ANALYSIS
A small group of PIOs, Queen Victoria’s frozen-in-time children, imagine they must save India from Indians
In the 1970s and ‘80s, school children were often asked to write essays on ‘brain drain,’ mournfully referring to people who secured degrees in India, and then migrated to foreign lands to reap the benefits of their education, without any payback to the nation that invested in them. Many of these migrant Indians still retain their Indian passport, which legally connects them to their homeland. We call them Non Resident Indians (NRI). Others gave up their Indian passport, cutting the umbilical chord, choosing to be American citizens, for example, taking the US Oath of Allegiance that demands they abjure all relationship with foreign sovereign powers. These are the Persons of Indian Origin (PIO).
Most PIO and their children, look back at India nostalgically, and do connect with India mainly for religious reasons. However, a tiny group of PIO feels dissatisfied in the foreign land of their choice. It has not delivered on its promise. So they seek a new purpose. They look back to the land they abandoned, and have decided its time they save India from Indians. These are the Bharat Tyagis, who claim to be more Bhartiya than resident Indians, despite abandoning Bharat Mata. Bharat Tyagis find India messy and dirty, mismanaged by its democratic process, and feel technology will save the land, and of course, chest-thumping jingoism. They blame reservation policies for this, and Left liberalism, and Nehru. This is why they migrated out, they say defensively when asked about their passport. With little or no memory of the land they left behind, they imagine India as a Hindu land, where cows are worshipped, where there is no discrimination based on caste or gender, where Muslims are invaders who destroyed pure Hindu culture a thousand years ago. They spend every waking hour cursing American academicians who they see as conspiring to divide India. Anyone who disagrees with them is an anti-national, especially those with Indian passport.
On enquiry, you realise most of them studied engineering in India before migrating. So they generally have a poor understanding of the humanities, especially history and geography, a subject that they ingored in school in the pursuit of science and mathematics, and encountered later only when they made millions of dollars to retire.
Exposure to the ground reality of India has naturally horrified them. Rather than facing it, they have gone into denial, and assault. The only reason anyone gives them any importance is because of their nuisance value, flooding internet with their hate-filled snarly misogynistic casteist supremacist tweets, spam mails and Facebook comments.
There is no doubt that some of American interpretation of Indian history and culture is problematic. But it is an American perspective. Like all perspectives, it cannot be perfect. Just as the British reading of India was not perfect. The colonial scholars understood India such that it justified their rule. Likewise, American academicians understand India such that it ensures their tenureship, which means they have to indulge America’s saviour complex by showing the rest of the world as full of victims and villains.
When the British encountered India’s tantrik past, Queen Victoria did not find it amusing and saw it as proof that the natives needed civilising. And so her embarrassed Indian subjects went out of their way to sterilise its mythology, preferring the abstractness of Vedas to the sensuality of its epics. These were Victoria’s children. Nehru was one of them, and Gandhi, embarrassed by images of the Khajuraho, until Rabindranath Tagore drilled in some sense. Today when American academicians refer to this tantrik heritage, and analyse it the way that makes sense to them, it horrifies the Bharat Tyagi, who is essentially Victoria’s child frozen in time. They hiss at the academics and spew venom at them for being Hinduphobic (which they well might be). Living far from India, having breathed American air for long, they forget that Indians who live in India in the 21st century have the maturity and the confidence to speak of India’s Vedic and tantrik roots, ascetic and sensual traditions, on their own terms, without being defensive, or apologetic, or seeking the approval of the Americans.
Devdutt Pattanaik is author of Olympus: an Indian retelling of Greek myths.
Russia plans to boost birth rate with 'Ministry of Sex', here's how
Jharkhand HC issues notice to MS Dhoni in business deal case, asks him to...
IND vs SA, 3rd T20I Dream11 prediction: Fantasy cricket tips for India vs South Africa match
Meet IAS officer, aka 'Collector Bro', who cracked UPSC exam in 2007, now suspended due to...
Here’s why Chunky Panday wouldn’t stay in Shah Rukh Khan’s house in London
Yash's Toxic in trouble? FIR filed against producers of KGF star's upcoming actioner for illegal...
Meet Dr Priti Challa, Kangana Ranaut film director Krish Jagarlamudi's second wife, she leads...
Yaariyan actor Himansh Kohli ties the knot with mystery girl in Delhi temple, first wedding pics out
‘Sometimes I wish I was more tough, more thick-skinned,’ says Aishwarya Rai in viral video
KL Rahul sweats hard in Perth nets ahead of BGT series, WATCH video here
Shahid Kapoor, wife Mira Kapoor rent out their Rs 580000000 luxury Mumbai apartment for Rs...
South Korean actor Song Jae-rim dies at 39 in Seoul apartment
Viral video: Thar SUV gets stuck on railway track after man tries to shoot reel, watch here
Elon Musk's new X post claims Putin must not be blamed for Russia-Ukraine war, instead names…
Fabulous Lives vs Bollywood Wives fame Shalini Passi reveals 'Mom used chilli powder in my...'
My experiences with dating apps
Zomato CEO Deepinder Goyal reveals how company got its name, says 'we wanted…'
Key Differences Between the Indian Stock Market and Global Indices
Stock prices vs company valuation: Is your stock worth it?
Navjot Singh Sidhu is back on Kapil Sharma's show after five years, but there's a twist
Mukesh Ambani set to invest Rs 65000 crore in THIS Indian state, it will be Reliance's biggest...
Mohammed Shami to return to competitive cricket; star pacer set to play for…
Makoons World School brings a new approach to K-12 education across India
Pakistan Cricket looking to take BIG step on Champions Trophy issue, planning to...
Did Isha Ambani lend Neetu Kapoor her Navratna necklace? Reddit users react
J-K: Gunfight underway between security forces and terrorists in Bandipora
Viral video shows women as 'live mannequins' in mall, sparks fury; WATCH
As Vistara bids goodbye, Air India-Vistara's first flight takes off from Mumbai to...
GATE 2025 Schedule: Exams to begin from February 1; Check full timetable here
CBSE announces BIG changes in Class 10,12 board exams 2025, know details here
Veteran Bengali actor Manoj Mitra dies at 86
Isha Ambani graces Diwali party as she walks with her twins, husband, WATCH
Donald Trump plans to pick Marco Rubio as US Secretary of State: Report
Vadodara IOCL refinery fire: Death toll rises to 2; probe underway
Shah Rukh Khan death threat: Mumbai police arrest accused from Chhattisgarh's Raipur
Delhi reports record high chikungunya, malaria cases in 5 years
Japan's Nara deer's polite bow to Indian woman leaves netizens in awe, WATCH
Meet MS Dhoni’s sister Jayanti Gupta who works as teacher, is married CSK star's...
Pakistani TikTok star Minhal Malik's popularity soars in India, sees unprecedented 100-time surge
Seo Hyun Jin dramatically apologises to BTS ARMY, says 'I know a lot of...'
Amid threats of violent protests, Brampton Triveni temple cancels event
Mike Waltz, India caucus head, named Donald Trump's National Security Advisor
Mukesh Khanna returns as Shaktimaan, 90s kids dance with joy
This Indian man owns a train, he's not Mukesh Ambani, Gautam Adani, has net worth of...
SSC CHSL Exam 2024 admit cards to be released today at ssc.gov.in; get direct link here
‘He will play his last game in…’: CSK CEO provides massive update on MS Dhoni’s IPL future