ANALYSIS
How humanity, with its strange compulsion to actively control everything, is not able to separate the truth from the fantasy anymore.
Most of Madras was in shock when we heard about author Perumal Murugan’s promise to never write again as the result of his “compromise” with the RSS. For those not in the know, the RSS took umbrage to his book of 2011, Mathorubhagan (One Part Woman in the English translation).
The reason for this compromise is that the RSS and certain politicians had, since early in December last year, taken it upon themselves to—once again—take up moral policing as their cause. They believe that the 'selfless service', which they purport to perform, is better served by taking umbrage to the world knowing certain truths about Indian culture than feeding the poor, defending the defenceless, etc.
Let’s start with what they found offensive. In the book, a couple married for over a decade (though unclear, the time seems to be around the early 20th century) without ever conceiving, decides (or not, the author never makes that clear) to participate in a traditionally held “swinging festival” at the Vaisakam Car Festival in Thiuchengode. Children born of this socially sanctioned ritual are referred to as swamykuduthapillai (god-given children), and classical Hindu traditions refer to this practice as niyoga or niyoga dharma. Just as an aside, the word dharma signifies its cultural and religious sanction.
Now as a writer myself, I found many things objectionable about the book. To start with the positive, I thought Murugan possesses a superb sense of history. But I found it objectionable that after an enthralling read for the first three-fourths of the book, the last quarter petered away into an unsatisfactory ending. Like sitting in a restaurant for an hour, waiting for a meal that I never got to eat. I felt that the author touched upon many, extremely relevant social themes that he did not completely address; that he had strived too hard to be politically correct about values that should have been blasted; I found the book to be a tad disjointed and at the end, boring. But none of that is reason to ban a book.
No, the RSS found it objectionable that the writer wrote about the practice of niyoga. Mahalingam, Chief Troglodyte of the RSS branch of Thiruchengode, felt that Hinduism was somehow offended by the book, and so they started first by burning thousands of pages of his books, followed by threatening his life and the lives of his family. When he went to the police seeking protection, the police advised him to leave Namakkal, where he lives.
Firstly, as a group claiming to be Hindus, I would have thought that burning a book would be the first thing the RSS would avoid doing, but not so. I must be thinking of another Hinduism. Secondly, if their faith is so fragile that they find it offended by a book, one would wonder why they bother fighting so hard for such a faith. But most importantly, I’d like someone to tell me how these acts of the Thiruchengode RSS are any different from the Islamic terrorists that shot at the Charlie Hebdo offices. Is it just, then, a question of degrees? Threatening to violently kill someone’s family is not the same as murder, so what these people did was ok?
As part of the compromise, Perumal Murugan has agreed to withdraw all his publications, recompense everyone who spent any money on it, and never write again…AND NEVER WRITE AGAIN!
The refrain taken up even by the intelligentsia is, “in a multi-cultural society, one should be careful to not hurt any caste or community.” This is a direct quote from a well-known cultural writer, who first points out Kunti and Madri themselves resorted to niyoga dharma because their husband (Pandu, “father” of the Pandavas) was impotent. So if they’re willing to accept that this actually is a cultural practice, why then, are they siding with the censorship of a person’s art? Everything offends someone. As an ardent activist for animal rights, I find advertisements for KFC to be the most offensive thing I can imagine. Why is nothing done about that?
Why is somebody taking offence, any reason at all to suppress something? The state’s duty is to ensure that all its citizens enjoy the basic amenities of food, clothing, shelter, and education. They are failing miserably at this. Crime is on the increase, with police stations being overloaded with cases and not enough officers to handle them all, and we can do nothing about it. These are the kind of situations where the RSS could be of use. They could help feed the (literally) millions of starving children and families, start saving cattle from the horrors of India’s meat and leather trade, and a thousand other things that are consistent with their Hindu ideology, but instead, they choose the most un-Hindu endeavour imaginable: the burning of books. Does anyone else remember Hitler and Pol Pot?
Religion today enables terrible things, as can its secular equivalent: ideology. The terrible aspect stems from the reaction that comes when an unshakeable belief is challenged by different unshakeable realities. It is nothing less than cognitive dissonance, and humanity, with its strange compulsion to actively control everything, is not able to separate the truth from the fantasy anymore.
There is absolutely no difference between Hindu fundamentalism and Islamic fundamentalism (or, not to leave anyone out, any other religion’s fundamentalism) except in degrees. Christian kings during the Middle Ages, felt justified in travelling to Jerusalem and butchering the local Muslims because they believed their religion required it of them. They are no better or worse than the simpletons that the Al Qaeda brainwashes to blow up civilians in the name of Jihad, who are no worse than the RSS members who felt justified in making death threats to a writer and his family because he wrote about something they didn’t like, who burn movie theatres for showing a movie they don’t like, or who beat up and kill couples for public displays of affection or being out together on Valentine’s Day.
The biggest problem humankind faces right now is thinking these degrees of differences make things better. They do not. Bigotry and chauvinism are just as bad, whether you have a mild case of it or a major one. The facility of free speech exists to enable others to reveal to us things that we would not always like to know—the truths. If we don’t like it, we are free to ignore it, criticise it, even to advise others to boycott it. Whether it is only the artist’s truth or a universal truth is for each one of us to gauge within ourselves. That’s the only way intelligence could ever burgeon. However, to muzzle it is to mount a slippery slope, and I’m pretty sure humanity has slipped enough.
Also Read: I am not Perumal Murugan, but I very well could be...
Meet woman who became first Indian to win Miss Grand International, she is from...
Indian girl dances with US man on Bhojpuri song in front of India Gate, VIDEO goes viral
Why Ratan Tata didn’t give anything to brother Noel Tata in his will? Reason is….
Bigg Boss 18: Double elimination in house, Nyra Banerjee's BB journey ends? Here's what we know
Meet IAS officer, who got separated from son, left-high paying job, cracked UPSC with AIR...
ADRE grade 4 exam today, check admit card link, exam day guidelines here
Assam: Mobile internet services to be suspended in state today due to…
Wearing shoes, slippers is banned in this Indian village; know why
EAM Jaishankar slams Canada's targeting of envoy, says, 'we completely reject...'
DNA TV Show: Baba Bageshwar calls for Hindu unity on Social Media
Emerging Teams Asia Cup 2024: When and where to watch Sri Lanka A vs Afghanistan A final match?
Telugu actor NT Ramaswamy gets slapped by woman during screening of his film Love Reddy; here’s why
What's Baby Ariha Shah issue between India and Germany, know about 3YO kid
Gujarat: 10 hotels in Rajkot receive bomb threats, police launch investigation
Glenn Maxwell reveals how Virat Kohli saved his career after all-rounder's horror IPL 2020
‘Naa shakal naa surat…’: Veteran actor says Priyanka Chopra refused to kiss him, got upset when he…
Dhanteras 2024: 5 inauspicious things to avoid buying on Dhantrayodashi
Maharashtra Assembly polls: BJP releases second list of 22 candidates
Rama Ekadashi 2024: Know the date, shubh muhurat, rituals and significance
How India can still qualify for WTC final despite losing home series to New Zealand?
EAM Jaishankar praises military, diplomacy for India-China patrolling breakthrough along LAC
Isha Ambani stuns in modern Banarasi saree gown at Fashion Trust Arabia Gala
'Oxford failed me': Indian student claims racial discrimination after removal from...
Gautam Adani faces huge loss after Rs 6189 crore project faces halt in Kenya due to...
Maharashtra assembly polls: Congress makes SHOCKING claim, says two MLAs offered crores to...
Vidya Balan breaks up silence on REJECTING Bhool Bhulaiya 2: 'I told Anees ji that...'
Govt extends ITR filing deadline for corporates, check new date here
Meet woman, from remote Odisha village, who cracked UPSC exam by YouTube videos, secured AIR...
Dhanteras 2024: Gold to silver, 5 auspicious things you should buy for good luck
When Madhuri Dixit met with life-threatening accident on Diwali, her body caught fire, then...
Viral artwork of banana duct-taped could be auctioned for over ₹12 crore, but here's twist
The Essence of Leadership: Insights from Ankur Saini
Mamata Banerjee warns of communal riots and explosion ahead of Diwali, heightens security in Kolkata
Diljit Dosanjh, Coldplay concerts illegal ticket sales: ED conducts raids in 5 states, finds...
Mukesh Ambani loses over Rs 180000000000 in just 1 day, here's why
Do Patti movie review: Kajol is a misfit in this convoluted Kriti Sanon drama on Netflix
'Despicable, yet entirely predictable': India slams Pakistan at UN for raising Kashmir issue
Cyclone Dana: Two more deaths reported in West Bengal, toll rises to 4, no casualties in Odisha
BruntWork shares takeaways from Mayer Brown’s 16th Annual Outsourcing Conference
Vaishno Devi Yatra: All you need to know about helicopter booking
Watch: Vidya Balan falls during her live performance with Madhuri Dixit, handles it with grace
Escalation looms as Israel strikes Tehran, raising fears of full-scale conflict
From Syria to Tehran: F-35 Fighters spearhead Israeli offensive
Meet IIT-JEE topper with AIR 1, scored 352 marks in JEE Advanced, decided to drop out of IIT due to…
After Delhi, odd-even scheme to be implemented in THIS state from November 5 to control...
Jharkhand Assembly Election: Is MS Dhoni entering politics? Poll body makes THIS key announcement