore in comparison to allocation of Rs 2,021.81 crore for year 2017-18, nevertheless, it is a miniscule part of the Rs 24 lakh crore budget presented by the Finance Minister.
The government’s treatment of judiciary as a non-productive organ of state is the biggest anxiety. With less than one per cent of the Union Budget spent, the judicial system will undeniably be under strain on account of huge backlog of cases. The Department of Justice has proposed an infrastructural overhaul with a budget of Rs 9,749 crores. This would include setting up of additional courts in districts with high pendency, fast track courts to try cases of heinous crimes, more family courts, re-designing existing court complexes, digitization of case records and training and capacity building. The Union Government passed Gram Nyayalaya Act (2008) with an object to provide doorstep justice, but most states have not set up Gram Nyayalayas, especially the northeastern states. In order to reach out to marginalised groups and reduce the pendency of cases, state governments have to prioritise the setting up of Gram Nyayalayas with adequate infrastructure. Further, creation and implementation of ICT infrastructure in Indian Judiciary has to be done on priority basis. Expectations are more from Chief Justice of India, who claimed that he has a plan to deal with the pendency with this precise remark: “Time is short. We are making efforts for best results in the shortest time.”
Writer is associate professor of law, NLU
Why Mahindra XUV700 is perfect for road trips and off-road adventures
Mahindra Scorpio N: A legacy of toughness with a modern twist
'Capable of loving more women': Kamal Haasan's bold take on marriage and relationships goes viral
How reaction time and speed tests can give gamers a competitive edge
This is world’s most polluted city with AQI of 1165, it’s just 409 kms away from Delhi
Blow to Gautam Adani as his company's shares fell 7% due to...
Pune Porsche crash: Father of teen driver's friend surrenders before court
Geographic and political nature of drug trafficking sea routes to India
Delhi AQI Update: Air quality turns 'severe', AQI reaches...
Mukesh Ambani's SUPERHIT new plan for Jio users, offers 100 GB of free cloud storage for just Rs...
Delhi-Mumbai expressway to slash travel time to 25 minutes: Key stretch to open on...
'Modi govt is committed to building terror-free India': Union Minister Amit Shah
Chhath Puja 2024: What is the importance of bamboo basket in Chhath Puja?
SC to deliver verdict today on plea against NCLAT order transferring Jet Airways to winning bidder
Is it time for Virat Kohli, Rohit Sharma to step down from playing Test cricket?
Chhath Puja 2024: Are banks open or closed today? Check state-wise list here
DNA TV Show: How did Donald Trump win US elections despite his several controversies?
Sunil Mittal's Airtel joins hands with Indian Army, becomes only private company to...
Shah Rukh Khan's Mannat to Amitabh Bachchan's Jalsa: 5 most expensive celebrity homes in India
IPL 2025 auction: 42-year-old England legend registers for first time, his base price is...
Stranger Things season 5 teaser reveals episode titles, release date confirmed as...
Singer Rahul Vaidya buys 3110 sq ft luxury apartment worth Rs 90000000, it is located in...
Nimrat Kaur asks Abhishek Bachchan ‘would you distract Aaradhya’, he praises Aishwarya Rai in reply
JEE Advanced 2025: Candidates now allowed to give 3 attempts, check details inside
Watch: MS Dhoni's video of playing golf with Donald Trump goes viral after US Polls
Viral: Italy's Lake Como's 'fresh air' can being sold for Rs 907, details inside
Ranji Trophy: Jalaj Saxena scripts history, becomes first cricketer to achieve massive feat
Gautam Adani congratulates Donald Trump on winning US elections, says, 'If there is one person...'
Meet Usha Chilukuri, who is set to become first Indian-origin second lady of US, she is wife of...
Delhi NCR: Traffic advisory issued in Ghaziabad ahead of Chhath Puja 2024, check routes to avoid
ICC Test Rankings: Rishabh Pant breaks into top 10; Virat Kohli, Rohit Sharma suffer massive loss
NASA's Sunita Williams witnesses 16 sunrises, sunsets daily in space, here’s how
'India will…': Ricky Ponting makes BOLD prediction for Border-Gavaskar Trophy
From DU to Tesla: Meet man who works for Elon Musk, manages his company's...
Essence of Leadership: Insights from Ankur Saini
Who is Thomas Draca? First Italian player to register for IPL 2025 mega auction
IPL 2025 mega auction: Full list of players with Rs 2 crore base price
Meet man who quit Paytm after Rs 2048 crore deal with Deepinder Goyal's Zomato, he is...
Anushka Sharma can't stop laughing seeing Virat Kohli's funny move in unseen viral video - Watch
SA vs IND: Arshdeep Singh aims to surpass Bhuvneshwar Kumar’s all-time T20I record
Donald Trump reclaims US presidency, netizens win hearts with meme-fest
'Everyone will come to know...': LoP Rahul Gandhi's BIG statement on caste census in Nagpur
Thama: Ayushmann Khurrana reveals all about 'bloody love story', says it is....
'History’s greatest comeback': Israel PM Netanyahu congratulates Donald Trump on US Election victory
US Election Results LIVE: Donald Trump's victory speech; WATCH HERE
Arjun Kapoor hits back at haters post Singham Again success: 'To everyone who...'
'Let's work for global peace': PM Modi congratulates 'friend' Donald Trump on winning US election