INDIA
If the 1962 war with China gave Jawaharlal Nehru a bloody nose, of larger relevance to the country was the bigger defeat he was repeatedly handed out by his own bureaucracy.
He wanted the institution of chaprasis abolished, but the Sixth Pay Commission is still talking of eliminating them
NEW DELHI: If the 1962 war with China gave Jawaharlal Nehru a bloody nose, of larger relevance to the country was the bigger defeat he was repeatedly handed out by his own bureaucracy. Nehru’s war on wasteful government spending, pomp, ostentation and feudal labour practices failed to produce the desired results.
Not for want of trying, though, as the recently declassified documents of the Nehru era show. These documents, numbering around 50, were moved to the National Archives in Delhi over the past two years. DNA was the first to gain access to them, and the research has yielded gems of information and insight into Nehru’s broad vision and how it floundered on the rocks of babudom.
Nehru believed that Delhi’s palatial bhavans should be put to public use, and not used by public servants. In a communication on July 19, 1947, to Lord Mountbatten, the last viceroy and first governor general of independent India, Nehru said: “I have no doubt that in future we should have to use these enormous houses for some other purpose.” He was referring to Rashtrapati Bhavan, then called Viceroy’s House, and the Viceregal Lodge in Shimla, summer residence of the viceroy. In another file, Nehru remarks that he was himself living in a huge mansion (Teen Murti Bhavan) which wasn’t necessary.
While the viceregal lodge was converted into the Indian Institute of Advanced Studies in the 1960s, Rashtrapati Bhavan, atop Raisina Hill, continues to be occupied by the president of India and his/her family. Today, it is the biggest residence used by any democratically elected leader on the face of the earth.
But the most telling example is his failed battle to end the colonial practice of having chaprasis (peons) hanging around government offices. Nehru wanted peons to be phased out and replaced with a messenger service to carry communications between ministries.
The story begins soon after independence. In a missive to the home ministry dated April 11, 1949, Nehru writes: “I have frequently drawn attention to the general appearance of disorder and uncleanliness in the secretariat corridors.
There has been no improvement at all. A part of this lack of tidiness and decorum is due to the hordes of chaprasis who lounge about these corridors. It seems to me clear that the present system is a wrong one, apart from being inefficient.”
His controversial secretary MO Mathai added weight to his master’s voice on the matter of peons. He wrote: “I cannot understand why I have been inflicted with two chaprasis.” But Mathai was clear that doing away with his own chaprasis wasn’t the answer: “It serves no useful purpose in dispensing with my poor chaprasis alone. The whole flat should be cleared and the arrangements suggested by Mr Zachariah might be given a trial.” K Zachariah, head of the historical intelligence section of the external affairs ministry, had apparently studied the messenger system in the US and UK and made recommendations in this regard.
But babus know how to talk a subject to death. Detailed notes and memos were exchanged between the PMO and various ministries, and the proposal generated more paperwork rather that results. Committees and sub-committees were set up, and reports went back and forth for months.
But when Nehru reviewed the situation two years later, he found that the number of peons – far from going down – had actually multiplied.
In a note to the cabinet secretary dated June 24, 1952, Nehru noted with consternation that the number of peons in service had increased from “3,200 before the war to over 19,000”. This was a prodigious number and Nehru again emphasised: “No one should have a personal peon.” But, “in spite of my repeated attempts, nothing appears to have been done in this matter.”
Realising that he may be losing the battle in committee, Nehru reiterated that he wanted greater efficiency and “this process of engaging additional peons to stop.” He wrote to the cabinet secretary seeking information on “what the present number of peons is and how does it compare with the number three years ago. Have any new peons been engaged during this period in spite of our decision some time ago?”
In a telling sign of the nepotism that began to strangle Indian politics, Nehru says: “It is absurd to attach a crowd of peons to a minister or a senior official. Every new appointment means a crowd of hangers-on. It is likely that in the course of a week or two we may have additional ministers. I do not want new peons to be engaged. If necessary, some of my peons should be transferred to them.”
However, the babus had other ideas. They were planning the opposite – add more peons to the PM’s secretariat, the boss’s own den. In 1954, officials were proposing an increase in staff strength, including 10 new peons. In this file, one of the bizarre arguments given by BN Kaul, official in the PMO, was that peons were overworked and some were even falling victim to TB due to this. “I am also told that the strain is so heavy on the peons that there have been four cases of TB among them since the reduction of staff started in 1950, and one of these has unfortunately died. We, therefore, propose that we should have 10 more cycle peons.”
Nehru was apoplectic when he returned from a high-profile visit to China. On November 11, 1954, he wrote a stinker to Mathai: “Ten peons produce a sense of shock in me. I want to abolish the whole institution of peons, and I hope I shall succeed.” He dismissed the TB argument. “I am really surprised to learn that peons have got TB because of excess of work. I do not think anyone gets TB because of excess of work. There must be other reasons.”
Somewhere along the way, Nehru must have given up trying. Today, the Sixth Pay Commission has gone on record to say that class IV employees need to be phased out. But can a coalition government without spine succeed where Nehru didn’t?
Tata-BSNL partnership promises BIG relief for customers, set to provide fast internet in...
'This is pathetic, disgusting': Nia Sharma faces backlash for promoting 'vagina tightening' tablets
Big move by Gautam Adani: Ambuja Cements to acquire this cement brand for Rs 8100 crore
Why US Presidential Election is always held on first Tuesday in November?
'Perfect for him': Aamir Khan in talks to play Kishore Kumar in Anurag Basu's film; fans react
After calling Prabhas a 'joker', Arshad Warsi says 'everyone is allowed to...'
BRICS Summit Prelude: India and China move to defuse border tensions
Sakshi Malik’s BIG claim, says BJP's Babita Phogat wanted to be WFI chief, encouraged wrestlers to…
India launches its 4th nuclear-powered submarine, set to play major role in…
Uttar Pradesh: 6 killed in oxygen cylinder blast in Bulandshahr house
Why Kriti Sanon used to be called 'Tiger didi'? Actress reveals reason
'Zyada Hero Ban Raha Hai': Rohit Sharma's chat with teammate caught on stump mic, video goes viral
Prince Narula, Yuvika Chaudhary share FIRST photo of their daughter
Delhi AQI October 22: Air quality in ‘very poor’ category, Centre imposes GRAP Stage II from today
Man who threatened Salman Khan, demanded Rs 5 crore, issues apology: 'It was...'
Karni Sena announces Rs 1,11,11,111 for any police officer who kills Lawrence Bishnoi
US Presidential Elections 2024: Republican Donald Trump sued for defamation by Central Park Five
‘Will be able to…’: EAM S Jaishankar explains India, China patrolling deal along LAC
'Even double standards are...': Jaishankar's big attack on Canada amid diplomatic row
Hyundai Motor India IPO listing today: All you need to know about largest-ever IPO in India
Diwali Gift: THIS company gave Tata, Maruti cars to its employees ahead of festival, they cost Rs…
IMD issues alerts as Cyclone Dana approaches, heavy rainfall predicted for these states
RSMSSB Rajasthan CET 12th-level exam starts today, check guidelines here
DNA TV Show: Terror threat in Delhi after Rohini blast? Police tighten security ahead of Diwali
Taylor Swift suffers wardrobe malfunction on stage during her Miami concert, video goes viral
Ruturaj Gaikwad to lead India A squad for Australia tour; Ishan Kishan in, Shreyas Iyer misses out
THIS was going to be Aishwarya Rai's first film in Hindi but it didn't release because...
Meet woman, born in Pakistan, attempted suicide at 22, now leads Rs 1 lakh crore company, she is...
IPL 2025: This star overseas player likely to be KKR's top retention over captain Shreyas Iyer
Deepinder Goyal's Zomato clarifies on 'Continue', says 'Not venturing into...'
This company paid Rs 1328 crore tax to move its headquarters to India from US, it works in...
Meet man who works in Rs 1617003 crore company, now set to lead Walt Disney as...
Tata Group set to construct landmark building to honour Ratan Tata in...
Kagiso Rabada achieves massive feat, becomes first cricketer in the world to...
Elon Musk is offering over Rs 5000 per hour for THIS job, it requires you to be...
Steps To Select The Best Term Insurance With a Term Plan Calculator
IRIS Home Fragrances Introduces a Fresh New Range of Four Exquisite Diwali Gift Sets
Mukesh Ambani's next BIG step, set to challenge Elon Musk in…
Vasan Bala breaks his silence on Jigra's box office failure: 'Alia Bhatt could have...'
Meet man who began his career with Tata Motors, now runs Rs 2690 crore company, married to...
'Ye ek PR activity...': Flying Beast breaks silence on divorce rumours with wife Ritu Rathee
Mohammed Shami gives massive injury update ahead of Border-Gavaskar Trophy, says, ‘my fitness is…’
'Quit if you don't want to return...': Amazon AWS CEO Matt Garman warns staff
Indian Railways announces rescheduling, regulation, and restoration of trains due to...
How can Rohit Sharma-led India qualify for WTC final after losing against New Zealand in 1st Test?
Beyond Rumors: Adichunchanagiri Mutt's enduring contributions to Karnataka and beyond
Setback for Anil Ambani's company, NCLT dismisses plea to block use of...
India, China reach agreement on patrolling arrangements along LAC ahead of BRICS Summit
Will MS Dhoni play in IPL 2025? CSK CEO gives major update, says...
Zomato CEO Deepinder Goyal sets up new company with an eye to expand in...
'Want to put culprits on no-fly list': Aviation Minister on amending safety rules amid hoax calls
When is Ahoi Ashtami in 2024? Check date, subh muhurat, significance of this sacred fast