ANALYSIS
By preventing a Greenpeace activist from travelling to the UK, the Modi government has revealed a worrying dictatorial tendency to steamroller dissident opinion
If the idea was to prevent Greenpeace activist Priya Pillai from telling British Parliamentarians about her organisation’s work with the local community in Mahan, then the Narendra Modi government has been denied that satisfaction. Offloaded from a London bound flight on Sunday, Pillai addressed British Parliament through Skype three days later. In her 90-minute address Pillai talked about the resistance put up by Mahan’s forest community to stall a proposed coal mining project by the London-based Essar company, that threatens to uproot the local people.
“... I urge you to exercise your influence over the London-based company Essar Energy to help stop the environmental and human rights violation going on in Mahan…,” said Pillai. Some among the British Parliamentarians who had invited Pillai to deliver the talk, found the offloading episode “worrisome.”
But seemingly impassive, the government at home, has maintained a studied silence on the matter. The Intelligence Bureau has informed the home ministry that it has issued a look-out notice against the Greenpeace activist. “There were national security considerations,” the IB said, further informing that Pillai has been on IB’s radar after being named in a report submitted to the government last year. In other words, the IB was monitoring Pillai’s work in Mahan.
Strangely, the government has chosen not to clarify its position on the matter. The Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) spokespersons, though, have been vociferously defending the IB’s decision in the media. Some have even accused organisations like the Greenpeace of being “anti-national foreign agents” who are working against the Modi government’s development agenda.
Such an authoritarian attitude is indeed worrisome, to put it mildly. The premise that questioning the Modi model of development is tantamount to anti-national activity bodes ill for our democracy. Those who believe in homogenising and straitjacketing the nation into linear thinking may do well to remember that such dictatorial tendencies are being challenged — and increasingly so — across the world. The model of economic globalisation itself is under scrutiny. Even in an autocratic country like China, demonstrations routinely take place to protest the government’s policies of land acquisition.
The BJP-led government must learn to exist with and tolerate dissent. And the principle of dissent applies to every aspect of the nation’s life — economic, political, social and cultural. Gagging dissidents can only deepen the existing fault lines. In a democracy, governments need to engage with dissent, very often routed through civil society groups and non-governmental organisations. Unfortunately, even the previous government of the United Progressive Alliance (UPA) had a chequered track record in dealing with dissidence. It’s worthwhile to recall here how the Congress’s moves to arrest the anti-corruption crusader Anna Hazare backfired on the party and its government.
Like Greenpeace, many grass roots organisations believe in an alternative economic model/s. Preventing Priya Pillai from sharing her experiences with people and forums inside and outside India will not erase these beliefs. The IB’s explanation that Greenpeace International’s funding of Pillai’s ticket violates the government ban on foreign funding of Indian Greenpeace, cuts little ice. Jurists have underlined the distinction between foreign funding and foreign hospitality under the Foreign Contribution (Regulation) Act (FCRA). However, there are some people who are ineligible to accept foreign hospitality. But this would require the government to stop other people as well — which has not been the case.
What is hurting the government most is the alternative development paradigm propagated by Greenpeace: the primary reason for the government zeroing in on the organisation and stemming its foreign fund flow. If the government wants to dispel the notion that it is targeting dissidents, it must come clear on Priya Pillai.
‘India and Pakistan should bury the past’: Nawaz Sharif after S Jaishankar's visit
'Dil to bachcha hai ji': Rahul Gandhi's heartfelt interaction with kids, WATCH viral video
JEE Main 2025: NTA releases important notice on JEE Main exam pattern
Blow to Mukesh Ambani as Reliance Jio loses 10.9 million subscribers due to...
Joe Biden reacts to Hamas Chief Yahya Sinwar's killing, says 'that obstacle no longer exists but...'
Viral video: Desi girl's sizzling dance to 'Aaj Ki Raat' impresses internet, watch
Watch: Heartwarming video of girl treating slippers like a baby goes viral
Earn Rs 250000000 through THIS NASA challenge: Here’s how you can participate
DNA TV Show: Bahraich murder accused shot in police encounter near Nepal border; 5 held
Good news for Narayana Murthy, Infosys net profit rises to Rs 6,506 crore
Tamannaah Bhatia questioned by ED in Guwahati in money laundering case, details inside
Hamas leader Yahya Sinwar killed in Gaza, Israel PM Netanyahu confirms
UGC NET June 2024 Result DECLARED: NTA announces UGC NET 2024 June exam result online, check here
Did IDF eliminate Yahya Sinwar, or has Martyr been born in Gaza?
Hamas chief Yahya Sinwar among 3 killed by Israel? Israel Defense Forces updates
Kangana Ranaut's Emergency finally cleared by CBFC, new release date...
Here's the film after which Shah Rukh Khan started drinking, his co-stars were Aishwarya Rai and...
Akash Ambani, Shloka Mehta live on 27th floor of Rs 15000 crore Antilia, here's why
Young entrepreneur’s Rahul Sachdeva journey to make foreign education accessible
Is Rajinikanth's Poes Garden home flooded amid Chennai rains? Here's the truth behind viral video
'My family is broken but..': Zeeshan Siddiqui's first reaction to father Baba Siddiqui's death
DNA Auto Award 2024 Has Spoken: Jawa 42 FJ, bringing Neo-classic revolution in Motor Industry
Apple iPad 10th gen vs iPad 9th gen: Should you buy or wait for iPad 11?
Nita Ambani's hairstylist explains why haircuts can't fix damage and offers solutions
Bigg Boss Kannada's Kiccha Sudeepa retires from hosting duties, says 'let's make this season...'
Air India flight from Mumbai transmits emergency signal over London, claims Flight tracker
Elon Musk applauds India's decision: Spectrum allocation favors open access and innovation
BIG UPDATE on IPL auction, Saudi Arabia to host event, will take place on...
Two Bahraich violence accused shot by police in encounter while fleeing to Nepal; 5 held
'I won’t be returning': South African legend bids farewell to Sunrisers Hyderabad ahead of IPL 2025
Indian stargazers spot rare, ancient comet after 80,000 years, see breathtaking pics
'46 all-out new 36 all-out?': Cricket Australia trolls India after batting collapse vs New Zealand
Karwa Chauth 2024: Know the date, timings, history and significance
Mukesh Ambani's Jio superhit 5G plan, offers 90 days validity with unlimited data
IND vs NZ: Virat Kohli equals THIS unwanted record with 9-ball duck against New Zealand in 1st Test
Proba-3: ISRO to launch ESA Solar Eclipse Mission with precision satellites
'Law not blind': Supreme court makes 2 BIG CHANGES, unveils new justice lady and replaced…
J-K: Several CRPF Jawans injured in road accident in Budgam, probe underway
Who is Justice Sanjiv Khanna named CJI Chandrachud's successor, could become next Chief Justice?
Mukesh Ambani's BIG move: Reliance investors to get this DIWALI bonanza, know details here
'Ravan ko kisne maara?' This kid's hilarious answer will leave your in splits, WATCH viral video
Nayab Singh Saini takes oath as Haryana CM in presence of PM Modi, BJP brass
IND vs NZ: India all out for 46 runs, lowest test score at home
Hunter's Moon 2024: NASA drops first glimpse of brightest Supermoon, shares its significance
Meet man, IIT graduate who worked for Indian Railways, then went on to join Elon Musk's...
IND vs NZ: Devon Conway takes one hand blunder, gets Sarfaraz Khan on duck, watch video here
IND vs NZ test: Virat Kohli, Rohit Sharma fail to impress, India 3 wickets down in first 10 overs
Nita Ambani, Isha Ambani have 'great skin and features' reveals celebrity makeup artist
CJI Chandrachud decides on his successor, nominates…
Delhi Police initiates probe in 7 hoax threats to flights, registers FIR
Meet Nikita Porwal, Aishwarya Rai's fan, Miss India 2024 winner who works as...