LIFESTYLE
Rito Paul tries to figure out what value an increasingly competitive industry here places on credibility.
F**k Dacre. Publish.” Rupert Murdoch uttered these three simple words 28 years ago. In a sense, they epitomise his journalistic philosophy. Lord Dacre was a historian who in 1983 expressed doubt about the accuracy of the Hitler Diaries that were being printed in the Murdoch-owned Sunday Times. As it turned out, the diaries were soon proved to be a clever work of fiction, a complete hoax.
This drive to create a sensation, without so much as a pause to consider the value of the content or its consequences, has been transmitted down the years to various news media acquisitions of Murdoch. It was only a matter of time before they stepped over the line of decency, propriety and law. Or perhaps it was only a matter of time before they got caught.
In July 2009, it emerged that the reporters of News of the World (NotW), a UK tabloid owned by Murdoch, had illegally hacked into the phones of celebrities and politicians. In the subsequent investigations, a closet-full of skeletons tumbled out, including the instance of NotW staffers hacking into the phone of a missing teenager, Milly Dowler. Since then, the Murdoch empire has well and truly been under siege.
Are we different?
The NotW scandal has led to a lot of introspection, among both the purveyors and consumers of news, about the possible Murdochisation of our own media. Even though no overt breakage of the law by the Indian media has come to light, so far, Murdoch’s basic philosophy — that business concerns should be put over ethical ones — apparently has enthusiastic acolytes in sections of the Indian media.
“The journalistic yardstick for success seems to be the number of eyeballs that you can garner,” exclaims Paranjoy Guha Thakurta, a senior journalist and a member of the Press Council of India, a self-regulatory body of the Indian media. “The argument that’s often made is that the media give people only what they want to see. If you take this argument to its logical conclusion, people also want to watch pornography; will the news media start dishing out pornography as well?”
Recently, a former NotW staffer spoke out about the work culture brought into the tabloid by its flame-haired former editor Rebekah Brooks, which led to the use of illegal tactics such as phone-hacking. He talked of how the staff were under intense pressure to deliver scoops at an impossible frequency.
If you’re in the business of sensationalism, then the problem that you face is the lack of sensational news cropping up on a daily basis. This either leads to misrepresentation of news to create sensation, or the use of underhanded, even illegal tactics to generate sensation, both of which fall far short of the ethical tenets of journalism.
A similar erosion of ethics in the Indian media came to the surface when the Radia tapes scandal broke in late 2010, exposing the seamy nexus between journalists, corporate lobbyists and politicians. The Indian media came under the scanner and the debate revolved around the deference of some of the country’s top journalists to the whims of the rich and powerful, in return for access or more. The argument made by the accused, in their defence, was that they needed to cozy up to the politicians to do their jobs, which presumably was to get access to news and report it. The question that needs to be asked is: what does this do to the credibility of the media and what importance does that have even from a business point of view?
Subhash Chandra, chairman of the Essel group which owns the Zee media network and also has a stake in Diligent Media, the publisher of DNA, says, “Credibility is what the viewer or reader of media wants. Unless there is credibility you won’t have viewers or readers. So I’m of the view that credibility for the media is very important and has to be maintained.”
This is not an easy precept to follow in the current environment, however. Speaking on condition of anonymity, one of the senior-most television journalists in the country says, “When channels which spend time, money and effort in reporting on real issues with half-hour shows find themselves competing with in-your-face tabloid-style reporting interspersed with Bollywood gossip and skin shows, and begin to lose the TRP war, it leaves you with two options: either you happily watch your advertisement revenue walking away to the competitor, or you jump in and play by his rules. Market forces often ensure you choose the latter.”
The race for ratings
If it’s viewership that determines content, then does the final responsibility lie with the consumer of news? Are we, as consumers of news, able to appreciate responsible journalism or are we too enamoured by the flashing lights and high pitch of sensationalism? To a certain extent, the responsibility does lie with the viewer or the reader. However, the problem is also with the metrics used to gauge viewership. Ratings, it seems, is the holy grail of journalism today. “We await Wednesdays with bated breath as TRP figures get released mid-week. Generally, this is what then decides programmes, run-downs, schedules and so much more,” admits Sudhir Chaudhry, Editor and CEO, Live India & Mi Marathi.
But then, given the levels to which Murdoch’s NotW stooped in the UK, who is to say the ratings themselves are bribe-proof? If push comes to shove, TRPs can be manipulated too in the cut-throat competition for ad revenues.
Moreover, a simple TRP doesn’t reveal the level of engagement a viewer has had with the content. In a landmark speech given in 1961, Newton Minow, the then chairman of the US Federal Communications Commission, castigated the heads of the television networks by declaring, “A rating, at best, is an indication of how many people saw what you gave them. Unfortunately, it does not reveal the depth of the penetration or the intensity of reaction, and it never reveals what the acceptance would have been if what you gave them had been better. I believe in the people’s good sense and good taste, and I am not convinced that the people’s taste is as low as some of you assume.”
The Murdochisation of news certainly didn’t start with Murdoch, nor will it end with his much clamoured for demise, if at all that happens. The responsibility lies with every stakeholder of the media.
— Yogesh Pawar contributed to this report
Vishal Tinani awarded for Legal Excellence by Sachin Pilot
Paytm CEO Vijay Shekhar Sharma deletes post on Ratan Tata after backlash, he said…
Ratan Tata became favourite customer of THIS Mumbai newspaper vendor due to...
Harbhajan Singh predicts this star player will attract bidding war in IPL auction, he is...
Ratan Tata, veteran industrialist, passes away at 86, TCS mourns
'You're not a…': Nitish Kumar Reddy reveals what Gautam Gambhir said before 2nd T20I vs BAN
Aniruddhacharya aka Pookie Baba apologises publically after appearing on Bigg Boss 18, watch video
Mukesh Ambani surpasses Gautam Adani, takes top spot on THIS list, his net worth jumps to...
'An era has just passed away': Amitabh Bachchan mourns Ratan Tata's demise, pens an emotional note
Ratan Tata’s pet dog 'Goa' attends his funeral, bids him emotional final goodbye
Happy Maha Ashtami 2024: Top 10 best wishes, messages to share with your loved ones on Durgashtmi
At least 22 killed in airstrikes in central Beirut, 117 injured
Manager sues this bank for Rs 416711420 after getting fired due to...
One flight made Amitabh Bachchan 'Sharaabi', changed his life, made him superstar
Centre declares Hizb-Ut-Tahrir as terrorist organisation for involvement in...
Mukesh Ambani gets richer by Rs 23088 crore in Forbes Billionaires list, his net worth is Rs…
Meet man who began his career at SBI, now set to lead Rs 30246 crore company as...
Happy birthday Amitabh Bachchan: When Bombay To Goa was offered to Rajiv Gandhi and not him
NASA's Hubble Space Telescope spots Jupiter's great Red Spot shaking like...
'It was my...': Javed Akhtar REVEALS reason behind his failed first marriage with Honey Irani
Dawood Ibrahim is scared of me, says Bigg Boss 18 contestant Gunratan Sadavarte
Who is Zarin Daruwala, Standard Chartered's India CEO set to retire in April 2025?
Madhura Naik recalls family's encounter with Hamas militants, says 'it was...’
Big setback for India as Rohit Sharma may miss first Test of Border Gavaskar Trophy in Australia
DSP to IPS officer: Meet woman who cracked UPSC exam in first attempt, her AIR was...
'I would feel like jumping off...': When Mrunal Thakur revealed she had suicidal thoughts due to...
Bigg Boss 18: These five contestants are nominated for eviction in first week of Salman Khan's show
Rohit Sharma meets injured Musheer Khan after accident, pic goes viral
Women's T20 World Cup 2024: How can India qualify for semifinals after 82-run win over Sri Lanka?
When Ratan Tata kneeled down with MBA graduates to pose for photo; see viral pic
Joe Root scripts history in Multan Test, joins Virat Kohli in THIS elite list
Ratan Tata did THIS work in 20 days, but govt took years to do it
PAK vs ENG: Harry Brook breaks Virender Sehwag's 20-year-old record with triple century vs Pakistan
When I Told World Icon Ratan Tata ‘You Are the Real James Bond of the Business Community’: Jay Patel
Good news! UP govt declares public holiday on THIS day; check details
How Ratan Tata's dog 'Goa' got his name, know story behind it
Nobel Prize 2024 in Literature awarded to Han Kang: Who is she?
PAK vs ENG: Joe Root equals Sachin Tendulkar's record with heroics in Multan Test
Daily Habits to Rejuvenate Your Eye Contour
WATCH: Mukesh Ambani, Nita Ambani and family pay homage to Ratan Tata at NCPA
Tennis legend Rafael Nadal announces retirement, ends illustrious career with 22 Grand Slam titles
Virat Kohli's old video singing 'sajna ve sajna' with Harbhajan Singh goes viral again, watch video
Bitcoin creator's true identity exposed in an HBO documentary, he is…
Ratan Tata's influence continues as Tata Group shares including Tata Power, Tata Steel rise
'His loss will be...': Bill Gates shares photo with Ratan Tata, calls him 'visionary leader'
IND vs BAN: Riyan Parag bowls with bizarre action, ends up bowling rare no-ball, watch viral video
ZEE proposes biographical film on Ratan Tata's life as humble tribute to his legacy
Will Samajwadi Party's alliance with Congress continue? SP chief Akhilesh Yadav breaks his silence
From 'Ugly Duckling' to 'White Swan': Kabir Bedi traces Rekha's remarkable journey as she turns 70
Ratan Tata didn’t recognise Amitabh Bachchan while traveling together, superstar then...
An untold story: Here's how Ratan Tata extended unwavering support to victims of 26/11 attack
Another masterstroke by Gautam Adani, plans to raise more than Rs 1,67,92,60,00,000 through…
Beyond Cash and Cards: Rise of AI-Powered Payment
Meet woman, Tata Son's first female director who shaped Ratan Tata's personality, for whom he left…
Hunter's Moon October 2024: When, where to watch biggest supermoon of the year
7th Pay Commission: Good news for central govt employees, 3% DA hike likely to be announced on...
'Would sit and...': When Shah Rukh Khan made Mahima Chaudhary wait for 20 days on sets of Pardes