ANALYSIS
An ex-civil servant has been convicted of an offence which isn’t a misconduct under legal provisions
When the British left this country they took justice with them and left behind laws, in-laws and outlaws.
Former Coal Secretary Harish Chandra Gupta’s is a curious case of someone being convicted of a purported offence that is not an offence under the current provisions of law.
Even if it treated as offence, there is no evidence of any pecuniary benefit to him or any other form of quid pro quo. Yet, he and a few other officers have been convicted.
The conviction of Harish Chandra Gupta and a few other IAS officers in the so-called “coal scam” case has created unprecedented outrage amongst the civil servants.
Amitabh Pandey, another retired officer, has correctly stated, “Never before in its history has the Indian Administrative Service (IAS) witnessed a perversion of justice as has been evidenced in the conviction of H C Gupta……..He is not just another retired civil servant, but an icon who represents the gold standard for rectitude and probity in public service.”
All the officers convicted in this case have unimpeachable reputations. Someone of the stature of S Y Quraishi, former Chief Election Commissioner, has gone on to describe Gupta as “one of the most honest officers”.
These officers had committed no “crime” and the law under which they have been convicted had been amended to do away with the “injustice” inherent in the provision of Section 13(1) (d) (ii) of the Prevention of Corruption Act.
This provision was not originally a part of the Act, but was introduced subsequently through an amendment. The crisis actually is an outcome of this provision that does not exist in law anymore. The provision stipulates that if a private party gets a benefit that is not in public interest, a civil servant could be held liable even if there was no evidence of quid pro quo or mala fide.
Ironically, in some of the judgments, it has been clearly brought out that the charge of personal benefit has not been levelled against Harish Gupta; neither is there any evidence available to this effect. Yet Gupta and the officers have been pronounced guilty.
It all started with the hype created around the CAG report that dumped the coal block allocations and the subsequent intervention of the Supreme Court. Posterity will determine whether it was actually a “scam” of the scale it was made out to be or a “tsunami” that swept the good, the bad and the ugly.
Now, let us understand whether it was a “crime” at all. Certain sets of “facts” and documents came before a committee that was chaired by Gupta. Some of the documents provided incorrect information. These errors were not apparent on the face of the record. The committee, accordingly, made recommendations. These recommendations were accepted at an “appropriate level”. This “appropriate level”, the decision-making authority, was privy to the same set of information that the committee headed by Gupta had. All this raises a few questions that need urgent answers.
Was it practically possible to verify all the facts that came before the committee? Won’t the administration come to a grinding halt if all Committees of the government start verifying the facts that come before them?
If, for the sake of argument, Gupta and other two officers are held liable, why shouldn’t the other members of the Committee be held equally liable? Why shouldn’t the “appropriate level” that took the final decision be also held liable?
The British Northcote-Trevelyan Report published in 1854 - on the basis of which the Indian Civil Service (ICS) of pre-independent India, and its successor, the Indian Administrative Service is governed - clearly states that “politicians are elected and must, therefore, take decisions. Civil servants must remain anonymous in the sense that they should not be held publicly accountable for their advice or policy “. Can the politician, therefore, ‘hide’ behind a recommendation of a civil servant?
The civil service performs a critical role in delivery of services. Despite being castigated and pilloried, it has done well in a number of spheres. There are many performers in the bureaucracy and, more often than not, their efforts go unrecognised.
However, like any other segment of the society, civil service too has its share of those that prefer not to stick their necks out. Such developments will only induce many more of them to “play safe”.
The decision will impact decision- making. Officers will be averse to expressing their views on the files. This is already in evidence in a number of departments of the government. The consequences could be grievous. Governance is suffering and could become worse on account of the sense of insecurity that such developments convey. It is hoped the amendment to the Prevention of Corruption Act will take care of recurrence of such developments.
Author is a former Union Secretary
‘Another example of…’: MEA on Canada labelling India ‘cyber adversary’
'Bhai kyu jhooti tassali....': Mrunal Thakur criticizes fan who photoshopped her in Diwali pic
Mukesh Ambani, Anil Ambani set to earn money from Singham Again's box office collection, here’s how
Adani Power cuts Bangladesh electricity supply by half due to $846 million unpaid bills
Here's what is happening inside Ratan Tata’s Bombay House since after death of business magnate
Virat Kohli dispels retirement rumours, suggests he may continue playing cricket till....
Meet man, highest UPSC exam scorer, who broke IAS Tina Dabi's record, he is...
Swati Maliwal pours bottle of polluted water outside Delhi CM Atishi’s residence; WATCH
IPL 2025: R Ashwin tops CSK's wishlist as franchise plans to utilize RTM for THIS New Zealand star
'Dusre ki biwi ko cheen ke...': Arya Babbar roasts Arjun Kapoor for Singham Again villain role
'Abki baar...': AI imagines Donald Trump, Kamala Harris as Indian politicians, netizens react, WATCH
Amid bomb threats, ammunition cartridges found in Dubai-Delhi Air India flight
This Indian king, was first man to make history by marrying foreign woman during his trip to...
Mukesh Ambani's Jio once again TOPPED in global telecom industry, sets record in...
Bhai Dooj 2024: Date, shubh muhurat, significance, rituals and more
New ‘Satoshi Nakamoto’ emerges: Meet man who declares himself to be Bitcoin founder but fails to...
Watch: Former CSK star gets hit for 6 sixes in an over against England during Hong Kong Sixes
'Makes no sense': Ex-India star slams Rohit Sharma, Gautam Gambhir for absurd Sarfaraz Khan decision
World's richest man Elon Musk faces lawsuit from Ex-Twitter CEO Parag Agrawal for...
Security forces kill 2 terrorists, including a foreign national in Jammu and Kashmir
WWE Crown Jewel 2024: Full match card, timing, live streaming details - All you need to know
'Absurd and baseless': India dismisses Canadian minister's allegations against Amit Shah
IND vs NZ: Virat Kohli scripts history in Mumbai Test, becomes first player in world to...
This 51-year-old woman leaves husband to marry 30-year-old Indian security guard
Mukesh Ambani's best plan for Jio users, 200GB data, 90 days of unlimited calls at just Rs...
'Thanks for...': Abhishek Bachchan's viral statement amid divorce rumours with Aishwarya Rai
Jammu and Kashmir: 2 terrorists killed in encounter with security forces in Anantnag
21-Day Mars, Moon simulation in Ladakh
Prashant Kishor's fee for advising in one election will leave you shocked, it is Rs...
Dua Padukone Singh: Here's how Deepika Padukone, Ranveer Singh named their baby girl
Another BIG move by Mukesh Ambani, set to provide some help for debt-ridden Ghana as Reliance Jio...
J-K: Gun battle breaks out between security forces and terrorists in Srinagar's Khanyar
Noel Tata takes BIG decision at TCS after Ratan Tata's death, plans to hire...
'Will chop them up...': Mithun Chakraborty hits out at TMC’s Humayun Kabir at Kolkata rally
Delhi Air Pollution: Delhi-NCR AQI turns ‘very poor’ as city wakes up to toxic smog post-Diwali
Gautam Adani's next BIG step: Adani Power stops Bangladesh’s power supply due to...
Indian troops start patrolling Demchok sector in eastern Ladakh following India-China disengagement
Amy Jackson announces first pregnancy with husband Ed Westwick, flaunts baby bump in adorable pics
In THIS Indian village, families live with cobras, the reason is...
Hardik Pandya flaunts his special 'World Champion' ring after being retained by MI, video goes viral
Happy Govardhan Puja 2024: Top 50 WhatsApp wishes, messages, quotes for loved ones
Despite massive Diwali opening, is Singham Again paying the price for banking on huge star cast?
Shah Rukh Khan's heartfelt gesture towards jewellery store staff wins internet, watch
DNA TV Show: Public calls out celebrities’ hypocrisy on Diwali pollution
Fashion designer Rohit Bal dies at 63: Last year, he was on ventilator for heart ailments
BCCI scraps India's intra squad warm-up game ahead of Border-Gavaskar Trophy, reason revealed
Legendary fashion designer Rohit Bal dies at 63 after prolonged illness
Another terrorist attack in J-K, militants shoot two non-locals in Budgam