ANALYSIS
Close to nine decades since that fateful conversation, and it is apparent that the evils of caste remain far from being vanquished. It is in this context that the recent debate and discussion on the caste system needs to be had.
India has had the good fortune of having some exceptional founding founders. Of all these eminent personalities though, two leaders have the distinction of being called “fathers” in juxtaposition to their contribution to our great nation. Mahatma Gandhi has been rightly anointed as the “Father of the Nation” and Dr. Ambedkar has been often referred to as the “Father of the Constitution”.
Both these great leaders considered the caste system to be a horrible social evil that needed uprooting. While Gandhi ji and Dr. Ambedkar had differences of opinion, it is a matter of fact that Gandhi ji relied on Dr. Ambedkar when it came to understanding the burden of caste. Gandhi ji displayed genuine interest and concern for the backward castes but it was Dr. Ambedkar who lived it. This was evident in an interaction between the two towering personalities after the signing of the Poona Pact in 1932. When Dr. Ambedkar visited Gandhiji, the former spoke in detail about the struggles and ignominy that Dalits faced. He is reported to have told Gandhi ji that” "You may not know what even I have to face. I do not get any other place to live in Bombay except the Port Trust chawl. In my village, I have to stay in the midst of the Mahars. In Poona, all others stay with their friends. I have to stay at the National Hotel and have to spend Rs 7 and transport fare.” Gandhi ji displaying his characteristic empathy responded with unequivocal support telling Dr. Ambedkar while talking about the evils of caste that “The main thing still remains to be done. I am ready to give my life for it. All the injustices you mention ought to end.”
This interaction is telling because it lays bare stark facts. The first is that despite being an intellectual force of nature and a man of unquestionable ability, Dr. Ambedkar suffered the ignominy of caste-like many others in his community. The second is Gandhi ji’s characteristic desire to first understand and then react.
Fast forward to today, close to nine decades since that fateful conversation, and it is apparent that the evils of caste remain far from being vanquished. It is in this context that the recent debate and discussion on the caste system needs to be had.
The evils of caste are most apparent when talking about acts of violence against individuals from lower castes, especially those from the scheduled caste and scheduled tribe. Data from the National Crime Records Bureau, for example, record a trend of increasing violence against those from the backward caste. The act of Pravesh Shukla urinating on a tribal man, though, shows that these acts of violence are not just mere statistics but a painful reality for members of the backward caste.
While physical violence is the most visible form of such discrimination, the systematic manner in which individuals from the OBC, Scheduled Caste, and Scheduled Tribe communities remain unrepresented is a form of violence that kills with a thousand cuts. Consider the following: as of 2019, out of a total of 6,043 teaching positions in IITs, only 2.81 % are teachers from the SC and ST community. Similarly, amongst Group A officers (the highest tier of bureaucrats), the number of individuals from the SC community is 12.86% against a legally mandated reservation of 15%, individuals from the ST community are 5.64% against a legally mandated reservation of 7.5%, and those from the OBC community are at 16.88% against a legally mandated reservation of 27%.
The air gets rarer still when we go higher up the bureaucratic structure. It is a travesty, for example, that (as of 2022) out of 91 Additional Secretaries, only 14 come from the SC/ST and OBC community in total. Similarly out of 245 Joint Secretaries only 55 come from these communities. The parallel is not restricted to the government or educational institutions but to our society in general. As yourself, for example, how many prime-time news anchors come from these repressed communities? How many people from these communities become CEOs in India Inc.? How many top doctors or lawyers or judges are from these communities? Data reflects the true state of affairs.
It is in this backdrop that the Congress party has made demands for a caste census. Prime Minister Modi, while responding to the demands, is reported to have said that the only caste for him is the poor. The Prime Minister’s statement follows a familiar tune. One that seeks to avoid the uncomfortable question of a lack of representation for these communities by ignoring their unique identity. It also displays an alarming lack of awareness of a real likelihood that individuals from these backward communities are unable to be adequately represented because of systematic discrimination and not because of a lack of resources (although this is a symptom of discrimination) or a lack of ability (a ridiculous argument). The fact that individuals from these communities are within the bureaucratic structure but still remain underrepresented when it comes to top jobs is proof that Prime Minister Modi is shifting goal posts.
Mr. Modi’s reluctance to adequately deal with calls for a caste census from the Congress and members of the INDIA alliance is understandable when you understand that the moral center of the BJP is the RSS, an organization that itself has a troubled history with caste. Gowalkar, the RSS’ ideologue, for example, said that “God” manifests itself through caste. A Wikipedia search of the sarsanghchalaks, or heads of the RSS, displays an uncomfortable uniformity of upper caste men as well. The BJP cannot evade this ingrained philosophy, despite its best efforts. An example of this was the “all vegetarian” meals given to delegates as part of the recent state G20 state functions. This is despite the fact that “vegetarianism” is deeply linked with issues of caste and is in fact contrary to how the rest of the country consumes its meals. It is a microcosm of a philosophy that makes Prime Minister’s reluctance to adequately address the opposition’s demands for a caste census unsurprising.
It is important to understand that the alarming underrepresentation of individuals from these communities in all facets of public life is not due to a lack of ability but a lack of opportunity. The United States offers a limited parallel in this regard and the American Civil Liberties Union’s Amicus brief before the United States Supreme Court, captures this beautifully. The brief, while detailing the data showcasing the large disparity between the “white” community and the “black” community in various spheres, states that “the inescapable conclusion is that this is not a “color blind” society where opportunity is singularly determined according to individual ability. Rather, it is a socially-constructed racial hierarchy with whites firmly on top. The only other conceivable explanation – that this gross inequality is the consequence of a natural order of black inferiority and white supremacy – is, of course, wholly unacceptable.”
A caste census, therefore, is the first step to recognizing that there is a problem. Only then can we, as a nation, hope to find a solution.
Article by Dr Ajoy Kumar, Former IPS and Former Member of Parliament, Member of Congress Working Committee
Disclaimer: Views expressed in this article are of the author, and are not associated with DNA English.
Meet woman who couldn't become doctor due to tragedy, later cracked UPSC in first attempt, she is...
SC to hear today pleas seeking curbs to tackle air pollution as GRAP 4 imposed in Delhi
Ganadhipa Sankashti Chaturthi 2024: Date, shubh muhurat, rituals, significance and more
Viral video: Little girl wins hearts with adorable dance to 'Tere Bina Na Guzara AE', watch
Meet man who left home with only Rs 50, later built company worth Rs 17000 crore, his business is…
World’s most expensive watch costs Rs 465 crore, it is made by…
AUS vs PAK Live Streaming: When and where to watch Australia vs Pakistan 3rd T20I live in India?
Which players will Mumbai Indians target in IPL 2025 mega auction?
No road tax, registration fees on electric vehicles in THIS Indian state till...
PCB set to sack Jason Gillespie; 52-year-old former Pakistan cricketer to assume role as head coach
After Imsha Rehman, Minahil Malik, THIS Indonesian celeb’s private video leaked online
GRAP 4 imposed in Delhi from November 18: What's open, what's closed
'Need a full album': Man's hilarious mimicry singing of celebrities goes viral, watch video
'Tohar Lalla Badshah': A collaboration between Badshah and Manoj Tiwari you didn't see coming
Hrithik Roshan’s sister Sunaina’s weight loss journey: Here’s how she lost over 50 kg in 12 months
WI vs ENG Live Streaming: When and where to watch West Indies vs England 5th T20I live in India?
'I always believe...': Sudha Murty praises son-in-law Rishi Sunak's 'good Indian cultural values'
Allu Arjun impresses with his Hindi at Pushpa 2 trailer launch event in Patna, watch viral video
Matt Gaetz: From F-35 Fighter Jets to Attorney General Nomination Amid Sex Scandal Allegations
'I'm scared of him': Muhammad Ali's old video praising Mike Tyson goes viral, WATCH here
How 'Banana for Scale' meme found its way to Elon Musk's SpaceX starship rocket
Zomato delivery agent riding bike with her child melts hearts online, watch viral video
Man who mistakenly declared dead walks into his own prayer meet; here's what happened
VIRAL: In terrifying video, Leopard sneaks into house attacks pet dog in Mount Abu, check here
BCCI gives massive update on KL Rahul's availability for 1st Test vs Australia in Perth
Baba Siddique murder: Mumbai crime branch makes 25th arrest of Gujarati man from...
IPL 2025 auction: Full list of players with Rs 2 crore base price
India break Pakistan's massive T20I world record, become first team in world to...
This is the biggest mall in Pakistan, built with Rs 315 crore, it is owned by...
Anil Ambani's Reliance Group sets up new centre, to play a key role in...
BIG win for Mukesh Ambani, Dubai-based siblings to transfer Jiohotstar.com domain to Reliance for...
India's largest govt bank loses Rs 34984 crore in 4 days due to...
Donald Trump, Elon Musk's relationship could break over THIS country, it is...
Why do you experience heartburn, diarrhoea during periods? Here's how to manage it
Vande Bharat passenger finds insects in meal, Railways takes action, imposes fine of Rs...
Who is Mojtaba Khamenei? Ali Khamenei's son elected as Iran's next leader
Naga Chaitanya and Sobhita Dhulipala’s wedding card LEAKED online: couple to tie the knot on…
IIM Indore student gives tour of hostel room to her nani, watch heartwarming video
'Your input is...': Nirmala Sitharaman’s response to X user requesting 'relief' for middle class
Caught on camera: Horse kicks woman off scooty on busy road, watch viral video
Here's how you can travel with your dog on Indian Railways: Check step-by-step guidelines
BJP forms 12-member manifesto committee for upcoming Delhi assembly polls
Lyricist Jaani reveals his real name for the first time, it is...
Gold is priced cheaper in India than UAE, Qatar, Oman, and Singapore, reason is...
Madhya Pradesh: Gwalior vendor attacked with super glue, his eyes and lips sealed; probe underway
Delhi Minister Kailash Gahlot resigns from AAP: 'Embarrassing and awkward controversies like...'
Manoj Bajpayee was mistaken for having liquor before shooting, then this happened
Viral video shows woman in saree dancing alongside moving car, leaves netizens awestruck, watch here
From F-35s to Fairways: Will Trump's second term be defined by arms deals and Arabian villas?
Kanguva review: Suriya, Disha Patani, Bobby Deol's film is no Baahubali
Anil Agarwal reveals next BIG plan of Vedanta, set to increase production in...
Elon Musk announces future of ultra-fast travel, claims US to India trip will just take...
Adnan Sami went from 220 kg to 75 kg in just 16 months by leaving THESE 4 things
'We ran out of missiles': US fighter pilots recall countering Iranian attack on Israel
Shillong Teer Result TODAY November 17, 2024: Check lucky winning numbers
DNA Explainer: Why are millions switching from Elon Musk's X to Jack Dorsey's Bluesky?
12-yr-old boy illustrates Bhagavad Gita verses with 84,426 pics, creates record
Manipur violence: Protesters attack residence of CM, 2 ministers, 3 MLAs; curfew imposed