India - 370 = 2 Union Territories and 28 states

Written By Manan Kumar | Updated: Aug 06, 2019, 05:00 AM IST

Promise Fulfilled: Shortly after Monday’s historic decision, BJP general secretary Ram Madhav dug out a black and white photo of Prime Minister Narendra Modi in what appears to be a protest against special status to J&K under 370. He shared the image on Twitter and wrote ‘Promise fulfilled’

Tricolour to soar high in Jammu and Kashmir; Special status for J&K struck from Article 370; State to be divided into 2 UTs – J&K and Ladakh; Decision ends suspense over force build-up in J&K

With the stroke of two Presidential orders, the Modi government wrote fresh history on Monday that many thought was impossible and untenable by revoking the special status of Jammu and Kashmir under Articles 370 and 35A which empowered the state legislature to define the J&K's permanent residents and their rights and privileges.

The government also brought and passed The Jammu and Kashmir Reorganisation Bill, 2019, bifurcating the precariously perched state into two Union Territories. With the passage of the bill, J&K will become a UT with a legislative assembly like Delhi, and Ladakh will function like the centrally administered Chandigarh.

The unprecedented decision ended days of suspense following fast-paced actions in the long intervening night of Sunday and Monday and the deployment of an additional 40,000 central forces before asking Amarnath yatris and tourists to leave the state.

CHANAKYA

Shah is new Iron Man

Amit Shah, who means business, has emerged as the Iron Man of India. He is a Chanakya who speaks for core Indian values and is in no mood to pardon any wrongdoer. His emergence on the scene has left BJP’s rivals speechless and stunned. He is being praised in every nook and corner of the country as a strong-willed man, who does not care for the consequences. If he has to take a strong decision, he will go ahead, irrespective of the repercussions. He is very astute. In this new era, Amit Shah leads the band of Bharat bhakts. Undoubtedly, if Sardar Vallabhbhai Patel had ever been asked who his chosen disciples were, his answer would have to be Narendra Modi and Amit Shah. Amit Shah is a patriot to the core who is also emerging as a leader of big standing and a sharp and tough administrator.

Tarun Vijay, BJP leader, former editor, Panchjanya

"I would just say that the bill that the government is bringing is historic. Article 370 has prevented J&K to merge with India rather than being a basis of its merger," said Union home minister Amit Shah in Parliament.

He rejected the Opposition's charge of bringing the bill by stealth, reminding them that the BJP's manifesto of 2014 and 2019 clearly mentioned scrapping both articles.

ROAD AHEAD

Corrupt elite to be hit 

Ninety per cent of the people in Jammu and Kashmir have not benefited from Article 370. The government needs to ensure two things. One, people get a positive message about the advantages of abrogating this Article. Two, it needs to showcase development on the ground. Over the years, J&K has become a hotbed of corruption and Article 370 protected the well-fed elite, politicians and the bureaucrats. They are surely going to be hit and will obviously protest against losing the enormous privileges they have enjoyed. It is difficult to imagine that until the arrival of Governor Satya Pal Malik on the scene, there was no formal anti-corruption bureau in the state! Article 370 ensured that the state had no CBI or anything else. No institutions that worked in the rest of the country, applied to J&K, thanks to this special status.

Kulbir Krishan, former top home ministry official

Challenging the Opposition to debate on the merits of the bill, Shah said, "The politics of vote bank has looted the youth of the state for over 70 years. I would call on the opposition members to debate and discuss on why the benefits of development were not allowed to reach the common people of J&K till now. Politics of religion must be avoided at all costs. Article 370 is equally harmful to people of all religions."

IT'S A BLESSING
Kashmiri pandits are thrilled

The Kashmiri Pandit community is thrilled and we owe it to the Narendra Modi government. There is genuine happiness today for all of us. The fact that I can buy property in the state, even if theoretically, is a very good feeling. That my children can go and live there and see the land of their ancestors is very positive. We may not actually go back, but at least we have the option to do so. Sure, as long as we lived there we had no future, as Pandits were discriminated against. So in a way, we are lucky to have left the state when we did. It turned out to be a blessing in disguise. But the Kashmiri Pandit community is progressive. Despite everything, no grudges are held. We have moved on. But again, we owe it to this BJP government for scrapping Article 370.

Renu Kaul Verma, managing director, Vitasta publishing house

Flummoxed by the surprise move and the jubilant mood on the streets, the Opposition went in disarray as staunch rivals like AAP, TDP and BSP chose to side with the BJP-led NDA and left a handful of members from Congress, TMC, DMK, JDU and Left parties to offer feeble resistance.

PEEK INTO HISTORY

Ambedkar refused to draft 370, Nehru coaxed

BR Ambedkar, father of the Indian Constitution, was asked to draft Article 370 and he refused point-blank. He told Sheikh Abdullah that such an Article would create an independent Islamic state in India, which he refused to have anything to do with. He called it ‘treachery’ against India. The President refused to sign it. Ultimately, it was left to Gopalaswami Ayyangar, member of the Drafting Committee of the Constitution and Rajya Sabha leader, to do the honours. Ambedkar was right, historically speaking. All those in Jammu and Ladakh became second-rate citizens; the only thing that has mattered is the Kashmir Valley. As for Nehru, he kept saying the Article was temporary. When the draft was put up before the Congress Working Committee, the party rose in revolt. Nehru had to plead before Patel, citing international commitments, to clear the draft. Against his better judgment, Patel relented. Then everyone in Congress fell in line. The rest is history.

Madhu Kishwar, academic and writer

Dr Mookerjee’s vision

Dr Syama Prasad Mookerjee was the first martyr in Kashmir after Independence. He was a visionary in the truest sense. He was the first to realise that a nation could not have two Constitutions and two prime ministers. It was inapplicable and a blot on the country that such an arrangement would be accepted. He realised that the Indian Republic would be incomplete if Article 370 was allowed to continue. Mookerjee was visionary enough to see that if India accepted such an agreement, it would tantamount to compromising on the country’s security. It was for this reason he went on a satyagraha. Till date, no one knows how he died. The local Sheikh Abdullah government and their cohorts in New Delhi ensured that. The decision of Jawaharlal Nehru not to order an inquiry into the unexplained death of this great leader haunts people of this country even today. At a time when everyone was praising Kashmir’s integration into the Indian Union and Article 370, Mookerjee saw the inherent dangers. That is why he was the first man to raise his voice against this anti-national act.

Rakesh Sinha, Rajya Sabha MP, BJP

Leading the Opposition attack, former home minister and Congress leader P Chidambaram dubbed the bill a dangerous move with "catastrophic" consequences. "Momentarily you may think you have scored a victory, but you are wrong and history will prove you to be wrong. Future generations will realise what a grave mistake this House is making today," he warned.

Similar sentiments were expressed by Derek O'Brien of TMC and members of the DMK and Left parties. However, Shah told them to rest assured saying nothing was going to happen. He added, "Article 370 is only a mental barrier…Don't get trapped in fear psychosis that this will happen that will happen. Nothing is going to happen. JK will integrate fully with India."

THEN & NOW

Article 370 was a temporary provision introduced in the Constitution on October 17, 1949, granting J&K a special status. Article 35A was inserted in 1954 to define permanent residents of J&K. Striking off J&K’s special status will redefine several aspects:
Policies: J&K had the right to take a call on its own matters except defence, communications and foreign affairs. Those special powers are gone
Citizenship: Earlier J&K residents would lose their dual citizenship if they married people from other states. No more dual citizenship from now 
Land: People from other states were not allowed to buy property in J&K. That condition has been scrapped
Flag: Article 370 allowed J&K to have its own flag. It will no longer have that special privilege. J&K can only hoist the Tricolour now
Financial emergency: Revoking Article 370 will allow the Centre to declare financial emergency in the state  
Quota: There was no reservation for minorities such as Hindus and Sikhs in J&K. Now, they will be eligible for 16% reservation 
Information: Earlier RTI was not applicable to Jammu and Kashmir. That has changed
Education: Right to Education was not applicable. Now children in J&K will benefit from RTE