ANALYSIS
Their principal task ought to be to create and manage infrastructure, including electricity, water, roads, and maintain defence and essential services. In addition, governments also spend on education, healthcare, and employment generation.
Is my sop better than yours? No. Actually, all sops are bad for the system. They make a virtue out of government “giving,” masking bad governance with the fake varnish of charity. The government does not own the wealth of the nation, let alone create it. By virtue of the power we vest in it, which comes from the social contract between citizens those we elect to administer it, governments spend money on our behalf for the general welfare of the nation. Their principal task ought to be to create and manage infrastructure, including electricity, water, roads, and maintain defence and essential services. In addition, governments also spend on education, healthcare, and employment generation.
So far so good. But when governments start doling out money to the needy, they are not only overstepping their role, but also dangerously tampering with the notion of citizens’ responsibility. Redistributing money in this manner is the worst example of a nanny state; it encourages citizens to become passive and dependent. In a word, it is against every conceivable idea of Swaraj. That resonant word, not only redeployed by Mahatma Gandhi and Sri Aurobindo, but earlier by Lokmanya Tilak and Dadabhai Naoroji, provided not just the blueprint of independent India, but the vision of a just and virtuous society. The latter would be made up of highly evolved, self-regulating, and compassionate individuals. Such a society would not need an obsessively interfering government, whether of the mai-baap or of the big brother variety. Its informed and self-reliant citizenry would take care not only of their own and their family’s problems, but also the problems of their neighbourhood, village, even of the state and nation.
A government which overtaxes its populace, then justifies its incompetence or profligacy by handing out concessions, allowances, and benefits to some section or the other is nothing short of despotic if not corrupt. No government can usurp the citizens’ right to their own charitable dispositions by determining how or whom to benefit. “Nyay,” the latest of such ideas may go by the wonderfully noble sounding “minimum income” or “universal basic income” scheme but is only disguised socialism which will prove disastrous to India.
Does this mean that the poorest of the poor should not have a safety net or that governments must do nothing to ameliorate their lives? Not at all. But the basic guarantee should be not to income but to work: any able bodied person who is willing to labour for a living should not lack in the basic necessities of life. In other words, no work, no pay.
Instead, if the poor receive cash injections each month, we are going to see not a drastic reduction but a drastic rise in their numbers. Mainlining doles in this fashion will produce a nation of allowance addicts. Everyone, no matter how well-off, wants state benefits in India. Let’s not forget how the wealthy and powerful Farooq Abdullah, National Conference leader, refused to give up his LPG subsidy. Given how difficult it is to determine who is really poor and how easily certificates may be obtained, such a scheme is sure to be misused from its very inception. This will lead to a growing burden on the exchequer and progressive worsening of our economy, what with our growing population and shrinking employment. Government will end up printing notes, leading to rising inflation ballooning deficits, and decline of the real purchasing power of the very money handed out. It will also encourage poverty-mongering among high reproduction low income groups, leading to reverse eugenics. Incentivizing neediness and parasitism, in turn, will foment social division and resentment among hardworking sections of the populace.
But the worst effects of the proposed “Nyay” would be to send the wrong message to Indians. The universal belief among the Chinese is that if you don’t work you don’t eat. This is mostly true for all ages and climes — rich or poor, young or old, free or imprisoned. No one is exempt from this work ethic.
Even in extremely rich countries like Singapore, where the government has enough surpluses to feed the entire population for years even if they stopped working, this “Oriental” norm of earning one’s daily bread persists.
In India, on the other hand, a sizeable number of us are not only habitual, but conniving shirkers of work. It is not because we are born lazy, but because we have been spoiled by externally imposed notions of deprivation and entitlement. The BJP’s own PM-KISAN Samman Nidhi scheme teeters dangerously on the edge of giving out free money. But “Nyay” throws fiscal and moral caution entirely to the winds. It is likely to ruin the nation if it is allowed to be implemented.
Author is Director, IIAS, Shimla Views are personal
DNA TV Show: Ahead of Maharashtra poll results, MVA, Mahayuti engage in resort politics
Maharashtra: Stage set for assembly poll results; Mahayuti, MVA confident of their victories
All set for vote counting in Jharkhand tomorrow; NDA, JMM-led alliances confident of winning
Watch: Australia star inquires Rishabh Pant about his next IPL team, gets 2-word reply
Shah Rukh Khan’s house Mannat was first offered to his industry rival…, but he refused because...
The Visionary Who Promises a Blue Sky for India: Holger Thorsten Schubart’s G20 Climate Speech
The Surge of High-End Living: Luxury Residential Market to Outpace Other Segments
FeFCon 2024 to be Held in Bangalore: A Premier Event on Fever Management
'That’s wild': Noida man turns cigarette butts into teddy bears in viral video, watch
London Airport evacuates passengers over security threat, thousands stranded
The World’s First Innovative Iron Supplement to Combat Iron Deficiency and Anaemia
Meet grandmother who became fashion icon after trying on her granddaughter’s clothes
IND vs AUS: Rishabh Pant joins Virat Kohli, Rohit Sharma in elite WTC list, becomes 3rd Indian to...
'All scripted drama...': Puneet Superstar allegedly assaulted by influencers in viral video, watch
Actress Ana de Armas caught kissing Cuban President Miguel Díaz-Canel’s son in viral photos
Oreshnik's Shadow: Will Russia's hypersonic missile force west to back down?
‘You’re So Beautiful’: World’s tallest woman meets world’s shortest woman over tea, pics go viral
Delhi-NCR Air Pollution: Consequences of GRAP-4 are drastic, may have adverse effects, says SC
Delhi-NCR Air Pollution: Schools likely to stay closed till..., check city-wise update
Maharashtra: 3 killed, 9 hospitalised after gas leak at fertiliser plant in Sangli
THIS farm is selling a cup of coffee for Rs 28000, but there's a twist, it is...
Chhattisgarh: 10 Maoists killed after encounter with security personnel in Sukma
Mukesh Ambani's SUPERHIT plan for Jio users, offers unlimited 5G access for 1 year for just Rs...
IND vs AUS 1st Test: KL Rahul's dismissal sparks DRS controversy in Perth Test
Dense fog, heavy rain predicted in these states till November 25; check here
Oreshnik Hypersonic Missile: Which nations are within its range?
Bihar teacher, principal reach school in drunken state; know what happened next
'I have faced a lot of...': Arjun Kapoor REVEALS his biggest fear amid break up with Malaika Arora
How millions of Indians may get affected due to US indictment of Gautam Adani in bribery case
Amid divorce rumours with Aishwarya Rai, Abhishek Bachchan says 'missing someone is okay but...'
After Bibles, watches and sneakers, Donald Trump is now selling autographed guitars, price is...
Delhi pollution: Air quality improves to ‘very poor’ category, AQI at...
Vladimir Putin's BIG threat, warns he could strike UK with new ballistic missile if...
Shillong Teer Results TODAY November 22, 2024 Live Updates: Check winning numbers here
Somebody misbehaved with Alia Bhatt on Highway sets then Imtiaz Ali had to...
Zomato CEO Deepinder Goyal reveals twist behind Rs 200000 job fee, closes application window
Days after Ratan Tata's demise, Tata Group's Rs 131000 crore company inks pact with ADB for...