INDIA
While SC believes there must be some regulation, it is concerned about how it will be implemented.
Supreme Court on Monday expressed willingness to issue directions to curb dissemination of "insulting" jokes against Sikhs through public modes like internet and SMS, but said the key concern was the enforcement of such directives.
"We are not saying that there should not any guideline on the issue, but the question remains as to how these directions will be enforced," a bench comprising Chief Justice T S Thakur and Justices C Nagappan and A M Khanwilkar said. The comments or jokes may be "humiliating and denigrating" to the community, the issue is how to enforce any such direction, the bench observed.
It asked lawyers and Sikh bodies like Shiromani Gurdwara Parbandhak Committee (SGPC), Amritsar, Delhi Sikh Gurudwara Management Committee (DSGMC), Sikh Gurudwara Management Committee from Haryana and Gurudwara Management Committee from Patna Sahib in Bihar to mull over the issue after perusing various reports and materials and come out with their suggestions. "We can pass orders to stop commercial exploitation of such jokes and materials," it said, adding that in private arena, it will be difficult to contain such acts.
"People from Northeast and South also face such kind of harassment and discrimination," the bench observed, adding "even if you are a Kannadiga or a Telugu or a Malayalee, people still call you a Madrasi. This is very insulting". The bench then deferred the hearing on the PIL by four weeks and sought suggestions about the possible directions on such practices and ways to enforce them. Earlier, the court had asked organisations representing the Sikh community to make a united effort in their endeavour to ban jokes on them, rather than being divided in giving suggestions and evolving mechanisms to curb such activity.
"You should be united in the effort rather than divided," it had said while hearing a batch of petitions seeking ban on circulation of jokes on Sikhs. Senior advocate R S Suri, appearing for DSGMC, had said a committee comprising former apex court judges -- Justices H S Bedi, M Y Eqbal and former diplomat Pavan Verma and former bureaucrat M P Bezbaruah, an expert on northeast -- was working and all of them will meet shortly to come out with the guidelines.
The senior advocate had said there was a need for simple guidelines which can be executed and "one final meeting is required." The first PIL on the issue was filed by a woman lawyer, Harvinder Chowdhary, who had then got emotional and spoke about the menace of jokes on the community by referring to the suicide of a boy, who was upset by a joke lampooning the community.
Chowdhary had said she herself has been the victim of being a Sikh, was treated in a discriminatory manner and suffered humiliation. She contended that such jokes were a violation of Sikhs' right to equality and an attack on the dignity of the community. Earlier the apex court had observed that there was a need to sensitise the society from the formative stages.
The Supreme Court, which had asked for suggestions from the committee, had said it can stop jokes when they are circulated for a commercial purpose and it would examine the framing of guidelines to stop circulation of racist or communal jokes in the cyber world. The DSGMC has sought direction to Telecom Ministry to filter websites which targeted Sikh community, on the ground that it was violative of sections 153A and 153B of the IPC. It had said the community was against making and circulating of jokes on Sikhs, Biharis and calling people from Northeastern states by a particular term.
Aishwarya Rai ends rumours of tiff with ‘pa’ Amitabh Bachchan’s family with new post, writes…
Mumbai Metro launches Whatsapp-based ticket service for lines 2A and 7; know steps to avail it
Meet former TCS employee, who even worked in SBI bank, then cracked UPSC exam to become...
India announce squad for New Zealand Test series, Jasprit Bumrah named vice-captain
Tamil Nadu train accident: Mysuru-Darbhanga Express crashes into goods train, several feared injured
DNA TV Show: All about JPNIC controversy and why it's causing political tension in Lucknow?
NC's Omar Abdullah meets LG, stakes claim to form J-K government, swearing-in ceremony on...
IND vs BAN, 3rd T20I: Predicted playing XIs, live streaming details, weather and pitch report
Sharjah-bound Air India Express flight with 150 onboard safely lands in Trichy after reporting…
IND vs BAN, 3rd T20I Dream11 prediction: Fantasy cricket tips for India vs Bangladesh
Combined wealth of India's 100 richest individuals, for first time in 2024, surpasses Rs...
Ozonetel Acquires CloudConnect Communications
Noida Police announce traffic diversions for Dussehra celebrations: Check key routes to avoid
Ratan Tata's millennial friend Shantanu Naidu and his midnight surprise for the industrialist
Indian speedster Mohammed Siraj takes charge as Telangana DSP
Mukesh Ambani’s Diwali dhamaka offer: Get free AirFiber for one year, unlimited internet; here's how
Oil Ignores War: Why Markets Are Calm Amid Middle East Chaos
Amitabh Bachchan receives birthday wishes from Ajay Devgn, Prabhas, Rajinikanth, Kajol, Navya
PAK vs ENG: Pakistan become 1st team to lose Test match by an innings despite scoring 500 plus runs
Noel Naval Tata: Check educational qualification, family tree of new Chairman of Tata Trusts
Rupee hits all-time low against dollar, know why Indian currency fell, which one's strongest
Here's how Shantanu Naidu's midnight birthday surprise for Ratan Tata left him 'visibly awkward'
Nobel Peace Prize 2024 awarded to Japanese organisation Nihon Hidankyo for...
An Ila Arun blockbuster launched THIS actress in Bollywood, everybody in her family is a star
Amid divorce rumours, 'Flying Beast' Gaurav Taneja and Ritu Rathee reunited for daughters?
When PM Modi's one-word SMS to Ratan Tata brought Nano to Gujarat
PM Modi holds bilateral talks with his Laos counterpart Sonexay Siphandone in Vientiane
Meet man, who is behind over 9% surge in Bandhan Bank share price today
Narayana Murthy's next BIG step, Infosys to no longer send job offer letters, the company will...
Vettaiyan Box Office Day 1: Rajinikanth, Amitabh Bachchan's film earns Rs 30 cr
Vishal Tinani awarded for Legal Excellence by Sachin Pilot
Your FAVOURITE car doesn't have steering wheels or pedals, is priced at Rs...
Paytm CEO Vijay Shekhar Sharma deletes post on Ratan Tata after backlash, he said…
Ratan Tata became favourite customer of THIS Mumbai newspaper vendor due to...
Late Ratan Tata talks about his romantic relationships, 'Seriously four times'
Harbhajan Singh predicts this star player will attract bidding war in IPL auction, he is...
TCS mourns the death of veteran industrialist Ratan Tata in this post
'You're not a…': Nitish Kumar Reddy reveals what Gautam Gambhir said before 2nd T20I vs BAN
Bigg Boss 18: Pookie Baba Aniruddhacharya apologises for appearing on Salman Khan show
Mukesh Ambani BEATS Gautam Adani to take top spot on THIS list, his net worth jumps to...
Amitabh Bachchan mourns Ratan Tata's death, writes 'an era...'
'Goa', Ratan Tata's pet dog, bids him emotional goodbye
Happy Maha Ashtami 2024: Top 10 best wishes, messages to share with your loved ones on Durgashtmi
At least 22 killed in airstrikes in central Beirut, 117 injured
Manager sues this bank for Rs 416711420 after getting fired due to...
One flight made Amitabh Bachchan 'Sharaabi', changed his life, made him superstar
Centre declares Hizb-Ut-Tahrir as terrorist organisation for involvement in...
Forbes Billionaires list: Mukesh Ambani gets richer by Rs 23088 crore