INDIA
The CAG highlighted that the entire process of allocation of the Unified Access Service licences lacked transparency and was undertaken in an arbitrary, unfair and inequitable manner.
Indicting A Raja, the CAG today said 2G spectrum allocation had caused revenue loss of Rs1.76 lakh crore as the then Telecom Minister had ignored the advice of the prime minister besides those of ministries of law and finance, giving "undue" benefits to Anil Ambani-led RCom.
The CAG highlighted that the entire process of allocation of Unified Access Service licences "lacked transparency" and was undertaken in an "arbitrary, unfair and inequitable manner", in the process "flouting every canon of financial propriety, rules and procedures."
The 77-page report of the CAG tabled in Parliament said due diligence was not followed and even the recommendations of the telecom regulator TRAI were "not followed in spirit".
The report said the "presumptive" loss caused to the exchequer through spectrum allocation to 122 licencees and 35 dual technology licences in 2007-08 was Rs1,76,645 crore. It pegged the figures on the basis of 3G auction held earlier this year in which the government mopped up over Rs67,000 crore.
It said there was an "imperative need to fix responsibility and enforce accountability for the lapses highlighted in the audit report."
Elaborating on the lapses and irregularities, the government auditor said Prime Minister Manmohan Singh had "stressed on the need for a fair and transparent allocation of spectrum" while the ministry of finance had sought for the decision regarding spectrum pricing to be considered by an EGoM (Empowered Group of Ministers).
"Brushing aside their concerns and advices, the Department of Telecommunications, in 2008, proceeded to issue 122 new licences for 2G spectrum at 2001 prices, by flouting every canon of financial propriety, rules and procedures," the CAG said.
The DoT also did not do the requisite due diligence in the examination of the applications submitted for the licences, leading to the grant of 85 out of 122 licences to the "ineligible applicants" as all these firms did not have stipulated paid-up capital at the time of application.
Further 45 out of 85 licencees were issued to companies which failed to satisfy conditions of main object clause in the memorandum of Association (MoA), it said.
The CAG said the process of giving dual technology licences to leading telecom firms including Reliance Communications and Tata Teleservices "lacked transparency and fairness", and equal opportunity was denied to other similarly placed operators who could apply for use of dual technology only after formal announcement of the policy.
Noting that this approval (dual technology use) had violated cabinet decision of 2003 to allow additional spectrum at 2001 prices, the auditor said, "Deviation from a cabinet decision should normally be with the approval of cabinet.
"However, in the present case, such a crucial decision to permit service providers to offer access using combination of technologies (CDMA, GSM and/or any other) under the same licence with dual spectrum allocation was taken without the matter being referred to the cabinet."
It said the dual technology was introduced in October 2007 in a "hasty and arbitrary manner" and in-principle approval was given to three operators on a day prior to announcement of the policy, which gave "the perception of discrimination against other players in the field."
The companies which got the licences, were created barely months earlier and "deliberately suppressed facts, disclosed incomplete information, submitted fictitious documents and used fraudulent means for getting licences and thereby access to spectrum.
"Onus of these licences, obtained at unbelievably low price, have in turn sold significant stakes in their companies to Indian/foreign companies at high premium within a short period of time," the auditor said.
The premium earned by these "new entrants" to the telecom sector was nothing but the true value of the spectrum, which should have normally accrued to the public exchequer, "had the transparent and fair market mechanism been followed" for the allocation of these licences, the CAG said.
In the report, the CAG noted that the ministry of communication and IT "decided to go ahead with arbitrarily deciding that the cut-off date for issuance of Letters of Intent would be advanced to September 25, 2007 and applications received would be decided on FCFS (first-come first-served) basis."
In November, 2007, Prime Minister Manmohan Singh had written to the telecom ministry suggesting introduction of "transparent methodology" of auction, "revision of entry fee" in the "backdrop of inadequate spectrum and large number of applications received for fresh licences."
The CAG highlighted that the law ministry had suggested setting up of an Empowered Group of Ministers to discuss the large number of applications and spectrum pricing, but the telecom ministry rejected it saying "the need for forming and EGoM arises when a new policy is being framed and in this particular issue no new policy for grant of UASL (unified access service licences) was being framed."
The auditor, however, said the "contention of the DoT is untenable as the rejection of the advice" of the Law Minister to have detailed deliberations on the issues in the EGoM on the ground that changes in policy might lead to litigation "goes against the well established and time-tested procedures of functioning of the government and the collective responsibility of the Union cabinet."
Harbhajan Singh predicts this star player will attract bidding war in IPL auction, he is...
Ratan Tata, veteran industrialist, passes away at 86, TCS mourns
'You're not a…': Nitish Kumar Reddy reveals what Gautam Gambhir said before 2nd T20I vs BAN
Aniruddhacharya aka Pookie Baba apologises publically after appearing on Bigg Boss 18, watch video
Mukesh Ambani surpasses Gautam Adani, takes top spot on THIS list, his net worth jumps to...
'An era has just passed away': Amitabh Bachchan mourns Ratan Tata's demise, pens an emotional note
Ratan Tata’s pet dog 'Goa' attends his funeral, bids him emotional final goodbye
Happy Maha Ashtami 2024: Top 10 best wishes, messages to share with your loved ones on Durgashtmi
At least 22 killed in airstrikes in central Beirut, 117 injured
Manager sues this bank for Rs 416711420 after getting fired due to...
One flight made Amitabh Bachchan 'Sharaabi', changed his life, made him superstar
Centre declares Hizb-Ut-Tahrir as terrorist organisation for involvement in...
Mukesh Ambani gets richer by Rs 23088 crore in Forbes Billionaires list, his net worth is Rs…
Meet man who began his career at SBI, now set to lead Rs 30246 crore company as...
Happy birthday Amitabh Bachchan: When Bombay To Goa was offered to Rajiv Gandhi and not him
NASA's Hubble Space Telescope spots Jupiter's great Red Spot shaking like...
'It was my...': Javed Akhtar REVEALS reason behind his failed first marriage with Honey Irani
Dawood Ibrahim is scared of me, says Bigg Boss 18 contestant Gunratan Sadavarte
Who is Zarin Daruwala, Standard Chartered's India CEO set to retire in April 2025?
Madhura Naik recalls family's encounter with Hamas militants, says 'it was...’
Big setback for India as Rohit Sharma may miss first Test of Border Gavaskar Trophy in Australia
DSP to IPS officer: Meet woman who cracked UPSC exam in first attempt, her AIR was...
'I would feel like jumping off...': When Mrunal Thakur revealed she had suicidal thoughts due to...
Bigg Boss 18: These five contestants are nominated for eviction in first week of Salman Khan's show
Rohit Sharma meets injured Musheer Khan after accident, pic goes viral
Women's T20 World Cup 2024: How can India qualify for semifinals after 82-run win over Sri Lanka?
When Ratan Tata kneeled down with MBA graduates to pose for photo; see viral pic
Joe Root scripts history in Multan Test, joins Virat Kohli in THIS elite list
Ratan Tata did THIS work in 20 days, but govt took years to do it
PAK vs ENG: Harry Brook breaks Virender Sehwag's 20-year-old record with triple century vs Pakistan
When I Told World Icon Ratan Tata ‘You Are the Real James Bond of the Business Community’: Jay Patel
Good news! UP govt declares public holiday on THIS day; check details
How Ratan Tata's dog 'Goa' got his name, know story behind it
Nobel Prize 2024 in Literature awarded to Han Kang: Who is she?
PAK vs ENG: Joe Root equals Sachin Tendulkar's record with heroics in Multan Test
Daily Habits to Rejuvenate Your Eye Contour
WATCH: Mukesh Ambani, Nita Ambani and family pay homage to Ratan Tata at NCPA
Tennis legend Rafael Nadal announces retirement, ends illustrious career with 22 Grand Slam titles
Virat Kohli's old video singing 'sajna ve sajna' with Harbhajan Singh goes viral again, watch video
Bitcoin creator's true identity exposed in an HBO documentary, he is…
Ratan Tata's influence continues as Tata Group shares including Tata Power, Tata Steel rise
'His loss will be...': Bill Gates shares photo with Ratan Tata, calls him 'visionary leader'
IND vs BAN: Riyan Parag bowls with bizarre action, ends up bowling rare no-ball, watch viral video
ZEE proposes biographical film on Ratan Tata's life as humble tribute to his legacy
Will Samajwadi Party's alliance with Congress continue? SP chief Akhilesh Yadav breaks his silence
From 'Ugly Duckling' to 'White Swan': Kabir Bedi traces Rekha's remarkable journey as she turns 70
Ratan Tata didn’t recognise Amitabh Bachchan while traveling together, superstar then...
An untold story: Here's how Ratan Tata extended unwavering support to victims of 26/11 attack
Another masterstroke by Gautam Adani, plans to raise more than Rs 1,67,92,60,00,000 through…
Beyond Cash and Cards: Rise of AI-Powered Payment
Meet woman, Tata Son's first female director who shaped Ratan Tata's personality, for whom he left…
Hunter's Moon October 2024: When, where to watch biggest supermoon of the year
7th Pay Commission: Good news for central govt employees, 3% DA hike likely to be announced on...
'Would sit and...': When Shah Rukh Khan made Mahima Chaudhary wait for 20 days on sets of Pardes
An untold story: Here's how Ratan Tata took 'revenge' on Ford after his humiliation by...
'Nuclear Submarines, Predator Drones': India clears mega deal worth Rs 80000 crore with US