INDIA
A parliamentary panel that probed the prospects and effects of genetically modified (GM) food crops has found a nexus between the industry and political class pressuring scientists to hurriedly introduce these crops in India for reaping a commercial harvest.
A parliamentary panel that probed the prospects and effects of genetically modified (GM) food crops has found a nexus between the industry and political class pressuring scientists to hurriedly introduce these crops in India for reaping a commercial harvest.
The committee also felt there was a link between the suicides of farmers in Yavatmal district of Maharashtra and the failure of Bt cotton crops to provide the desired yields.
Deposing before the parliamentary committee, Dr PM Bhargava, the Supreme Court nominee on the government’s Genetically Engineering Approval Committee (GEAC), said the government was reluctant to set up a lab of its own to conduct all the tests, currently done by the companies themselves, and there was also pressure to swiftly approve Bt brinjal and other crops.
Even Dr Arjula Reddy, chairman of the expert committee that approved Bt brinjal on October 14, 2009, now says he was under pressure from the industry and from a minister. “I am under pressure. I had calls from the industry, the GEAC and the minister,” Dr Bhargava quoted Reddy as telling him in a confidential conversation.
The chairman of the parliamentary committee Basudev Acharia, who tabled its report in the Lok Sabha on Thursday, refused to disclose the name of the minister. He didn’t even explain why Dr Reddy was not summoned for deposition.
Dr Bhargava, also a founder-director of the Centre for Cellular and Molecular Biology, said top scientists Dr Raj Paroda and Dr Mashelka were reluctant to set up a lab where tests could have been done rather than relying on the company for doing tests. He said, “They (scientists) were under pressure not to set up a lab. Can you believe that a country like India with all technological advancements does not have a lab of its own to conduct tests?”
The committee also wondered how the regulatory bodies missed the 30% increase in toxic alkaloid content in Bt brinjal and approved it for environmental releases. Expressing lack of confidence in the regulatory mechanism, the panel said not only was there a conflict of interest in the GEAC, but it has also shown a complete lack of concern towards its responsibility. “Rather it conveys in unequivocal terms its strong inclination towards the benefit of industry. The committee, therefore, recommends the government to not leave such a crucial decision in the hands of GEAC, but come up with clear-cut policy in this regards without any further loss of time,” the report concludes.
The committee has asked the government to immediately bring in legislation to ensure biosafety in the light of modern biotechnology. Recommending emulation of the Norwegian law, which has incorporated safeguards to a large extent, the panel warns that the tearing hurry would lead the agriculture sector to meet the similar fate as that of communications, pharmaceuticals and mineral wealth, where the government’s benevolence has led a colossal loot and plunder.
The report said against an average Rs 8,000 to Rs 12,000 investment for cultivating traditional varieties of cotton per acre, the farmers in Vidharbna region of Maharashtra had to now invest Rs 48,000 to Rs 54,000 per acre for Bt cotton varieties. It has asked for a thorough probe to track the decision making involved in commercial release of Bt Cotton right from the initial stage.
Mahindra's plan to pick up 50% stake in this European company stalled due to...
Relief for Malayalam actor Siddique as SC grants anticipatory bail in rape case
Meet woman who rejected high-paying job offer from abroad, cracked UPSC exam with AIR...
Banks Holiday November 2024: Banks to remain closed in THIS state tomorrow, know why
Israeli airstrike hits central Beirut near key government buildings and embassies
'Glad to have met...': PM Modi meets Italian PM Meloni on sidelines of G20 Summit
Shillong Teer Results TODAY November 19, 2024 Live Updates: Check lucky winning numbers
Nayanthara Beyond The Fairytale: Who is Nayanthara's ex-lover who asked her to quit cinema?
This stray dog becomes popular among tourists after it climbs Giza Pyramid, watch
Savarkar defamation case: Pune court summons Rahul Gandhi on December 2
IND vs AUS: Virat Kohli aims to surpass Cheteshwar Pujara in elite Border-Gavaskar Trophy list
‘He'll be very…’: Sunil Gavaskar warns Australia of Virat Kohli ahead of BGT 2024-25
Meet woman who turned family business into Rs 8500 crore empire, not from IIT, IIM, she is...
Meet woman, who cracked IIT and UPSC exam in same year, became IAS officer, was inspired by...
Delhi pollution soars to highest level, AQI breaches 500-mark
Ex-Maharashtra minister Anil Deshmukh injured after car attacked with stones in Katol
Kanguva box office collection day 5: Suriya, Disha Patani, Bobby Deol film earns Rs 56 crore
'Always a delight': PM Modi meets Joe Biden at G20 Summit in Rio de Janeiro
Air pollution: SC orders closure of classes 10, 12 in Delhi-NCR, Grap 4 restrictions imposed
Gangster Lawrence Bishnoi's brother Anmol Bishnoi detained in US
50 million consumers have stopped buying luxury brands like Dior and Burberry due to...
Swiggy Delivers Big: Hundreds of employees set to become crorepatis overnight, here's how
Elon Musk reacts to his hilarious viral video with Donald Trump, says, 'I am watching myself…'
Hindu Roots in American Politics: Tulsi Gabbard’s trailblazing leadership in US Intelligence
Bangladesh in a tizzy on ‘Crazy Medicine’ ‘Yaba’
Air pollution: SC directs Delhi-NCR states to strictly implement GRAP-IV
Meet woman, IAS Officer who studied CS, LLB before taking UPSC exam, secured AIR...
Manipur Violence: Curfew imposed in 7 districts, schools, colleges shut till...
How two young minds from Bhopal are changing India's recycling game?
Samsung Galaxy S25 Ultra India launch: Check expected price, features, and more
Bad news for Amazon, Flipkart as Blinkit launches new services for...
Pakistan pollution: Lockdown in Lahore, Multan as AQI crosses 2000 mark, health emergency in Punjab
Elon Musk wore ‘Omega’ necklace to UFC event sparks online debate, know what it means
Amid Abhishek Bachchan and Aishwarya Rai divorce rumours, both avoid daughter Aaradhya Bachchan's...
Meet Indian-origin CEO who is receiving death threats due to this reason
Cheteshwar Pujara returns to Border-Gavaskar Trophy in THIS new role
Astronomers find largest water reservoir ever, 140 trillion times Earth's total...
Punjab: Samyukta Kisan Morcha, Kisan Mazdoor Morcha announce march towards Delhi on...
IndiGo pilot's cute surprise for wife on flight will make your day, watch viral video
Kanguva: Disha Patani 'was there to look pretty' says producer's wife, angry netizens bash her
Apple iPhone 15 gets massive price cut on Amazon, here's how you can grab this deal
Amazon India's BIG decision, set to move headquarters to this place, will impact…
Day after quitting AAP, Kailash Gahlot joins BJP
Coolie lifts passengers, helps them board train coach through window, video goes viral, watch
Pushpa 2 trailer: SS Rajamouli reviews Allu Arjun's action-drama, calls it...
This is world's longest-running experiment, started nearly 100 years ago, could go on for...
Tata's BIG move, to buy stake in this Apple partner amid reports of new iPhone unit in Tamil Nadu
Brazil welcomes PM Modi with vedic chants and traditional festivities ahead of G20 summit