ANALYSIS
The apex court ought to follow its own guidelines on sexual harassment because the world is watching
Rising pendency with a backlog touching 3.3 crore cases and the procedure of judicial appointments that has generated tensions between the judiciary and the executive were two issues that dominated the Supreme Court in the last two decades.
However, it appears that these two issues have become subsidiary among many current concerns surrounding the institutional crisis that has gripped the Supreme Court.
Early 2018 brought to the fore another aspect – the accumulation of powers in the hands of Chief Justice of India (CJI) to select colleagues on the bench over which he presides or allocates cases to his colleagues.
It became global news when four senior most judges, including the present Chief Justice of India, publicly said that the then CJI had been assigning cases arbitrarily and according to his own preferences.
While this public protest ended as brusquely as it had commenced, the apex court faced the spotlight soon when the CJI introduced a new roster system.
This led to unprecedented spin-offs. Seven opposition parties led by the Congress moved a notice for the impeachment of the then CJI accusing him of “misbehaviour” and “misuse” of his administrative powers.
Though Chairman Rajya Sabha, M Venkaiah Naidu, vetoed the notice, it brought unparalleled disgrace to the institution in general and office of the CJI in particular.
The ghost of the past has come to haunt the office of the CJI once again with certain titillating questions and paradoxes.
The first paradox: it is not a mere coincidence that the judge who protested against preceding CJI arguing that ‘democracy is in danger’, is now facing charges of sexual harassment from a court employee. The paradox lies in the fact that the Supreme Court, which for the first time laid down the guidelines and norms for preventing sexual harassment at workplace in the famous Vishaka and Others vs. State of Rajasthan and Others (1997), failed to apply those guidelines when it came to itself.
The guidelines, besides imposing obligations on the employer to provide a safe working environment, mandated all to set up a Complaints Committee within the organisation to look into such offences.
“Such a complaint mechanism should ensure time-bound treatment of complaints,” provide the Supreme Court guidelines. The Complaints Committee should be headed by a woman and not less than half of its member should be women.
Further, to prevent the possibility of any undue pressure or influence from senior levels, such a panel should involve a third party, either a NGO or another body familiar with the issue of sexual harassment.
Unfortunately, ignoring all these principles laid down by the Supreme Court, double standards were on display once again.
The apex court, which keeps a constant check over every institution, has once again failed to apply similar method of disciplining its own behaviour.
Second paradox: the Chief Justice, who strongly raised his voice against his predecessor’s master of roster prerogative and held a press conference alleging that he was assigning cases arbitrarily, constituted a bench comprising himself and Justices Arun Mishra and Sanjiv Khanna, all male justices in spite of the fact that Supreme Court has three women justices at the moment.
The CJI, unpredictably, saw urgency and posted the matter on the judicial side constituting a bench of three judges and holding a hearing on a holiday as “In Re: Matter of great public importance touching upon the independence of the judiciary.’’
Third paradox: That the CJI judged the case, while being an accused, appears way too strong to digest.
Nemo judex in sua causa, i.e. no one can be judge in his own cause, a cardinal principle of natural justice, it seems is applicable to all except My Lords.
The name of the Chief Justice was, however, conveniently omitted from the order to be on safe side. The allegations may be true, false or politically motivated, but the manner in which CJI dealt with this case was undeniably vindictive.
Denial of hearing to the complainant and attempts to cancel her bail congregates the very essence of the justice delivery process, which is fair and transparent. Another principle of natural justice audi alterum partem stands desecrated.
Fourth paradox: the Chief Justice who made history by organising a press conference in January last year against the then CJI, has now requested the media to show restraint to protect the independence of judiciary.
The irony of the argument put forward by the CJI that an alleged sexual harassment against him has the potential of damaging the independence of judiciary, seems too naïve to be acceptable on pragmatic grounds.
The spirit of independence was underlined precisely by Lord Woolf, “the independence of the Judiciary is not the property of the Judiciary, but a commodity to be held by the Judiciary in trust for the public.”
On the contrary, greater transparency and accountability in the working of the apex court will foster more respect for the institution. Provided there is nothing to hide or shove under the rug.
For way too long, the judicial body has been wrapped under the cloak of discretion and inexplicability.
The Supreme Court of India has been a people’s court, pronouncing judgments for the betterment of human conditions and upholding rule of law. At this juncture, it will be surprising if it denies the due process on grounds of judicial independency. It will be a battle fought for all the wrong reasons.
Author is Registrar National Law University Odisha
DNA TV Show: Why Election Commission changed Assembly by-elections' dates
Days after imposing fine on Anil Ambani, Sebi now issues Rs 130 crore demand notices to...
Thailand announces indefinite visa-free entry for Indian travellers
Meet daughter of billionaire, who studied in UK, now works in Rs 32770 crore Indian company as...
MUDA case: Lokayukta police summon Karnataka CM Siddaramaiah for questioning on...
This city is 4000 years old, belongs to bronze age where 500 people lived, it is located in...
Kamala Harris has been the President of US before? Here's when and how
Meet son-in-law of billionaire whose net worth is Rs 38690 crore, he co-founded...
What is elimination inflammation diet that helped Vidya Balan lose weight?
Shah Rukh Khan feels breathless after quitting smoking: Know withdrawal symptoms, how to manage them
Zomato CEO Deepinder Goyal takes action on vendor for mislabelling mushrooms at Hyperpure warehouse
Mukesh Ambani's Reliance shares fell by 3%, loses Rs 50205 crore in one day due to...
IAF's MiG-29 crashes near Agra in Uttar Pradesh, pilot ejects safely, court of inquiry ordered
Driving Growth and Monetization at Zendesk: A Conversation with Darshit Thakkar
Can air pollution make you fat? Know how high AQI impact your health
Locanto Addresses Challenges and Innovations in Indian Education System
Nita Ambani stuns in floral co-ord set while Anant, Mukesh Ambani go casual in Dubai
Indian Railway to launch this 'SUPER APP', passengers can now..., know details here
Who is Rashmi Shukla, IPS officer whom EC removed as Maharashtra DGP?
This village in India allows men to have two wives, living under one roof due to…
AUS vs PAK, 1st ODI: Australia beat Pakistan by 2 wickets to take 1-0 lead in series
Singham Again’s sole aim is to entertain, it’s not Hindutva propaganda
Delhi pollution: 'Why firecracker ban was not implemented during Diwali,' SC asks police, govt
IPL 2025 mega auction likely to be held in Riyadh on these dates
Big update on Reliance Jio IPO as Mukesh Ambani eyes THIS date
EC reschedules UP, Punjab, Kerala bypolls from Nov 13 to...
Coldplay's Chris Martin falls through stage trap door while performing live in Australia
Meet man, who is rising star in Tata Group after Ratan Tata's death, now tasked with...
'Nice handwriting': Internet reacts to Elon Musk's physics homework from his college days
AIIMS INI CET 2025 admit card releasing today at aiimsexams.ac.in; when and how to download
Sustainability Meets Innovation via uPVC: Industry expert shares experience
Promoting innovation in engineering education
AP TET 2024 exam result declared at aptet.apcfss.in; steps to check
AI-Powered Development: Insights from industry leaders on transforming software engineering
Another BIG move by BSNL, now set to provide tough competition to Jio, Airtel, Vi by...
Uttarakhand Bus Accident: 36 dead after bus falls into gorge in Almora; rescue operations underway
Bigg Boss 18: Vivian D'Sena accuses Chahat Pandey of pooping on floor, latter loses her cool
One of India's best wicketkeepers set to retire after this season, won't play IPL too, he is...
Research shows awe-inspiring details about Black Holes, they can...
US Presidential Election 2024: Harris vs Trump goes down to the wire, say polls
AP TET 2024 exam result to be declared today on aptet.apcfss.in, when and how to check
Shampoo, tea, biscuits, oil to get costlier soon? FMCG firms caution price hike as...
Swiggy fined Rs 35000 for duping Hyderabad customer by doing THIS
Delhi pollution: Air quality in Delhi-NCR further deteriorates, AQI hits 'severe' level
Indian mission condemns attack on Hindu devotees at Canada temple by ‘anti-India’ elements
'Upar se leke neeche tak...': Bigg Boss 18's Kashish Kapoor, Eisha Singh get into ugly spat
Man grows 500 kg pumpkin, uses it as boat to sail 70 km, SEE PIC
Devotees at Banke Bihari Temple drink AC water believing it to be 'Charan Amrit'; WATCH viral video
Bank Holidays in November: Banks to remain closed for four days in THESE states, full list here
Bhool Bhulaiyaa 3: Kartik Aaryan's mother struggles to get tickets, hilarious video goes viral
Mumbai Police arrest Maharashtra woman for hoax death threat to UP CM Yogi Adityanath
Kriti Sanon avoids posing with rumoured boyfriend Kabir Bahia at Mumbai airport, video goes viral
This is world's most expensive house, twice price of Mukesh Ambani's Antilia, it is located in...
SC to hear today Delhi govt's plea against vesting LG with power to appoint...
Viral video: Girl’s sizzling dance to ‘Taareefan’ song earns praise from netizens, watch
Watch: Elderly couple's heartwarming dance at Mohit Chauhan's Patna concert goes viral
This is India’s most expensive wedding card, made from real gold and silver, it costs Rs…