ANALYSIS
Politics in judicial appointments in India has a long history going back to post Independence
The law ministry recently notified the appointments of four judges, justices Hemant Gupta, R Subhash Reddy, MR Shah and Ajay Rastogi to the Supreme Court within 48 hours of the Supreme Court Collegium recommending them to the government.
Though it appears to be a welcome move, the modus operandi of the government, vis-a-vis judicial appointments, looks doubtful.
The Union government was under pressure early this year for resisting Justice KM Joseph’s elevation to Supreme Court on the ground that in the All India High Court judges’ seniority list, he was placed at serial number 42 and there were presently 11 chief justices of various high courts who were senior to him.
A brief survey of past appointments makes it evident that seniority either in appointment to the post of chief justice of the high courts or to elevation from high courts to Supreme Court, have only been given little weight.
Justice JR Mudholkar, a judge of the Bombay High Court and number 7 among permanent judges of the various high courts was elevated to the Supreme Court (on 3.10.1960) in preference to all the chief justices of the high courts. Justice RS Bachawat was at No. 2 in the list of permanent judges of various high courts when he was appointed to the Supreme Court (on 7.9.1964) in preference to the then chief justices of the high courts. Justice GK Mitter, No. 8 in the list of permanent judges of the various high courts was appointed to the Supreme Court (on 29.8.1966) bypassing three judges senior to him at the Calcutta High Court, including the chief justice.
Likewise, Justice CA Vaidialingam was appointed to the Supreme Court (on 10.10.1966) when there were two other judges senior to him in the Kerala High Court, including the chief justice. His position in the list of permanent judges of various high courts was number 23. Justice AN Grover was elevated to the Supreme Court on 12.2.1968 when there were two other judges senior to him in the Punjab and Haryana High Court, including the chief justice and his position among permanent judges of the various high courts stood at 39.
Justice AN Ray, who was number 30 among permanent judges of the various high courts and junior to three other judges in the Calcutta High Court, including the chief justice, was elevated to the Supreme Court on 1.8.1969. As was Justice KK Mathew to the Supreme Court (on 4.10.1971) when there were three other judges senior to him in the Kerala High Court, including the chief justice, and his position among permanent judges of the various high courts was number 70.
Likewise, there are many instances that can be narrated. Justice YV Chandrachud was at number 19 in the list of permanent judges of the various high courts and junior to two judges of his own high court, including the then chief justice, when he was appointed to the Supreme Court on 23.8.1972.
This trend has continued. Justice Ranjan Gogoi was elevated to the Supreme Court (on 23.04.2012) before his Supreme Court colleagues justices Madan B Lokur, Kurian Joseph, AK Sikri, SA Bobde, RK Agrawal, NV Ramana, Arun Mishra, AM Khanwilkar, AM Sapre and DY Chandrachud, who were all senior to him.
Justices Deepak Gupta and Naveen Sinha were both appointed Supreme Court judges on (17.02.2017) over the heads of 30 high court judges senior to them as of now. At the time of their appointment on February 17, 2017, they had around 40 high court judges senior to them in various high courts.
Similarly, Justices S Abdul Nazeer and Mohan M Shantanagoudar, both were elevated to Supreme Court (on 17.02.2017) in preference to 20 high court judges senior to them.
The most recent appointments of justices Hemant Gupta, R Subhash Reddy, MR Shah and Ajay Rastogi who stand at numbers 4, 5, 17 and 25 respectively in the all-India combined seniority of high court judges, has once again established that seniority has been given the go by and the choice has always been made in the name of quality and a judge’s worth on the bench.
Judicial appointments seemed to be influenced by political preferences across the world, particularly in the UK, US and India. Historically in UK, ruling political parties make every effort to appoint judges who share their ideology, and who in turn, begin to staff junior and senior ranks of the judiciary with political allies.
Similarly, politics plays an important role in the appointment of judges in the United States of America. Political influence in judicial appointments in India has a long history. George H Gadbois Jr, in his book Judges of the Supreme Court of India (1950-1989), gives crucial insights about the role of Chief Justice of India and the sway of prime minister in such appointments.
Appointment of four judges within 48 hours of collegium’s recommendation does not unveil government’s concerns towards judiciary. It rather postulates that these four judges fit in within the schematic framework of the Modi government.
The writer is associate professor of law, NLU
Why Mahindra XUV700 is perfect for road trips and off-road adventures
Mahindra Scorpio N: A legacy of toughness with a modern twist
'Capable of loving more women': Kamal Haasan's bold take on marriage and relationships goes viral
How reaction time and speed tests can give gamers a competitive edge
This is world’s most polluted city with AQI of 1165, it’s just 409 kms away from Delhi
Blow to Gautam Adani as his company's shares fell 7% due to...
Pune Porsche crash: Father of teen driver's friend surrenders before court
Geographic and political nature of drug trafficking sea routes to India
Delhi AQI Update: Air quality turns 'severe', AQI reaches...
Mukesh Ambani's SUPERHIT new plan for Jio users, offers 100 GB of free cloud storage for just Rs...
Delhi-Mumbai expressway to slash travel time to 25 minutes: Key stretch to open on...
'Modi govt is committed to building terror-free India': Union Minister Amit Shah
Chhath Puja 2024: What is the importance of bamboo basket in Chhath Puja?
SC to deliver verdict today on plea against NCLAT order transferring Jet Airways to winning bidder
Is it time for Virat Kohli, Rohit Sharma to step down from playing Test cricket?
Chhath Puja 2024: Are banks open or closed today? Check state-wise list here
DNA TV Show: How did Donald Trump win US elections despite his several controversies?
Sunil Mittal's Airtel joins hands with Indian Army, becomes only private company to...
Shah Rukh Khan's Mannat to Amitabh Bachchan's Jalsa: 5 most expensive celebrity homes in India
IPL 2025 auction: 42-year-old England legend registers for first time, his base price is...
Stranger Things season 5 teaser reveals episode titles, release date confirmed as...
Singer Rahul Vaidya buys 3110 sq ft luxury apartment worth Rs 90000000, it is located in...
Nimrat Kaur asks Abhishek Bachchan ‘would you distract Aaradhya’, he praises Aishwarya Rai in reply
JEE Advanced 2025: Candidates now allowed to give 3 attempts, check details inside
Watch: MS Dhoni's video of playing golf with Donald Trump goes viral after US Polls
Viral: Italy's Lake Como's 'fresh air' can being sold for Rs 907, details inside
Ranji Trophy: Jalaj Saxena scripts history, becomes first cricketer to achieve massive feat
Gautam Adani congratulates Donald Trump on winning US elections, says, 'If there is one person...'
Meet Usha Chilukuri, who is set to become first Indian-origin second lady of US, she is wife of...
Delhi NCR: Traffic advisory issued in Ghaziabad ahead of Chhath Puja 2024, check routes to avoid
ICC Test Rankings: Rishabh Pant breaks into top 10; Virat Kohli, Rohit Sharma suffer massive loss
NASA's Sunita Williams witnesses 16 sunrises, sunsets daily in space, here’s how
'India will…': Ricky Ponting makes BOLD prediction for Border-Gavaskar Trophy
From DU to Tesla: Meet man who works for Elon Musk, manages his company's...
Essence of Leadership: Insights from Ankur Saini
Who is Thomas Draca? First Italian player to register for IPL 2025 mega auction
IPL 2025 mega auction: Full list of players with Rs 2 crore base price
Meet man who quit Paytm after Rs 2048 crore deal with Deepinder Goyal's Zomato, he is...
Anushka Sharma can't stop laughing seeing Virat Kohli's funny move in unseen viral video - Watch
SA vs IND: Arshdeep Singh aims to surpass Bhuvneshwar Kumar’s all-time T20I record
Donald Trump reclaims US presidency, netizens win hearts with meme-fest
'Everyone will come to know...': LoP Rahul Gandhi's BIG statement on caste census in Nagpur
Thama: Ayushmann Khurrana reveals all about 'bloody love story', says it is....
'History’s greatest comeback': Israel PM Netanyahu congratulates Donald Trump on US Election victory
US Election Results LIVE: Donald Trump's victory speech; WATCH HERE
Arjun Kapoor hits back at haters post Singham Again success: 'To everyone who...'
'Let's work for global peace': PM Modi congratulates 'friend' Donald Trump on winning US election